VisitScotland motor...
 

  You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more

VisitScotland motorhome & campervan survey

172 Posts
47 Users
176 Reactions
960 Views
Posts: 6581
Free Member
 

Scotland sounds like a bloody horrible place to visit now that thousands of people are randomly 'camping' in laybys, outside people's house etc.


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 7:54 pm
Posts: 1911
Free Member
 

Well, really it only sounds like it because this threads gone a bit Daily Mail.


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:00 pm
convert reacted
Posts: 45504
Free Member
 

Scotland sounds like a bloody horrible place to visit now that thousands of people are randomly ‘camping’ in laybys, outside people’s house etc

Yeah. Don't bother coming up, I prefer it quieter. 😜


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:17 pm
Posts: 1844
Full Member
 

Hi Simon, Scotland is a great place to visit. Just pick your time and avoid honeypots, there's plenty of quiet space, avoid school holidays.


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:22 pm
Posts: 1639
Free Member
 

this is where I struggle. I think the roadside campervanning has gone way beyond the point of being acceptable. But ( from previous debates) its really hard to see how you can justify banning roadside camping whether practically or philosophically and leave real wild camping alone

Making wild camping illegal would have very little effect on people actually wild camping rather than doing it within sight of their car. I've never had any bother doing it in England or Wales but then I've only ever done it on my own and away from other people.


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:45 pm
Posts: 3636
Free Member
 

The entitlement some people in rural areas feel they have to live in a beautiful place and have it to themselves, to have jobs and services and money in the area without having to deal with any of the negatives brought by a major source of those things, tourism.

The bagshitter that complained about "de-personalisation" and "bogeymen" also totally invented an argument that literally no-one is making. 🤣

in my view, they would bring in money to the council and provide a revenue stream

This is exactly the trap councils fell into when they started energy companies - they couldn't decide whether the point was to make money for the council (in which case, what makes it different from the existing private providers?) or to provide cheap energy to customers (which is fine, but it's gonna cost money). In the end, most of them ended up doing neither.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-nottinghamshire-54056695


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:48 pm
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

Wild campers offer nothing to the local economy, they pitch up in the ‘wild’ and don’t use local facilities, leave a mess and disturb the wildlife. ‘Van lifers’ park up near towns or pubs, the use the local facilities and bring money to local area and will happily pay a fee to stay in a spot. The environmental impact is no different to wild campers who drive near where they stay, abandon their car taking up spaces where they shouldn’t and cause problems with parking.

Is that enough generalisation?

Reality is both can offer an income to local facilities, both can be sensible and of course there is idiots in both groups who ruin it for those who are respectable.


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:51 pm
snotrag, colournoise, tillydog and 1 people reacted
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

Hi Simon, Scotland is a great place to visit. Just pick your time and avoid honeypots, there’s plenty of quiet space, avoid school holidays.

Spot on.


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:52 pm
Posts: 2701
Free Member
 

Can I go to sleep now (in my motorhome) happy that we’re all friends again, or can be?


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 8:59 pm
Posts: 9783
Full Member
 

Well I shall sleep comfortably knowing I've paid my campsite fees, all be it to some corporate company down south, as well as about the same amount into the local economy.

I always thought that we were all friends on here 🤞

If you work out the turnover on this basic campsite run by two people I'm sure the revenue would be better going into the local community  coffers 🤔


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 9:25 pm
andywnpt, colournoise, Drac and 1 people reacted
Posts: 2880
Full Member
 

No. Sadly not wheels On fire. You’re clearly the scum of society and having the a wrong sort of holiday. You should have checked whether STW approved of your holiday plans / methods before you left home  🙄


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 9:25 pm
lowey and wheelsonfire1 reacted
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

You’re clearly the scum of society and having the a wrong sort of holiday. You should have checked whether STW approved of your holiday plans / methods before you left home

Said no one on this thread.  to deny there are issues is head in the sand.  To look for solutions is reasonable.  to discuss this is fine

"methinks the gentleman doth protest too much"


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 9:42 pm
Posts: 2701
Free Member
 

Ah, on this occasion we’re paying £40 a night for two of us to “The Club”.  I’d much rather go somewhere for a meal but at these prices we’ve nothing left. A lot of the high prices are opportunistic profiteering, it can be £25 a night for a field and a tap, they shut end of September after they’ve made their money. With imagination a community could make some money with overnight pitches for tourist camper vans/motorhomes/caravans.

night night all!


