The Thursday Murder...
 

  You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more

The Thursday Murder Club Movie...

70 Posts
43 Users
17 Reactions
2,933 Views
Posts: 13617
Full Member
Topic starter
 

In true STW style of critiquing before anyone has seen it!... 😜

...does anyone else feel they've got too big and too star-studded with it?

I'm sure Richard Osman is loving the cash and attention but the charm of the books was the normalness of the situation and the characters. 

From watching the trailers I just see the stars not the characters.

 


 
Posted : 22/08/2025 7:59 am
Posts: 32265
Full Member
 

I'm looking forward to seeing if they manage to pull it off. There's a very easy lazy charm to the books, perfect brain out reading.

SPOILER ALERT

Not sure how ordinary it is for a care home to have a former top spy as a resident though. 


 
Posted : 22/08/2025 8:23 am
Posts: 13617
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Posted by: MoreCashThanDash

Not sure how ordinary it is for a care home to have a former top spy as a resident though.

 Old habits die hard for a spy - it's the need to blend in with normal society! 🙂


 
Posted : 22/08/2025 8:26 am
Posts: 77347
Free Member
 

Haven't read the book(s) and this is the first I've heard about a film.

From the trailer...

... I think it looks excellent and now I want to read it.  My partner has it I think, I'll pilfer it if so.


 
Posted : 22/08/2025 1:29 pm
 nbt
Posts: 12381
Full Member
 

Loved the books. Been looking forward to the film, even more so now I've seen the trailer


 
Posted : 22/08/2025 2:12 pm
Posts: 9491
Full Member
 

Lovely easy books to read. I too am looking forward to these excellent actors pulling off a Steven Spielberg film.


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 2:49 pm
 MSP
Posts: 15473
Free Member
 

The trailer looks like easy viewing fun, I am sick of over serious pretentious and depressing crap (like the joker etc).

Is there a series of these books? Sounds like good audiobook fodder to listen to on the commute.


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 2:58 pm
Posts: 32265
Full Member
 

Posted by: MSP

Is there a series of these books? Sounds like good audiobook fodder to listen to on the commute.

I think there's 3 or 4 of the books, and I believe his next book is setting up a new group of characters. Felt quite similar to the Marlowe Murder Club or whatever it's called, which has been nicely televised, or maybe Dick Francis books - easy going characters involved in thwarting criminal plots.

 


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 3:20 pm
Posts: 3579
Full Member
 

Is there a series of these books? Sounds like good audiobook fodder to listen to on the commute.

Yep, the 5th one is due to come out next month.

I love the books, and was really excited to hear the Netflix was doing something with them, but was a little disappointed when I heard it would be a film, not a series. I think they missed a trick there, TBH, but none the less, I'm still really looking forward to seeing it.


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 3:22 pm
Posts: 3579
Full Member
 

Posted by: MoreCashThanDash

I believe his next book is setting up a new group of characters.

First in t new series, We Solve Murders (pretty much does what it says on the tin/cover), came out last year.

Different but in a similar style to the Thursday Murder Club.


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 3:25 pm
Posts: 13134
Full Member
 

Enjoyed the audiobooks in a guilty pleasure, not having to try too hard to keep up kind of way. Instinctively it feels more a novel(s) for a TV series of the Death in Paradise easy viewing style rather than a film. Watching the trailer makes me feel I was probably right.

 

Not sure about Pierce Bronson as Ron. The bastard may be 72 but he just looks too good! Ron was a union man that would like to punch someone out but knows it'd put his back out instead. Bronson still looks like he could be playing Bond! In fact all the celeb actors/actresses in general are wearing a bit too well for the roles.


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 3:57 pm
Posts: 744
Free Member
 

In my minds eye as I read the books I had Charlotte Rampling as Elizabeth and Alison Steadman as Joyce. Trevor Peacock(Jim, vicar of Dibley) as Ron and Naveen Andrews as Ibrahim. 

Pierce Brosnan makes no sense to me.


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 3:58 pm
white101 and convert reacted
Posts: 32265
Full Member
 

Posted by: jobro

In my minds eye as I read the books I had Charlotte Rampling as Elizabeth and Alison Steadman as Joyce. Trevor Peacock(Jim, vicar of Dibley) as Ron and Naveen Andrews as Ibrahim. 

