[Closed] Titanic - why why why ??

I just don't get it.

And yet you just HAD to post about it.

I agree.

Let's ignore stuff that's happened more than, say, 19 years ago.

People should not be permitted to have any sort of interest in historical events. Their money and time would be FAR better spent on a 29er fixie (steel of course).

i'm inclined to agree. a lot of it is excessively morbid, i find.

Yes, it was a tragedy, but there are tragic things happening all the time which deserve just as much recognition. I can understand documentaries, etc. but it's not news.

Having said that, these days the BBC news seems to be much more about plugging the BBC's other 'factual' programmes rather than reporting actual news

That terrible film was more than 10 years ago, unless there have been other terrible Titanic films that I an unaware if as I'm so effing cool.

Captain Flasheart - I was hoping that in amongst the sarcasm and disdain there might lurk a gem of understanding and insight. And I'm off work, it's raining, and I'm bored.

How ironic would it be if the recreation voyage sank, btw ? Now that would be proper actual Kate Adie Real News.

Even when considering death, half-witted people need to wrap it all up in a warm fug of nostalgia. Thats all fine, if you have a sense of perspective

I'm not an expert in History, but I seem to recall that around about 100 years ago, there were a couple of world events that resulted in the loss of a few more lives than on a badly constructed ship

I'm not an expert in History, but I seem to recall that around about 100 years ago, there were a couple of world events that resulted in the loss of a few more lives than on a badly constructed ship

I [i]am[/i] an expert in history, I believe the events you are referring to are the construction of the pyramids and something that happened in Rome. HTH.

I don't care much about the Titanic, all the hype about it, or the moaning about the hype.

Just thought you'd like to know 😛

EDIT: Oh and a proper moan should go "Why, oh why?".

Send a U-boat to torpedo it ... 🙄

That will create history.

Yes, yes, no iceberg but torpedo create more sparks.

Now I feel bad for wishing a ship would sink. I am reminded of a quote from Rob Muldoon, Kiwi prime minister during the 70s re Kiwis emigrating to Australia and raising the average IQ of both countries.

I'm doing a proper moan right now Al. Should I also let you know what I'm wearing ??

All this fuss about the Titanic. What happened to the iceberg?

At least it isn't more on the bloody oxbridge boat race. How that's still shown live on tv is beyond me.

I'm not an expert in History, .. .. .. a badly constructed ship

Not so much bad construction as poor design.

Aye it was the design that was flawed, no?

Leading to separate partitions?

so what were the elements of the ship that were "badly constructed?"

I hear some of the marquetry on the tables in 2nd class was, frankly, shocking, even for 2nd class standards

I think its the fault of whoever vocalised the word 'unsinkable'

Once that's out in the open, there's only ever going to be one outcome

I had hoped never to hear that apalling Sealion Dion record again...

MwA y'all... there there now..

1.2.3 altogether now..

I hear some of the marquetry on the tables in 2nd class was, frankly, shocking, even for 2nd class standards

hels - Member

I'm doing a proper moan right now Al. Should I also let you know what I'm wearing ??

Pics please.

not an expert in history but an expert in marine construction? so what were the elements of the ship that were "badly constructed?"

Weren't the rivets brittle resulting in their heads popping off on impact and causing the plates to separate?

ye it was the design that was flawed, no?

Leading to separate partitions?

Rudder was too small also.

However, I am not a metallurgist, marine architect, doctor, ice cream salesman or rabbi so I do tend to speculate or regurgitate stuff that I gave seen on the TV.

hels - Member
How ironic would it be if the recreation voyage sank, btw ? Now that would be proper actual Kate Adie Real News.

Funny you should say that, I saw the BBC report this morning and the journo on the boat looked a tad nervous IMO....

But there are no icebergs there at the moment...

if they hadnt said it was 'unsinkable' i doubt whether any of us would have heard of it.

I didn't know until a couple of days ago, that there were two other ships, just the same, Gigantic and something else. And there was a nurse who survived the titanic and got sunk on another one, and she survived that!!

amazing

They didn't say it was unsinkable before it sank. That tag was applied afterwards by the press, much like Tommy Simpson didn't say "Put me back on the bike", King Harold didn't say "These buggers will have someone's eye out" and Neil Armstrong didn't say "F### me! It is made out of cheese".

if they hadnt said it was 'unsinkable' i doubt whether any of us would have heard of it.

Sadly that quote is an urban myth not said until quite a while afterwards by the media to hype up their coverage.

It wasn't called "unsinkable", nor was it "the biggest", nor was it badly constructed etc.

The truth is it was the 2nd ship of the class. The Olympic was the 1st and biggest and the subject of all the press that today is attributed to the Titanic.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RMS_Olympic

As for "badly constructed"; the Olympic was made side by side with the Titanic and was basicly identical. This ship actually sunk a U boat by ramming it as was known as "Old Reliable" in the war.

Weren't the rivets brittle resulting in their heads popping off on impact and causing the plates to separate?

Indeed they were, iron not steel rivets.

I didn't know until a couple of days ago, that there were two other ships, just the same, Gigantic and something else

You mean the Olympic and the Britannic?

There's an interesting conspiracy theory that it was actually the Olympic that sunk, they 'swapped' the ships to avoid a costly repair on the Olympic. The iceberg bit wasn't supposed to happen though.

Edit: I say 'interesting' in the mental sense, it's all rather far fetched!

A groundbreaking disaster movie in which the audience soon find themselves rooting for the disaster.

Spare a thought for the 4,375 people who died on the MV Doña Paz In 1987. Not much talk about that.

i hope leo survives this time x

i hope leo survives this time

You would have thought that as he'd spent most of the film trying to ride her like a lilo he would have taken the opportunity to do it once they hit the water.

Spare a thought for the 4,375 people who died on the MV Doña Paz In 1987. Not much talk about that.

just read up on that. how terrible 😯

Yup, puts things into perspective.

Weren't the rivets brittle resulting in their heads popping off on impact and causing the plates to separate?

However, I am not a metallurgist, marine architect, doctor, ice cream salesman or rabbi so I do tend to speculate or regurgitate stuff that I gave seen on the TV.

i hope leo survives this time

Not on the pictures I've seen (Dive magazines etc), and as a diver, anything to do with shipwrecks is interesting to me, and I've never seen any evidence of flawed rivets.

Google it. Commonly stated point.

I never went to see Titanic, don't think I'll ever watch it... the boat sinks, right?

Eventually. Takes longer in the film than it did in real life virtually!

as a diver, anything to do with shipwrecks is interesting to me, and I've never seen any evidence of flawed rivets.

Oooh, so they teased it out. I thought it would be more along the lines of... boat floating, iceberg floating, boat meets iceberg, boat sinks, iceberg floats off into moon-light, 15 mins max, even if you included a dreadful ending song from a gonk nosed warbler.

Did anyone see Camerons documentary on it, some of it was fascinating.

Can't beleive the film is 10yrs old now.. what happened in the meantime??

I gained about 10kg of fat.

Can't beleive the film is 10yrs old now.. what happened in the meantime??

It's not. It's 15 years old. 1997.

bikebouy - Member

Did anyone see Camerons documentary on it, some of it was fascinating.

the bit where you see kate winslet's tits?

Didn't more people die in the Cap Arcona?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Cap_Arcona_(1927)