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 9:42 pm
andywnpt, matt_outandabout, tillydog and 4 people reacted
Posts: 6130
Full Member
 

https://campra.org.uk/ 👍 I often wonder how many "experts" know what the costs are to provide and run a site are??


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 10:49 pm
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

£15 to park overnight at the community owned aire in Findhorn. There's a basic toilet (no electricity last time I was there - so take a torch) and somewhere to dump your rubbish. I reckon that's on the limit of a fair charge but I do use it as I know it's going to the community and I'm not pissing off any locals. I usually eat/drink in the village in the evening.

I've seen £25 charges for about the same - I reckon that's taking the piss a bit.

Same campsites are becoming too expensive, though the various tarriffs can be a bit of a minefield. Sometimes it's the same cost for a solo camper as it is for a family, sometimes the charegs for each additional person look extortionate. I really don't know where the balance should be.

I often wonder how many “experts” know what the costs are to provide and run a site are??

I know that the recent lease of the Glenmore site included a substantial ongoing payment to FLS well above the cost of the ground and facilities themselves. They certainly see a profit in it 🙂


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 11:11 pm
Posts: 1846
Full Member
 

Findhorn is a great place so £15 is fair I think. Somehow I have never noticed the toilets there, I haven’t stayed but will give it a try next year. We tend to stay in the caravan on a cl at Nairn which is £40 per week when in that part of the world, I always offer more but they won’t hear of it. Wetow with a small camper so that would be great for a night and we can have an evening at the pub

Picture taken from culbin forrest by Findhorn a couple of weeks ago


 
Posted : 03/08/2023 11:39 pm
Posts: 13134
Full Member
 

The 'just use campsites' argument for not having Aires makes no sense. Its like saying 'why do we need a coffee shop when we have already got a Michelin star restaurant?'. Different product for different people, or maybe the same people but different days. My town is a perfect example of both working well - the local static caravan park has quite a nice motorhome section, seems pretty popular. But it's minimum 3 nights stay and in high season that's £120. Little indoor pool, kids play parks, 'evening entertainment', restaurant. Less than 1/4 mile away is the harbour and campers/mortohomes used to 'wild camp' for free. Locals got a bit peeved and as it's on common good land put in 10 bays for campers and banned overnights unless in the spots. I think it's a tenner a night and for that you get the code for sailing club showers. Very popular. A lot will eat in their vans but others will use the fish and chip shops, or the restaurants. Or a coffee shops. You, know like tourists. But if you are passing through you are just not going to pay for 3 nights if you don't need it or don't want the 'extras'.

The Aires model works well already almost with the caravan club certified sites which are almost the same with some of them virtually a facility free park up.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 8:56 am
andywnpt, Pauly, Simon and 2 people reacted
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

the "aires" model would seem to be the answer but a we can see from this thread some folk do not want to pay (enough) for them)

Edit - no one has said do not build Aires


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 9:02 am
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

Aires is a great idea. There are so few like your example though so little choice but to use sites. Not all sites are £40 a night, I stayed in a lovely one near Alton. That was £25 per night for 2 of us with full facilities on the pitch and lovely clean showers and toilets.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 9:14 am
 Spin
Posts: 7655
Free Member
 

Edit – no one has said do not build Aires

Yes they have, at least one person up thread was arguing that local authorities shouldn't build aires and if local authorities don't do it it's not going to happen.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 9:26 am
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

Sorry - must have missed that post


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 9:28 am
Posts: 259
Free Member
 

Convert hits the nail on the head; if communities find van parking etc to be problematic they can and should take positive action which would benefit all - and just putting up 'no overnight parking' signs isn't really that.  I really like the example he cites.