Pierce Brosnan makes no sense to me.

Brosnan has one key advantage over Trevor Peacock, to be fair

 


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 8:32 pm
convert reacted
Posts: 490
Free Member
 

Wonderful books. Truly beautifully written, sublime! 

I don’t mind the casting. But I’m struggling with the setting of the home. Didn’t have that in my mind 


 
Posted : 23/08/2025 8:51 pm
white101 and ThePinkster reacted
Posts: 10315
Full Member
 

Is there a series of these books? Sounds like good audiobook fodder to listen to on the commute.

I use them for running.  It's not hugely important if you zone out for a bit and they are enjoyable enough.  I prefer We Solve Murders 


 
Posted : 24/08/2025 4:24 am
Posts: 13134
Full Member
 

From a BBC interview....

Brosnan also admits he first thought of another actor when reading the part of Ron.

"I never asked Chris why he cast me," says Brosnan. "I thought: 'this is Ray Winstone, bro'". But the actor kept any doubts to himself, and remembers thinking: "'Don't say anything Pierce, just keep going'".

Maybe a few years too young - but yes!
 
But I’m struggling with the setting of the home. Didn’t have that in my mind 
Me too. Was a retirement village in the book, with the old house for the more infirm and the central facilities. It was posh, but not that posh in my head.

 
Posted : 24/08/2025 7:44 am
Posts: 744
Free Member
 

Posted by: MoreCashThanDash

Posted by: jobro

In my minds eye as I read the books I had Charlotte Rampling as Elizabeth and Alison Steadman as Joyce. Trevor Peacock(Jim, vicar of Dibley) as Ron and Naveen Andrews as Ibrahim. 

Pierce Brosnan makes no sense to me.

Brosnan has one key advantage over Trevor Peacock, to be fair

 

Fair enough!

 


 
Posted : 24/08/2025 7:46 am
Posts: 3579
Full Member
 

Posted by: jobro

Pierce Brosnan makes no sense to me.

A quote I read from Richard Osman that a lot of people were questioning the choice of Pierce Brosnan as Ron and his response was that he would have been Ron's choice to play him in the movie 🤣


 
Posted : 24/08/2025 8:12 am
convert reacted
 nbt
Posts: 12381
Full Member
 

Posted by: jobro

Posted by: MoreCashThanDash

Posted by: jobro

In my minds eye as I read the books I had Charlotte Rampling as Elizabeth and Alison Steadman as Joyce. Trevor Peacock(Jim, vicar of Dibley) as Ron and Naveen Andrews as Ibrahim. 

Pierce Brosnan makes no sense to me.

Brosnan has one key advantage over Trevor Peacock, to be fair

 

Fair enough!

 

 

 yeah, I think Peacock works have been a bit lifeless as Ron

 


 
Posted : 24/08/2025 1:34 pm
Posts: 33325
Full Member
 

Posted by: convert

Me too. Was a retirement village in the book, with the old house for the more infirm and the central facilities. It was posh, but not that posh in my head.

But who is Number One?


 
Posted : 25/08/2025 10:01 pm
gecko76 reacted
 nbt
Posts: 12381
Full Member
 

Been quite the race so far, the daily grind as it were has been run of the mill, but the finishes have been exciting with some unexpected winners. Team Time Trial today. Ineos? Maybe UAE?


 
Posted : 27/08/2025 7:27 am
 nbt
Posts: 12381
Full Member
 

Posted by: nbt

Been quite the race so far, the daily grind as it were has been run of the mill, but the finishes have been exciting with some unexpected winners. Team Time Trial today. Ineos? Maybe UAE?

 

Well that was supposed to be posted on the Grand Tours thread, not here. Sorry

 


 
Posted : 27/08/2025 8:11 pm
Posts: 32265
Full Member
 

Posted by: nbt

Posted by: nbt

Been quite the race so far, the daily grind as it were has been run of the mill, but the finishes have been exciting with some unexpected winners. Team Time Trial today. Ineos? Maybe UAE?

 

Well that was supposed to be posted on the Grand Tours thread, not here. Sorry

 

I was concerned they'd maybe taken a few liberties with the book...

 


 
Posted : 28/08/2025 8:46 am
Posts: 20169
Full Member
 

Posted by: convert

Not sure about Pierce Brosnan as Ron. The bastard may be 72 but he just looks too good! Ron was a union man that would like to punch someone out but knows it'd put his back out instead. Brosnan still looks like he could be playing Bond!

