Scrabble question, ...
 

  You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more

[Closed] Scrabble question, probability

27 Posts
17 Users
0 Reactions
460 Views
Posts: 2386
Free Member
Topic starter
 

The other night I played a 5-letter word, and took my 5 pieces from the bag.

I didn't look at the pieces, I just put them in the rack as they left my hand.

I did a double-take, and was a little bit freaked out because my letters now read:

AAEEIOU

In that order.

What are the chances of pulling all the vowels, and then placing them without looking, in the order in which you're taught them?

Is the probability of pulling out a 7-letter word, and placing the letters in the rack in the right order without looking, about the same?


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:02 pm
Posts: 396
Free Member
 

less if you live in Wales

back pages of New Scientist do this sort of stuff even had a question about corrugations on gravel roads a few months ago...pretty dubious answers


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:15 pm
Posts: 12507
Free Member
 

It would depend on how many and which letters have been taken already.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:20 pm
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

From the point of view of statistics, AAEEIOU is just another word.

At the start of the game there are 100 tiles and 9 As, so the probability of getting an A is 9/100. Then the probability of getting the next A is 8/99. There are 12 Es left in the bag which now has 98 letters in it, so your probability is 12/97. The probabilties stack, so work out all those numbers and multiply them together and you get your probability of that pariticular word at the start of the game.

Some words are more probable than others because of the distribution of letters. The string of vowels is more likely than say QUETZAL (a type of bird) because obvs there are more vowels in the bag than Qs and Zs.

Where it gets beyond my A-Level maths is how to calculate the probability of it happening at any point during a game. It clearly depends what has happened in the game before, and how many words have been played. And this remarkable event is notable at any point in the game, so you need to stack all the probabilities which either diminish as vowel-heavy words get played, or increase as consonant-heavy words get played. There may be a way to create a model averaging out the course of a game and stacking those probabilities, but I have no idea off the top of my head and I CBA to consider it in depth 🙂


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:21 pm
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

less if you live in Wales

Seven vowels in the Welsh alphabet. The fact you don't know what they are doesn't constitute anything weird about Welsh.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:22 pm
Posts: 17273
Free Member
 

Han Solo wouldn't want to know.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:32 pm
Posts: 396
Free Member
 

Seven vowels in the Welsh alphabet

my mini brain that doesn't know what they are reckons that means that pulling all the vowels in order is less...maybe my pointing out that defining vowels depends on location was wasted


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:38 pm
Posts: 17273
Free Member
 

Seven vowels in the Welsh alphabet

L,W,Y,L,W,L and L?


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 12:40 pm
Posts: 2386
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Thanks molgrips, that's about as much of an exposition as I hoped for, or would be able to deal with.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 1:00 pm
Posts: 20561
Free Member
 

I often wrestled with a similar question regarding the National Lottery (and had many arguments about it in the pub with mates) - is it equally likely for the numbers coming out of the machine to be (in this order): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 as it would be any other random numbers such as 25, 4, 49, 46, 12, 31?


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 1:17 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

is it equally likely for the numbers coming out of the machine to be (in this order): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 as it would be any other random numbers such as 25, 4, 49, 46, 12, 31?

Yes, it is. Any given combination is very unlikely, that's why 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 would be really surprising. If you predicted beforehand that the draw would be 25, 4, 49, 46, 12, 31, it would be just as surprising if that was the draw as if it was 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. Trick is, you have to predict the numbers before the draw, not afterwards.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 1:58 pm
Posts: 8835
Free Member
 

As long as 25, 4, 49, 46, 12, 31 had to come out in that order, then yes it's the same probability as 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 in order.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 2:00 pm
 poly
Posts: 8699
Free Member
 

Without knowing how far through the game you were, ie. what other tiles had already been drawn it would be impossible to say what the odds of that combination in that order were.

Probabilities of any particular "hand" in Scrabble are fairly complex to calculate because their is an uneven distribution of tiles to start with, and then it changes every time someone plays. The fact you only picked 5 and ended up with 7 vowels further complicates the issue (you must already have had 2 vowels which must themselves have been "in order" you then presumably had one choice to place your pieces to the left or right of them.