Where I live in the Dales we don't really have a problem (maybe slight irritation at times); the spot that does get popular (and for good reasons; I'd stop there too) isn't in sight of anyone's house and rarely suffers from dumped rubbish etc. Some locals will moan 'have you seen that lot?' but I always respond that other than a minor temporary visual impact its a bunch of folks enjoying life and hurting no one. We are all tourists sometime eh? And plenty of locals are responsible for questionable visual impact; we may live here, and may own land, but we don't own the right to exclude everyone else 'just because'.  There is a basic 'field and tap' Caravan Club site in the dale but it's not very popular. It's a nice enough spot and I doubt expensive, but I think folks in vans are attached the the idea of just stopping in a nice spot with a good view; a kind of gypsy romantic ideal. I know I do in my van. It's not the money, I just don't like the whole camp site thing.

We drove back from the Hebrides overnight last weekend, and yes there were plenty of vans parked in laybys etc - but generally they really were in the middle of nowhere. Don't sh1t in the bushes, take your rubbish away, and what harm are they doing?

I can't help but feel in many cases it's an example of folks feeling because they spent a gazillion quid on a house they are aggrieved that others can inhabit the same space for free, even temporarily. Clearly there are places it's reached genuine problem levels (I cited Arisaig earlier and stand by that) but those extreme examples can't be allowed to become a panacea for NIMBYs to use.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 9:35 am
andywnpt, Pauly, chickenman and 4 people reacted
Posts: 259
Free Member
 

Another good example of community action on this is at Ulva Ferry on Mull.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 9:36 am
Posts: 3636
Free Member
 

The ‘just use campsites’ argument for not having Aires makes no sense. Its like saying ‘why do we need a coffee shop when we have already got a Michelin star restaurant?’. Different product for different people

Edit – no one has said do not build Aires

I have said councils shouldn't build campsites (whether or not you give them a fancy French name). They also shouldn't build coffee shops just because tourists moan about the price of coffee. If it's such a moneyspinner, local taxpayers can do it. If it's not a moneyspinner, then "people who own expensive diesel vans and want cheaper campsites" are not the top priority for council help.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 10:07 am
peekay and kilo reacted
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

. If it’s not a moneyspinner, then “people who own expensive diesel vans and want cheaper campsites” are not the top priority for council help.

Just as well that’s not what they are after. They want areas where they can park up in for a few nights, better for local businesses if they can attract them, better for locals as that van in a parking space isn’t temporarily ‘blocking’ a space and better for the visitors as they can have somewhere with basic facilities.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 10:38 am
Pauly reacted
Posts: 15907
Free Member
 

Driving back from Shrewsbury towards Welsh land last night I actually passed a couple of cars with roof beds on them, so perhaps this will no longer be the preserve of big white boxes.

I've got nothing against 'Aires' being setup (posh name for a cheap campsite) but as above is it really a priority when councils are struggling to provide basic amenities for health and wellbeing ?

Still looks like simple supply and demand to me, people are not prepared to pay the costs of what things are at the minute, and there just isnt the supply for places to put all these big white boxes.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 10:46 am
 Spin
Posts: 7655
Free Member
 

I’ve got nothing against ‘Aires’ being setup (posh name for a cheap campsite) but as above is it really a priority when councils are struggling to provide basic amenities for health and wellbeing ?

Well I think we can agree on this one.

Highland Council is flat broke and have massively cut additional support needs provision in schools. They've also shut most public toilets in rural areas, those that remain being community run. I think they would really struggle to make the case for invesing widely in aires although the have done at least one.

If it does happen it's likely to be some sort of community lead thing which means they'll probably be few and far between.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:03 am
Drac reacted
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

is it really a priority when councils are struggling to provide basic amenities for health and wellbeing ?

There's a scheme (partially?) funded by ScotGov to improve toilet provision round the Highlands. It's not too much of a stretch to combine both requirements if that can help improve things for locals and tourists alike.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:03 am
Pauly, gordimhor and Drac reacted
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

I can’t help but feel in many cases it’s an example of folks feeling because they spent a gazillion quid on a house they are aggrieved that others can inhabit the same space for free, even temporarily.