There were a couple of subtle references to that in the film, the sort of "nod and a wink" type stuff where everybody knows exactly what is meant. A nod back to one of Helen Mirren's previous film roles too.

Happens a lot now with ageing actors. Arnie does a good line in self-deprecation throughout FUBAR (also on Netfilx).

It was all quietly entertaining. A bigger mystery to solve would be how anyone could ever afford the fees at such a grand retirement home.


 
Posted : 28/08/2025 1:02 pm
Posts: 1513
Free Member
 

Watched the film Netflix, haven’t read the book.  Film was absolute rubbish. I’m aware it’s supposed to be cosy crime, but that’s no excuse for this lazy arse shit. Terrible dialogue, terrible characters, all round Dan Brown level stuff. To top it all they seemed to demand a murder suicide at the end! Given the hype it’s received in the media and the positive reviews it gets I’m getting a distinct whiff of Emperor’s New Clothes about the whole thing.


 
Posted : 29/08/2025 9:39 pm
Posts: 240
Full Member
 

 

distinct whiff of Emperor’s New Clothes about the whole thing.

 

4* then? 😀 


 
Posted : 30/08/2025 6:56 am
roger_mellie reacted
Posts: 1612
Full Member
 

Yeah, kinda what Supernova said. But with less passion 😁It's a film to put on on a Sunday and fall asleep to.
Pierce Brosnan and Tom Ellis both have shocking accents.
Brosnan needs to stop doing accents 😁


 
Posted : 30/08/2025 11:27 pm
Posts: 11269
Full Member
 

Watched it tonight with mum, I thought it was rather shite and was glad when it finished, mum thought it was ok. 

I want a room in the care home (given I have spms it’d probably be a good idea) , their rooms are larger than my entire house 


 
Posted : 31/08/2025 12:08 am
Posts: 24332
Full Member
 

Not read any of the books but if the film is anything like them I won't bother, truly awful like a mix of the worse bits of the Agatha raisin adaptation mixed with midsomer murders.

 


 
Posted : 31/08/2025 1:23 am
Posts: 33325
Full Member
 

Posted by: MoreCashThanDash

Not sure how ordinary it is for a care home to have a former top spy as a resident though.

Depends on the care home - Slow Horses had one specifically for elderly members of His Majesty’s security services, which would make perfect sense, a bit like the Chelsea Pensioners, but for spooks.


 
Posted : 31/08/2025 2:20 am
Posts: 33325
Full Member
 

And speaking of Slow Horses, it’s nice to see one of them has found a nice home with nice people around him… 😏


 
Posted : 31/08/2025 10:04 pm
Posts: 33325
Full Member
 

@supernova - everyone’s a critic, eh?  😏

I enjoyed it, everyone in it seemed to be having a whale of a time, it was entertaining without needing to overthink everything.


 
Posted : 31/08/2025 10:50 pm
Posts: 32265
Full Member
 

Watched it at the excellent Broadway cinema on Saturday night. Was pleasant enough but as a fan of the books it would have been so much better as a TV series, too much was missing.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 6:49 am
Posts: 11292
Full Member
 

Watched it last night and having not read the books, it was enjoyable. I had a few chuckles at the old folk jokes.

I did think it would be great if it was a series...worked for me as a film but I think it would have been better as a TV series.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 7:18 am
Posts: 1383
Full Member
 

Watched it last night. Not read the books.

we all enjoyed it, easy watching with a great cast - the ladies in the film really do steal the show. Brosnan we universally agreed was miscast.

Unfortunately we had watched “and then there were none” on the iPlayer a few days before which we thought was a million times better.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 8:10 am
Posts: 6688
Full Member
 

Saw it last night too and its ok if a little twee. A little like afternoon TV aimed at the older generation, and they're a sizable market.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 8:10 am
Posts: 25815
Full Member
 

Posted by: MoreCashThanDash

the excellent Broadway cinema

Pleased to hear that's still going - as seemingly the only good news in this thread


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 8:26 am
 Olly
Posts: 5169
Free Member
 

watched this last night.

Never read the book, im sure its totally different from the film, but the film writing jarred me.

Elizabeths character (Hellen Mirrem) was written for Dame Judi.

