[Closed] Traffic priority question

Maybe because HGVs cause a lot of pollution if they are stopping and starting or driving very slowly in a queue of traffic? (just a guess)

FWIW, I pass the morning queue on my way to work. Looks horrendous.

Because Highways says so!

I was thinking it was something to do with lane widths and large vehicles but its seems its

to ensure as much as possible the free flow of public transport and the haulage industry

Thanks for that, now i'm puzzled as to what makes the haulage industry more deserving of consideration. I only see the queue from the northbound lane but if I was stuck in it i'd get the hump.
I'm just going to imagine that scotroutes has it right, I can cope with the injustice if theres a reason for it 🙂

Or possibly because lorries have no option but to go on the road, and single people in a car tend to have alternatives.

appeals for commuters to use public transport and to car share were put in place in an attempt to limit congestion.

If they want car sharers then cars with 3 or more occupants should get to use the fast lane as well.

Because the truckers have a limited number of hours behind the wheel. Looking at the route it may be that delaying HGVs would mean drivers are unable to complete this leg of the A9 without exceeding their hours and therefore driving illegally, or having to take overnight breaks in inappropriate places. A long queue could be the difference between getting back to the depot and home for the night, or kipping in the truck overnight in a layby.

(That's a guess, not fact)

Per sq m of occupied road footprint, an HGV is much more valuable to the general population than a car. Seems obvious to me when you look at it like that.

Or possibly because lorries have no option but to go on the road, and single people in a car tend to have alternatives.

So you can use that lane if the car has passengers?

aracer - Member
Or possibly because lorries have no option but to go on the road, and single people in a car tend to have alternatives.
POSTED 9 HOURS AGO # REPORT-POST

Maybe not quite as applicable in that part of the UK as in some other parts though.

I can cope with the injustice if theres a reason for it

You would be ok if there was no food in the supermarket then, because all the wagon drivers had done their hours sat in a traffic queue and were now parked up in a layby till tomorrow.

As long as there was a reason for it 😉

the stupid people

The other thing is that many of the HGVs would end up taking the longer route through Dingwall, Muir of Ord, Beauly and so on, on roads that aren't really up to it and causing pollution and noise in those small towns and villages. Folk would then complain when, after the bridge works are finished, the A862 was full of potholes and they'd complain [i]again[/i] when that road was subject to delays whilst being repaired.

Go on then, indulge me. Why are people driving alone stupid?

the people who are happy to sit in traffic everyday

For example, I choose to live close to work - I drive, ride, run or walk depending on mood. I am fortunate.

My brother has a job that covers an area as far south as Sheffield and as far north as Scotland. His van is full of parts, installation manuals etc and he has to be able to get to distribution depots to collect other parts as and when required. This means he has to drive, he works alone so he is a single car driver and he has to use whatever roads are available to get to a variety of destinations, from banks to supermarkets...

The issue isn't with people like your brother. Of course there are lots of people for whom driving alone is the only real option. I'm talking about the vast majority, the millions (actually millions not a dramatic point making exaggeration) who are completely unwilling to consider any alternatives. The people who sit in a traffic jam they are contributing to and complain about it.

You would be ok if there was no food in the supermarket then, because all the wagon drivers had done their hours sat in a traffic queue and were now parked up in a layby till tomorrow.

As long as there was a reason for it

And that could be a reason, and there are a few other reasons up there so I feel better already. Although there are plenty of other people in the queue who have no option but whose time is just as limited.
I'm a nurse and the only reason I ever get caught there is when I go to visit a client, should someone miss out on nursing care because i'm in a queue, but the bread rolls [i]must[/i] get through.

It would presumably make sense if the lane was for buses, HGVs and nurses on call, but who else would you add to the list, and more importantly how would it be policed? Maybe you need to get a bus or an HGV to visit your clients 😉

The people who sit in a traffic jam they are contributing to and complain about it.

My brother has a job that covers an area as far south as Sheffield and as far north as Scotland

All the way from Sheffield to Scotand?! Bugger me, he is well travelled! 😉

Thats my point aracer, who else should get priority, or should anyone.
For what its worth I dont particularly mind if im sitting there, I'm getting paid by the hour, but I cover a radius of 40miles from inverness and with the peculiarities of my job and location public transport would limit me to one client a day.

Ive been campaining for a camper van but the bosses aren't biting i'm afraid.

All the way from Sheffield to Scotand?! Bugger me, he is well travelled!

If only there was some sort of railway in the North of scotland that could take the freight of the A9.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-highlands-islands-23470170

Dunno what the score is North of Inverness though - is there still a lot of stuff going to Nigg/Cromarty. There were quite a few HGV bimbling up to Caithness last summer when I was enroute to Orkney.

Is it the swiss who insist that lorries switch cargo to rail when it transits through switzerland