IME its not newcomers but folk who have lived there most of their lives who find the disruption difficult.  Its not jealousy or envy - its frustration at the disruption to their lives

Many years ago I asked a chap running a tourist boat up in the highlands about this  his answer " we are glad to see them come, and we are glad to see them go"  Tourism can be very much a double edged sword as folk in tourist cities worldwide can find.  Venice being a particular one and i see this as well in Edinburgh.  The tourist money is a huge part of what makes it such a nice place - but sometimes the sheer numbers of tourists reaches a point where it adversely effects your life.  One wee anecdote.  Julie used to work from an office on the royal mile.  Most of the year she would go out of the office for her lunch - walk to the shops to buy it and sit somewhere nice outside to eat it.  come festival time she would find that even getting out of the office door became difficult and queues in the shops and all the folk milling about meant it took more of her lunch break to buy her lunch and find somewhere to sit to eat it

when we moved to Edinburgh 30 years ago the royal mile still had ordinary shops on it.  Now its all tourist tat shops

What the answer is to this mass tourism effecting the lives of residents is I do not know.  Its a worldwide issue and I have seen no real solutions


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:04 am
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

the answer to the campervan issue in Scotland is IMO twofold - carrot and stick.  Facilities need to be put in place and I am happy with councils doing this so long as the prices are set as to make a profit.  Then once we have a greater range of facilities in place clamp down on the roadside campers - once they no longer have the excuse that all campsites are full / too expensive / inconveniently placed


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:28 am
andywnpt and gordimhor reacted
Posts: 1911
Free Member
 

Yes but remind yourself just how much fun Edinburgh would be if it just had Edinburgh folk in it...:)


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:33 am
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

Indeed - I acknowledged that


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:36 am
Posts: 1911
Free Member
 

I am probably unusual in that I enjoy the buzz of the festival and all the folk stooring about.

I did wonder when the pitchforks came out during lockdown in many highland communities whether they would ever get put away again, looks as if in some places that they haven't.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:47 am
 Spin
Posts: 7655
Free Member
 

clamp down on the roadside campers 

I suspect that this might be harder to do than many people think.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:50 am
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

I am happy with councils doing this so long as the prices are set as to make a profit.

How much have the various Edinburgh councils spent on tourism (including the numerous festivals) over the years without "making a profit"?

How much has been spent on the 7 Stanes without "making a profit"?

There are occasions when investment in facilities/infrastructure has to be seen in a wider context.

During the immediate lifting of Covid restrictions there was a loosening of some planning rules to allow a few (private/community) Aires to go ahead. I wonder if that relaxation still applies, because even planning permission can be an expensive and time-consuming issue.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:54 am
tjagain, gordimhor and Drac reacted
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

I did wonder when the pitchforks came out during lockdown in many highland communities whether they would ever get put away again

Pitchforks are rubbish at picking up faeces.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:57 am
Posts: 3636
Free Member
 

They want areas where they can park up in for a few nights

So..."campsites", then?

when we moved to Edinburgh 30 years ago the royal mile still had ordinary shops on it.  Now its all tourist tat shops

TBF that's half a story about mass tourism and half a story about the decline of shops generally. If it were any other street, you just wouldn't have the tourist tat shops and it'd be vacant shops, discount booksellers, and charity shops. I also have no idea how it can be fixed.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:57 am
Posts: 4899
Full Member
 

Three years ago Police took action after the entrance to Glen Nevis cemetery was blocked and mourners were delayed while the drivers were found and vehicles moved.The area is clearly marked no parking.The following two weeks vehicles parked in the designated area were towed away, some by helicopter I believe.
https://www.scotsman.com/news/crime/police-tow-vehicles-and-charge-drivers-after-visitors-block-roads-near-scotland-beauty-spots-2936888
I would say that this strong action has been effective as the problem hasn't recurred to anything like the same extent since .
So maybe we should be welcoming those who use campsites, aires, etc and park appropriately and those who take the piss(pun intended) should know that if they're caught it's likely to cost them.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 12:03 pm
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

So…”campsites”, then?