"easter egg" nods throughout

  • "its not like youre the head of MI6 or anything"
  • Aston Martin as a "retirement gift from work"

and then not casting Judi (I think her sight has gone, sadly) ruined it.

better to have taken the references out in my opinion..

i think Netflix suffers from being able to afford whichever A listers they like, and then use them in mediocre writing.

youve seen all these Heavy hitters in big movies, they dont sit right here.

 


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 8:49 am
Posts: 32265
Full Member
 

Posted by: scaredypants

Posted by: MoreCashThanDash

the excellent Broadway cinema

Pleased to hear that's still going - as seemingly the only good news in this thread

Our first visit but definitely not the last

 


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 9:46 am
Posts: 10567
Full Member
 

We watched it on Thursday (natch) when it came out on Netflix.  We really enjoyed it, but there again we're the same age as some of the residents.

(Pierce Brosnan was born 3 weeks before me)


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 9:57 am
Posts: 2256
Free Member
 

It was ok. I agree it was a bit too 'starry'.

I think this sort of thing works better as a series; there wasn't enough time to build tension or to subtly introduce characters.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 10:51 am
Posts: 11292
Full Member
 

The actors are getting on a bit and not getting the big hotter parts like they used to... probably better that they get opportunities than turn them down as they aren't big enough parts.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 11:16 am
Posts: 2400
Free Member
 

No views on Mr Brosnan’s “unusual” accent? At least he didn’t sing…


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 11:16 am
Posts: 24498
Free Member
 

No views on Mr Brosnan’s “unusual” accent? At least he didn’t sing…

 

 

Pierce Brosnan and Tom Ellis both have shocking accents.

Brosnan needs to stop doing accents


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 11:22 am
Posts: 3204
Free Member
 

Did someone just upload the book into Chat GPT and ask it to turn it into a script?

Im truly shocked anyone finished that film. Both those watching it and those involved in making it. An utter stinker.

 


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 2:55 pm
Posts: 13617
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Seems my fears were correct then!

I'll pencil it in as one to watch when I can't find anything else on. 🙂


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 3:19 pm
Posts: 10315
Full Member
 

Found it unwatchable really.  Enjoyed the book as an audiobook but as mentioned above it was just too compressed to really follow what was happening or allow characters to develop.  I think I lasted about a third of the way through. 


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 5:32 pm
Posts: 7076
Full Member
 

Just watching it at the cinema now. Starting in a few minutes. 

My wife's friend said she saw it and thought it "lumpy". She recommended we sit on the back row and spend the time snogging in the dark 


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 7:32 pm
Posts: 7114
Full Member
 

My wife's friend said she saw it and thought it "lumpy". She recommended we sit on the back row and spend the time snogging in the dark 

That sounds like a great idea. Don't let your wife find out though.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 7:43 pm
Speeder, funkrodent, DickBarton and 1 people reacted
Posts: 7076
Full Member
 

Perfectly acceptable.


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 9:27 pm
Posts: 2110
Full Member
 

Read the books. Saw the film tonight. Agree that Brosnan was woefully miscast. Others were pretty good. Overall I felt it suffered from having to cut so much and taking a chainsaw to lots of the plot. Oversimplified everything (understandable) and made Bogdan into the bad guy, which is unforgivable. Distinctly underwhelmed and would have been better as a series I guess


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 9:42 pm
Posts: 2110
Full Member
 

My wife's friend said she saw it and thought it "lumpy". She recommended we sit on the back row and spend the time snogging in the dark 

That sounds like a great idea. Don't let your wife find out though.

Deserving of recognition. Chapeau 


 
Posted : 01/09/2025 9:44 pm
Speeder and oldnpastit reacted
Posts: 7076
Full Member
 

Enough plot holes to bury several more bodies in.


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 4:39 am
Posts: 4143
Free Member
 

TTMC ..... literary/cinematic equivalent of Robson and Jerome.

 

Cosy content, I get it and in many ways I'm all for it, I really don't like violence as I mature.

But does cosy really have to mean dumbed down to this extent? 

Can joyful not also be clever ??

 

Mackenzie Crook where are you ??

 

 


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 7:34 am
Posts: 23107
Free Member
 

Watched it last night at my daughter's request. Have forgotten it already.

 

Was Daniel Mays padded up for that? 


