Any recommendations?
Like eating dark chocolate sat by the embers of a fire while a cold frost takes hold outside.

Mena Dhu
Fullers Porter
Mad squirrel have a couple good ones
Whitstable brewery had a good Porter.
Ghost ship
BananaBread Beer
I can’t stand the plum porters and that sort of thing. Much prefer chocolatey/malty stuff.
I’ve a mate through the bike club that brews in his shed.
He did a porter, it worked out at 13% and was quite honestly the best I have ever tasted.
I’m spoiled now and just want home to make more.
And yes, fruity beer is shite
For the non—alky crowd
https://shop.bigdropbrew.com/collections/best-sellers/products/galactic-milk-stout
(Love non-alky beer. Presently the comfortable end of a drinkable Merlot and a nice whisky)

Home bargains have got a Christmas pudding and custard stout. Yet to try it.
Bristol Beer factory Milk Stout
Stroud brewery Big Cat
Tiny Rebel Stay Puft
Garden brewery loveliness
https://www.beer52.com/shop/product/the-garden-brewery/vegan-milk-stout-garden/3940

Titanic Plum Porter, if you want a change from the coffee/chocolate usual suspects. And fruity enough to count as one of your 5 a day.
St Peters do a similar one as well.
Wild Beer- millionaire
Quantock Breakfast stout
Wiper and True milk stout
Siren- Carribbean chocolate stout (they do a few) also their broken dream.
Kinnegar yanarroddy
Cairngorm brewery had some really great autumn/winter beers on last time I was up in Aviemore. Well worth a look.
Have a look at Honest Brew, they have a decent selection and as far as I am aware they aren't part owner by inbev. Someone may correct me though.
I am brewing a cherry chocolate porter, but shouldn't be too sweet will have a nice balance of maltiness and bitterness. Some of the 'pudding' style stouts are just plain wrong Far far too sweet and sickly.
Pojala Must Kuld
Moersleutel Willy Tonka
Grolsch Winterbok
Siren Broken Dream
Kasteel Nitro Noir
Kees Caramel Fudge
Turning Point Gravedigger's Biscuits
https://www.vocationbrewery.com/collections/core
The imperial kersch (as said above)
Also the Abduction, imperial banana, all souls
All of the above are fantastic don’t do more than 2 cans though 😂
Thornbridge Cocoa Wonderland
https://brightsidebrewing.co.uk/brewery-shop/ millionaire shortbread porter, Inn Crowd dark mild, their Christmas beer is bloody good too
Mena Dhu
Old Peculier
Guinness West Indies Porter
Sainsbury’s London Porter
I think all of these have a ‘winter’ feel to the taste.
igm
Full Member
For the non—alky crowdGalactic
Well that post just cost me 36 quid! £6 off with a code though so I say that's a win!
A couple of years ago I put in some research buying every "Christmas" beer I could find.
90% were just pretty generic bitters with Santa or reindeer on the label and not worth bothering with. But there was one that actually tasted like Christmas pudding. Anyone got any ideas?
Twickenham Milk Stout - pretty much the best thing they do but only from the end of November roughly till it runs out mid December
Howardtown Tiramisu Stout

and Dark Peak Porter.

+1 for the Dark Island, although to paraphrase ‘A Dark Island is not just for Christmas’. A quantity is always consumed on my annual trip to The Gairloch/Poolewe/Ullapool area which is usually in May.
Made me think and I’ll look to see if I can find it locally
If you are ever in the Low Newton Northumberland area, the Sea Coal brewed on the premises is a lovely dark wheat beer.
Yep TINAS I had one like that on draught in the Coach and Horses, Great Brington. Brandy mixed in, the lot. It was so outrageously good I just can't remember what it was (or riding home).
Titanic Plum Porter/Plum Porter Reserve
Spey Valley Spey Stout and Sailor Terry
Beartown Crème Bearlee
One of the good things about living in Todmorden was going to the Golden Lion and trying the stouts sold by the shop at the back. I even had a short-lived stout of the week on Instagram
Dark Star “Imperial Stout”
Long Man “Old Man”
Evil Twin “Even More Jesus”
Brooklyn Brewery “Chocolate Stout”
Amazing stouts.
Tempest Elemental Porter. 5.1%
Tempest Kesennuma Stout. 10.8%
Tempest Sleight Of Hand AF Milk Stout 0% The only AF beer that I actually like.
Fixed Wheel Blackheath Stout. 5%