A form of yes. Well done on working that out all by yourself.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 12:26 pm
Posts: 259
Free Member
 

In the question of the 'born and bread' locals versus the offcomers/blowins levels of tolerance, what I find (I'm a long term offcomer who works with landowners professionally)  is that the new blood are more rules and regulations focussed; they tend to get excited at people infringing rules. The old blood are more pragmatic; if its sensible and not hurting anyone then fine; legal but still daft or damaging is less tolerated no matter what law is being broken or not. In  a way that mirrors my view on ROW use. It used to be called common sense and respect. There are plenty of footpaths great and suitable to ride, and plenty of bridleways a bike has no place on. Guess what I do 😀


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 1:17 pm
Drac reacted
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

https://news.sky.com/story/drivers-fined-for-ignoring-traffic-restrictions-along-b8008-morar-to-arisaig-route-in-the-scottish-highlands-12932357

I'm conflicted on this one too. We have a very similar situation nearby at Loch Morlich. One answer is to have more car parks, but then there's a knock-on effect that the beach becomes more crowded, taking away part of the attraction (They paved paradise...) . And then when the car park is full, folk still park where they shouldn't.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 2:55 pm
Posts: 3636
Free Member
 

In the question of the ‘born and bread’ locals versus the offcomers/blowins levels of tolerance...

So basically you think the former tend to roll with crumby behaviour on their doorstep, but if someone parks somewhere really barmy, they're toast? Sounds like they're using their loaf by not getting too wrapped up in things.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 3:17 pm
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

Scotroutes - there is the issue in a nutshell.  Its needs to be carrot and Stick IMO.  that area desperately needs somewhere for the vans to park up legally - then enforce the restrictions once you have that.

If it goes too far with the numbers of folk then what tho?  I read that a section of the Amalfi coast where there are lovely little villages and the roads are narrow one section of many miles with a couple of villages has had traffic counters and barriers.  Once a certain number of cars has entered the area the roads are closed.  They had to do this as it was ending in total gridlock.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 3:22 pm
Posts: 16346
Free Member
 

Once a certain number of cars has entered the area the roads are closed.

Same thing happens in national parks in USA and Australia


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 3:38 pm
Posts: 1846
Full Member
 

The main picture in the Sky News link in front of Traigh golf course has shocked me. There is a caravan club CL there which I last stayed in about five years ago and in many summer holiday weeks there I only saw the odd cyclists camping along there and one bloke in a van on a couple of nights.

Some places have really changed


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 3:45 pm
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

Thats the issue.  there is a spot I used a few times many years back.  Never more than one other van.  last time I went past 4 ish years ago - 20 -30 vans in a line


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 4:12 pm
Posts: 1846
Full Member
 

Those vans are parked on the verge of a singletrack road. Surely if the police wanted to be really awkward it would be a case of knock them all up at 2am and breathalyse the occupants. Am I wrong? There are actually over 200 campsite pitches within a mile of that photo, if there is no space at the campsites and you choose to park illegally then I am struggling to sympathise if they choose to get tough.

We actually had our car broken in to at that spot about ten years ago and it was a long wait for the police to arrive and that was before so many subsequent cuts.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 4:22 pm
andywnpt reacted
Posts: 5177
Full Member
 

Case study of 1 so very anecdotal.

I needed to go to South Wales for work and wanted to do The Gap ride. Turned up at about 10pm, parked my van in an fairly large, open air, pay and display car park in Brecon. Free overnight parking, then paid for parking during the day while I was doing the ride. I used the free toilet that was just nearby. Spent some money buying brekky and snacks, put the rubbish in the bin near the car park. Thought it worked rather well. No aire, just a tweak to the rules of the car park


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 4:27 pm
Posts: 4899
Full Member
 

I was at Silversands on Tuesday, dropped people off at the beach, then drove on found a legal parking spot took ten minutes to walk back and join the others. Did shopping at Spar in Arisaig.
I would think long and hard before going to Arisaig on a weekend in July or August


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 4:37 pm
Posts: 2582
Free Member
 

North Berwick weekend choc a bloc with campervans, many park right opposite the water treatment works with it's nice ripe aroma as the look over the Forth then just up the hill the wee carpark it is like some cowboy film where the all park in a circle preventing any day trippers from parking whilst they keep an eye out for the Cherokees
This is every weekend of the year


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 4:54 pm
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

I would think long and hard before going to Arisaig on a weekend in July or August

We were there in May, hoping to go for a swim off Traigh but couldn't get parked without being a dick. We drove along to Rhue and managed to get into a space as someone was just leaving. I reckon a couple of the campsites could add to their income by allowing some day parking.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 7:18 pm
 Spin
Posts: 7655
Free Member
 

Just to bring a bit of ballance to all this doom and gloom...