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 8:45 am
Posts: 3204
Free Member
 

Posted by: Harry_the_Spider

Was Daniel Mays padded up for that? 

 

I wondered this too. Unless he's gone all Raging Bull. 

 


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 9:10 am
Posts: 12482
Free Member
 

One word - Saccharine.  Not really worthy of the actors within in.


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 9:23 am
Posts: 4022
Free Member
 

Posted by: Ro5ey

Mackenzie Crook where are you ??

Working on this, coming later this year; https://www.comedy.co.uk/tv/news/8363/new-mackenzie-crook-bbc-comedy-small-prophets/


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 9:23 am
 kilo
Posts: 6666
Full Member
 

Posted by: kerley

One word - Saccharine.  Not really worthy of the actors within in.

 

Did you expect more? The books are an exercise in saccharine crime fiction.

 


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 9:26 am
Posts: 12482
Free Member
 

Did you expect more?

I didn't expect anything, I watched it with no prior knowledge of the books and that was my one word review.


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 9:31 am
Posts: 3026
Free Member
 

Just like the book, it was lightweight.  Wife enjoyed it - I though it plodded along with nothing much happening


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 10:18 am
Posts: 6071
Free Member
 

It wasn't meant to be taken seriously. Pleasant, lightweight entertainment, no expectations of procedural correctness so nothing to think about

No views on Mr Brosnan’s “unusual” accent? At least he didn’t sing…

This was a redeeming feature and everyone in it seemed to enjoy themselves


 
Posted : 02/09/2025 4:21 pm
Posts: 1387
Full Member
 

police guy did remind me of this

k">


 
Posted : 03/09/2025 1:56 pm
Posts: 12381
Full Member
 

Was Daniel Mays padded up

 

yes, he was


 
Posted : 03/09/2025 2:24 pm
Posts: 2763
Free Member
 

I thought it was pretty poor but still reasonably watchable, I've listened to all the audiobooks whilst driving so have a vision in my head which this missed by miles.

There were a few specific niggles, the casting wasn't right, particularly Bronson but also the actor who played Bogdan. Also, Bogdan got proper stitched up, presumably he'll be cleared in the sequel otherwise there'll be a lot of re-writing going on.

The worst thing for me though was that everything was just a bit overdone. The home was way beyond what the books suggest, the MI6 links in the book are much more subtle, the "bad cop" was too stereotyped etc. I'm not saying the books are exactly gritty by any means but they're definitely less "cartoony" then this. 

It's what puts me off a lot of current tv/film content, everything's too glossy, played for laughs and full of nods, references, homages and in-jokes.

The books have a successful enough vibe that they obviously thought it worth making a film, why they decided to throw that vibe away is anyone's guess.


 
Posted : 03/09/2025 7:54 pm
Posts: 32265
Full Member
 

I'm surprised people are saying the retirement village was more posh than they expected from the books. There's a similar looking one outside Matlock in a former private school (Muffin Man will know it) and that is exactly how I imagined it from the book. The book also indicated that residents were financially well off. Maybe it's just our personal reference points.

Be dull if we all thought the same though.


 
Posted : 04/09/2025 7:12 am
Posts: 56564
Full Member
 

Dear god! I thought this kind of insufferably twee rubbish was safely self-contained in the literal graveyard slot of 8 o clock on a Sunday night on BBC 1, where it can be easily avoided.

i endured 30 minutes of it and concluded I’d rather remove my own kidneys with a teaspoon than watch the rest. Mrs Binners fully concurred 


 
Posted : 06/09/2025 8:02 pm
Posts: 490
Free Member
 

Well I really enjoyed it! Not much thinking required, feels like in this day and age stuff like that is quite a pleasant escape. 


 
Posted : 06/09/2025 8:46 pm
Posts: 7812
Full Member
 

Watchable light fluff that made no attempt to take itself seriously.  Won't win any awards for original thinking and all the big names have produced far better but compared to some of the poorly produced fetid dingoes kidneys on Netflix / Prime it was a bit of easy and inoffensive telly. 


 
Posted : 06/09/2025 9:08 pm
Posts: 1612
Free Member
 

watched it - ending was terrible.  Did anyone else notice Bogdan was the bully in Inbetweeners?


 
Posted : 07/09/2025 9:36 am

6 DAYS LEFT
We are currently at 95% of our target!