The result you got was incredibly unlikely - as is every individual draw of tiles (at least in the early stage of the game). In fact because vowels (and A,E,I in particular) are more common than other tiles your outcome is less surprising than other combinations that would likely go unnoticed.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 2:16 pm
Posts: 6856
Free Member
 

AAEEIOU is just another word

It's not a word though, is it? If DK's letters said a random 7 letter word that would be more impressive. It's not even a particularly interesting pattern (other non-word patterns like ABCDEFG would be more interesting, for example).

As per the National Lottery Example, the chance of your precise combination occurring is admittedly very small, but no different to any other precise combination of letters (I'm ignoring Scrabble letter frequency for ease of argument, though again that increases the odds of your particular combo vs anything with a lower frequency letter in it). Google says there are 32909 seven letter English words, plus there must be a handful of other interesting combos like ABCDEFG, TUVWXYZ or acronyms like WYSIWYG.

So, OP, when you multiply your probability by the number of interesting combos (E.g. 33000), then multiply that by how many turns you have in each game, and again by how many games of scrabble you've played in your life... You get a probability that is not so unlikely. If you're another degree of separation away (as anyone reading this is), and you multiply the probability (you just calculated) by the number of people who might tell you in passing about a special Scrabble combination (on the radio, TV, books, internet, friends etc etc), then, well, I'm sorry I'm not very impressed.

P.S. yes I am fun at parties. Technically.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 2:17 pm
Posts: 16346
Free Member
 

is it equally likely for the numbers coming out of the machine to be (in this order): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 as it would be any other random numbers such as 25, 4, 49, 46, 12, 31?

Equally likely but a much reduced jackpot for 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 2:21 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

This is 96 sets of Scrabble letters randomized. As you would expect, lots of 3 letter words, surprisingly long strings of vowels. "BEARMATES" is kinda an 8 letter word. That's the longest one I could see from a quick skim.