I've spent most of the last 3 weeks dotting about the Highlands in my van. Mostly on NC500 roads, some day trips, some overnights, some nights in campsites, some just parking up.

Lots of vans around and some busy spots but nothing dreadful. No mess left behind anywhere I've seen and I've been looking.

There are definitely problems in some places but they're localised and the solutions are therefore local. No need for nationwide bans or similar hysteria, just deal with the problems where they occur.


 
Posted : 04/08/2023 11:11 pm
Drac, colournoise and Simon reacted
Posts: 3636
Free Member
 

North Berwick weekend choc a bloc with campervans, many park right opposite the water treatment works with it’s nice ripe aroma 

TBF the smell won't be worse than what's coming from inside the van. And also tbf the local yokels are up in arms about the idea of charging for parking in summer, even though free car parking is destroying the town's major asset - a walkable vibrant high street.


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 12:00 am
Posts: 13134
Full Member
 

I have said councils shouldn’t build campsites (whether or not you give them a fancy French name). They also shouldn’t build coffee shops just because tourists moan about the price of coffee. If it’s such a moneyspinner, local taxpayers can do it. If it’s not a moneyspinner, then “people who own expensive diesel vans and want cheaper campsites” are not the top priority for council help.

You seem to be under the misunderstanding that aires (other fancy and not fancy names available, but people know what the concept is when you use that term) need to or indeed are commonly owned by the council. Some no doubt are, but a lot are either community owned or privately owned. Certainly in rural Highland Scotland 'the council' own very little beyond the edge of the tarmac. Where the council/local government come in is granting licences and they've been notoriously tricky to get hold of. During the COVID staycation explosion they granted a bunch more temporary ones and 'pop up' campsites of the zero facility aires styles appeared for a short while.

Beyond that, yes councils do own carparks in towns obviously and could put a few bays in and monetise them......I mean the concept of paying to park is already a thing but if the solution to the problem was to enable some to legitimately park, make a bit of money from it and get a quota of what's reasonable and sustainable for the community then happy days.

Findhorn is another place that has done this successfully - two sets of public toilets have been renovated and other public works on the proceeds over the last winter.


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 8:39 am
Drac reacted
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

During the COVID staycation explosion they granted a bunch more temporary ones and ‘pop up’ campsites of the zero facility aires styles appeared for a short while.

Northumberland Council has relaxed the rules on pop up campsites for the with spaces for 60 or under. Was a bit late for this season, but talking to a friend who works in planning there’s a lot of interest.


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 8:46 am
Posts: 1846
Full Member
 

Presumably at least life must be getting easier for genuine gypsy travellers, because there can no longer be good justification for moving them on


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 8:52 am
Posts: 70
Free Member
 

People keep mentioning aires,a la French style. Plenty of mayors are selling off their aires to a private company as they just do not make financial sense.Despite providing free,or very low cost facilities,money was still not being spent by the campers in the town or village.

My next door neighbour has a £90,000 motorhome and parks overnight in council car parks. I can't see the enjoyment of looking out over a big piece of empty car park as part of my weekend break.


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 9:26 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I am constantly staggered by the price of these things, considering how many you see about. There’s a dealer near my parents which has an ocean of them, average price probably £80 – £90k. Or you can buy a 10 year old one for £40k.

I don’t know who’s buying them all, but they’re certainly wealthy enough that they won’t be worried about an extra 20p on a litre of fuel!

and when they get lumped in with campervans for people who can't afford anything they have validated that someone with a 15yr old Berlingo can afford any cost


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 9:29 am
Posts: 597
Full Member
 

Part of the problem with motor homes is that the owners (having spent £10s of thousands) turn out to be tight fisted and simply don’t want to pay for anything. The cognitive dissonance on the wild camping motorhome forum being a case in point. In the UK it is  easy to find a campsite in a nice area. But they’re nowhere near as nicely laid out as the French sites. And the price is daft. My favourite in Keswick is nearly the same as the new premier inn. Admittedly the views are incomparable.

In short it’s complex. And as someone else said it requires localised responses in my opinion.


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 12:16 pm
colournoise reacted
 myti
Posts: 1815
Free Member
 

I just did a 2 week motorhome holiday across France. Spent £2k on fuel, Aires, visiting caves, meals out, stocking up on local wines and cheeses from each region we visited, some uplifted MTB. We didn't book anything and always had somewhere stunning to stay which was a variety of free and paid spots. We were planning a Scotland trip of similar kind in September but Tbh after reading a lot of the attitudes on here I think I'd rather just take my money back to France. Filled out the survey though just in case the people running it aren't completely close minded.


 
Posted : 05/08/2023 11:43 pm
Pauly reacted
Posts: 7846
Free Member
 

Lots of vans around and some busy spots but nothing dreadful. No mess left behind anywhere I’ve seen and I’ve been looking.

There are definitely problems in some places but they’re localised and the solutions are therefore local. No need for nationwide bans or similar hysteria, just deal with the problems where they occur.

All seems reasonable Spin but that wont fit in on this thread *wink

We are off for 11 nights next month. Booked a campsite for each night as we tour the NC500 and Skye in out T6. We will do what we always do and respect the environment and those who live in it as well as those we meet. Judging by this thread we will be the only ones.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 6:26 am
Posts: 1844
Full Member
 

No Surfer, when I have stayed on campsites in my tent lots of motorhomes are staying on site.

Not all people are dicks some are responsible and have respect for the environment.

This thread is like a driving thread and highlights the worst behaviour, but plenty of people are nice.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 6:47 am
Pauly, wheelsonfire1, matt_outandabout and 1 people reacted
Posts: 7846
Free Member
 

@bruce I agree with you I was being facetious. This thread is like a DM anti cyclist letters page.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 6:55 am
andywnpt reacted
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

Two separate issues
1) the "dirty campers" who camp up in their vans inconsiderately and make a mess

2) the sheer numbers of folk wanting to take campervans around the highlands ecpecially in the honeypot areas

The former needs regulation and enforcement IMO - as well as more facilities- carrot and stick

the latter is a worldwide issue - ask the residents of Amsterdam, Venice Rome, Amalfi coast etc.  a few years ago I spent a few days in Rome.  The trevi fountains had a scrum of folk around it almost 24/7  A much harder issue to deal with


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 7:00 am
Posts: 1844
Full Member
 

It's capitalism they are sold the dream of the open road and it works while a few people are living the dream. When the hoards catch on then it turns sour.

What do you expect to happen?


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 7:10 am
daverhp reacted
Posts: 6317
Free Member
 

Ban overnight  road side parking is my veiw. Would love to be able to but it isn't right. After many years of holiday cottages and fake camping (that's a family tent on a fixed site with facilities as far as I am concerned ) we succumbed and bought a VW fully kitted thingy. Before covid made it silly.  Only ever had one night by the side of a road,well ferry slip way.

The fun has gone. The point of it was to be by ourselves but now , why bother?

I also feel thoroughly embarrased by the whole thing, driving around in the big white monstrosity.  We don't support the local economy apart from site fees as no one in their right mind buys exotic venison burgers etc from estate shops or eats in twee cafes.

I do feel that it is pricing partly to blame but that's just market forces.

Off the Aviemore soon (god help us!) . I bet the ski road laybys will be a white city.

A thought though. Many here are wondering what the point of so called quiet road side sleeping is if it isn't quiet. Should we not extend this thought? Why go to a place for its wildness then bring in civilisation?  I would love to see a time whereby we don't encourage visitors by adding car parks and toilets which ultimately are environmental disasters. That would also reduce footpath erosion , MTB damage etc.

Of course where is the line? Ultimately we need a pandemic that we cannot stop.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 7:24 am
Posts: 1794
Full Member
 

Our motorhome went quite a few years ago, and to be honest even then (born in Scotland done LOTS of it in the 60s and 70s with my parents) I thought it was fairly crowded and bad habits pretty common (inability to take litter home, toilet dumping inappropriately, inability to let faster vehicles pass on single tracks, parking ejittery, full campsites in remote areas, inability to walk any distance so you can park out of the way etc etc) that took the joy out of it for me so we stopped. I’d probably support a move to something like the formal sites as now and ‘designated overnight stop places only’ (with a single centrally controlled up to date register so booking/ availability checkable) with a fixed maximum charge for given facilities so that local councils/locals can get some income from it but I can’t see it happening (though JustPark etc suggest it appears to be possible)


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 8:04 am
 Spin
Posts: 7655
Free Member
 

We were planning a Scotland trip of similar kind in September but Tbh after reading a lot of the attitudes on here I think I’d rather just take my money back to France

Don't pay any attention to all the doom sayers. If you're smart about where you go and responsible when you get there you won't have any issues or cause any issues.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 10:29 am
Pauly and Drac reacted
Posts: 1178
Full Member
 

Ah, the NIMBYism (and maybe some jealousy) is strong on this thread. Just remember that there will be arseholes (in vans, motorhomes, riding bikes, driving cars, drinking beer…) in all walks of life.

Great to see the traditional British solution being suggested though ; BAN THEM ALL!

<span style="font-size: 0.8rem;">Maybe better to look at solutions that work for everyone. Interesting to read about the lack of public toilets in the Highlands.</span>

Personally, I can’t wait for my September motorhome trip to Scotland where I’ll shop locally, eat in cafes & restaurants, drink in local pubs and see my family.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 10:42 am
andywnpt reacted
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

We were planning a Scotland trip of similar kind in September but Tbh after reading a lot of the attitudes on here I think I’d rather just take my money back to France

Just ignore the grumpy ones on here. You’ll be made very welcome as long you’re respectful.

a few years ago I spent a few days in Rome.  The trevi fountains had a scrum of folk around it almost 24/7  A much harder issue to deal with

You being one of them of course.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 10:45 am
Pauly reacted
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

Indeed I was Drac.  Just an illustration of too many folk meaning that the experience is spoiled


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 10:47 am
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

Don’t pay any attention to all the doom sayers. If you’re smart about where you go and responsible when you get there you won’t have any issues or cause any issues.

There are still some spots where I'm regularly surprised to see no one parked up. These do tend to be away from the honeypot areas. When you know, you know 😉


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 10:48 am
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

Yeah I’ve seen a few but I’ve not bothered and like to use a site or at least have a toilet.

Indeed I was Drac.  Just an illustration of too many folk meaning that the experience is spoiled

That’s just a tourist thing in general though, been like that for decades in areas that have ‘must see’ site. We’re off to Italy next year with the van, we’ll be looking for quieter areas, we want to experience the food, hospitality, drink, scenery and relax. Probably do a few ‘must see’ spots if near to one but we plan on using public transport.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 10:55 am
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

That’s just a tourist thing in general though, been like that for decades in areas that have ‘must see’ site

As I said above - its getting worse tho with various places taking steps to actually reduce mass tourism.  But yes - its a worldwide issue


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 11:04 am
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

Yeah a growing population will do that.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 11:07 am
Posts: 1846
Full Member
 

Plenty of sites have availability below is a popular NC500 site on a beach. The car park also allows overnight camping for £10 I think and it has loos. It is not even showing low availability on any days this month


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 11:12 am
Drac reacted
Posts: 3636
Free Member
 

It's no so much a growing population as a long term reduction in airfares in traditional markets and a massive increase in wealth across Asia that increased demand for internation tourism. Plus also maybe a bit of fascination for not just going to Rome, but getting the specific photo at the right corner of the Spanish Steps in the golden hour so you can put it in Instagram

Great to see the traditional British solution being suggested though ; BAN THEM ALL!

Who, specifically, is suggesting that?


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 11:12 am
 Drac
Posts: 50352
 

Yes, no doubt the cheap air travel is also to blame. That seems less of a thing now then it was.


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 11:27 am
Posts: 1178
Full Member
 

“it either needs to be banished by enforcement…”

“The answer is dont buy a motorhome as there isnt the camping sites available for them”

“I have said councils shouldn’t build campsites”

Theres definitely a strong anti vibe from a couple of posters, yourself included @politecameraaction


 
Posted : 06/08/2023 11:44 am
scotroutes, convert and Drac reacted
Posts: 43345
Full Member
Page 2 / 3

6 DAYS LEFT
We are currently at 95% of our target!