TMZRJESRDEDZYIFUIINAEEGYGZPVTMKDEGSAIGSEETOTIIHFIRBSITAOEQKDTACCOEAWSEOACSIBRIKLIQCHOONAODUAUAGHBTRITADEGSRESYODLOIIMMEOIICINZUISEVHGMOAERKNTREJNIARHOSNNSNUOVRIEUTOSEEGYRTEYIAYOAMRHOVXIEWUTJOIPFEALWNHNIOEWERGRWGEOEIINLEOIHEZEKRTBBAEAAAODAISEEEIRAEETRYITDIRLDWAEFIELEADJQIOHMROSNTURZEITUGXNEIGCRNYSMOLJNNEUNGNASYENEDXIIEBUANACDOBWTWELGBYSNGLROTURBITHIAWOSSETBEUUENUEQYNTUVNIOSSRADFGOVOWYXCOYHEOKESAIIRDTOOJTAIAUETZIRRDAAQDBOOERUSTVUEYIROIAPNENNGIERAAYRALXIOENWPRGHEASEDZAAOOECSBAIZQIONTOYPATIITODOMITTLMNXPEOZDRSBBXFEABYAAIDWAMLAUSTVAFEEDATCQOOOTCEBYMKNIENNLTIOARAOILBTNCDAVUEICOOATRERWADDERUEDMUCPETRGDPJAWEELEGEERGYDTNIELPYODMEPENTASEFWVFGCOTRRIELECWSGOECZQIDKTTUVAUAHERTNAATRTQIHSSRRMNPOAQNNBIIUITLEILAAUTLARNOEMAOUBIEEBPOONIILICATNASSEIUOEIHQAAEEOALUEEFUTIUAKBLCAVIRUHLIBROEXVIQIVGYUJDFLEERNAESMTTEIJDIAEELPRGSSEMPIUWYVDPTZEEITMTIUIRUGSTIMMFNRIGIOEAIAAAITWIIRRENDTEEZLCAFIETTLOIWCERCILEILOFLVAIANMAEOAFPMORMLEUNEROTOHOTZHTTEGIAMMNOUVGTIYHZLQEIBLGDAINEPRTATQEIAOEFOXONSANATEDTEGKDILUXTDIDEUGEZHAUEELYAANCLLAFYAEIEIETAUNDOTXOIGCFVINUIIVSEUSWFEESOELKCEENBIDUTELUSAAXNYUAGGAUTDEOWEARURIRONINEEETEYYEEAEALIAIEATHDYLAPNINUSSRNIONIIWNDOWERMESORHDTNAEIIEIUHETRONNBOTRFNNOLNOASSCMEOIWHIIPRHDSRSNACABPUVETSEVGUZRRLNAERDGOLRZDJOHMDVJAREOXPOZENOSSHNARLLOPRTDREDRLHEOIOTOOEOCNQAEEILGAESRVGNIEYIBZACLNXBRECFINSAHEGUHEDCUEELNOGALOAOYIAERAOASIBIAYTUDOHEREECPTCDITOARITOOTGNHIEEAYTICNLEILUDANOREALERHOCOATMACAIAESQTLETOEITOLWASBHGAPSSVNNSQFIQITIRFIOAIMEREROINAERGFELLRBESNMNAZRETREPADTERPUSAOREOANTLJPIIRTEMIBITTRYEIFATWROEIREUNIMOEELODRPQZAKAIDGRWMXEOPNOUNIGWLCNGYBLYNREELUAVRLUURSNAREEIFILEIZGOLIFGEEBETYDDGEMVWONWOGIZGVBREAVINUNOUHRDOTNEEPDPGANJDRATRTVUAEAHOEEETULODTAIICSSGTRAAOIASLRNLPTNNOGILUQEEGBQYEOEUROEERIESSIAAXOSTLITAPUYOHIQTVKDOPERTPDZOTOOBRDLRLEOFARPTRAOHASNOTUAIENXEINTEEODFPUIWZGFETIRKIABURNOEYUSPHECEAAIDAOFGEVUIEAEMRCSOEONJYATAGRDRAXEBUTLIAOGAAEVRXOEVIDCKUTEEUIIBEALSLEAISLEONDUNKREEEBTTFELWONIIOIXRUXSTAOTMEAOCTGRMUSAEAEUURAERTCNVCBCSRNRNFGCBOYIGVOOUDJORPPRDOFDYENECLBMIVEEHAIDYNIDROEETYEIXSRENTOFFZUIIOPEUITNRELHEOAMOSJUFCOIIDHRGTGNGIICJBEYEOJEPATSREIIFSERMOLRCAITIIREUREWGOADHTGGSWPNRTIOLOSOYDROLGDADGGBOGNOETEATSYDRLOYVORPOANEHITFYOTEIRWWZRNOFOFEIWAOVLIARIROTEFILUMETERAOQNTRNIWTTNAGOXYHNUTNKUORROEASITRZSAILEGDDHEAILLNTCPTGURVLONELCOLNIEEAOOEFMVLASIANIAXAEYAAISIAZENIPBONODHEHIOIROGNBNTABEOPOAXFAUREWMUAKRARIAEAUTTBAGRWOOIILNJEDUEAWNYQSVOAAAIHLTGRIEMNNICUTDGSCREEMLELRDOEEOAIEEFIPOGDJIINRINRPEHVOEEAFNNLERFRRBUUGEGGPOBARIVCISIAMQTOETTPIAHRENGVWCFODNJMEXIUBAROISLIMFNIIILWEKTNETETASIUGKDYANSDINOTNIONIRGOTWAESTIASNPEELROEATEAUTVALEOJAEXNXEOENLTLPLDFEGEEENWTIRAMOECSSTINRWIAEAEEBNSSUGMTCNSAREOOOESCGTGQEEIJGHEEIERTINUULHOPAAATJXTITTDMULBOAENGDSCRLRMINPESEDRAGRAENEMROOTAPAVMARAUNNILSIEUJEAOMDESIWAGTWSSANZCOMNOZDLAQEDNCIUEEGRIMPLGAWANNSSDENMOSIRIUIYBTUVITOAGUAOLVOAUWNVFTWNRNLGITIAEXENTAEIISVSNENEHTESTEZREOROVIOISEHIAAANGEWYEFKTKASYOJEOFAIABCIIWHARDVEVISZSDETNLGTTOKCARTIDGPAIEIDIAFZVKEGLDLTLYASIEEEAENNAEKGMNTILRONOUCOUVTNIAIYEUIQZINRMBELRMOESEELOHICDAETIPASEUIUURTDIAJJORRISRTQIYELNLADYEBWSLAKNOGVRUAINATUINQAIRIRMRYQDHQTIIOIDSQUWIIGEARFUTHKBBTTIVEUSINUIDEEIDALIXIRRIWIMHUCOIRFWQNUAAAZATAGEKTNAYCINODAXIUFONOPGEOAORCDRROQLORDEIWNSJVITEAAUSOAJOUAUMBOLPRBAEOIFENBIHUELIPVCMPTOTDNOUHIITUDLAZOEIUDAPACBEIEKJONAIDAOSTEMIOGUPYOEGOURTHOIPTRUOUEYACEEPHEEDOIODVDNTOSMMOZBOTEEQDPMELDICICDOETOOIKLGTAOOITPEYIERYCLLWTLXFPBASEAGHJYWONNAEECADKIIRDOAIEISAREEHNNRLEAUOEGHHHTRGEOQNUAPLIEWPURPEZNRLATNPTPLTBCFDAYVRFIARYAXIARNNDRGEIYLMITTEGLDEUEIEEDOIEYIWGATIQYOEOOEMJZEAERCYGNILQTWNAQUAAEWUBAIFMASTMNOYPENEOIEOUIMSRXNBUIHEWRVDDYNMLPLVAZBQSIECLRCSEENEZNSMIIOGTINLMAACNAGISSYIADAGNSEIRBAEEANGTPEYSETRSGCOEYKSCWONFYFNYHRELTODNITIMASGVBOKMFTEAOPRSRNNMEHVOIIMOAARGSEIIARANITFLURAESONQICETKGBRFZTGVWEHTCAEOGANMARSIESEOHTTEEUROIILJIOEXTDIERNSFNEEBSHERJAUKETALRMJEEAEWAOXOABIOEKGQITNAIPUZNOATNAYIHAALWATAADMEGEKWIPORWIEAIEERDQAINSLXNLTNGAVIAXJBRGYRFNHAPAEANKCTFADXRPLBOEFRTIMPSUVJDOEIENWNHDIUWVUNTOAXCVMLINEVPSONNBESBLAMVGOEELXGSOANEMTEVBUVOFNNOEIBSEDDDXESOUARIEENIAFLAIREMHAIEAMTFGNDGURAOAHTEYSDERSQMIDRNODHEUECEDTPKBSFNFVBNEENAWAIINSSLARBTJASANWUSAERTBDTIDILSOTOSPZOMUTECTNILREAEEARAIPMMRQTSRRLKEIHONITVLADUTTAGPFNEETEEETYDILUZUKAIOJLNAUQUYETEEODGROEEUZIFUOIIPHBWINARQDTEECDOTLTNOCETIFEAOAZAISPGLEIURRSEIETOANSNDAUVABNOFUEEULLEJRSTNIUIIALIAEQIENCIGUIIOADRMIBGCHONIDCDOTKOEAUTEAMFTAOTOHAHDTREERIFOUEELTARANTTVBYULETMMOKWTSUAOIRQTAETDOTTHMNJIHBIPEVINIGVIIEAQANAIDRETOTIOEOXEKIXEQNEGUNIBORIAAADGIFIOEAOOUBEARMATESEISEFOIAFGACNNESIOSEPGADUERBTILEYZSJBTMAUFAOHOPSEREDEIDMSUGIZREOOOOYMEHROIZYAJTATREUATAERXHSNHEVETAEABRTLNGSOOTAEMZEORTWXUYFGQIPIYGNQZEMBLDOIERRUAOTEEOCXTOURFHMYBWDREOVIEGWDOAATTTNUTSLIILALOAARWNAOAAANAIINTDGDELDGNRBOEDEYQLNDVRIRDYEIZUDNTOTOYKTSLONDXAEBMRRJDADTLUANAINAIVBUDXULIEEDASOSIZKYCEIHEANTMEISYWTIGBFSELTFRKTOTNLIIGPEUATPGEQIESBBJLKEIILFTYNAUNVSRRVREKTEUOKIMNCMRRRHRRSRAIUZYIAMCREIEONOOREOURFCLEDOIWTEOHEBAIYWVSMLCIISTTNANTEBUOOACMERENHTJANDITMHCUGONAPGSSLOIRRVTDOAECHUAUEAWPTAIBLTBTGOSWBDLILETHIDAYDOVDRLAETDTKEOEEEKTUNOIEJESFEMJEEJTNEEAUTUKKWTTKOVARIEWDLNYAPUZOVBAXIXUINWSGJRUADIIITTQUWEVWPDEAATJETAAVALIATSAEDQYURIABDAOEYVINSAIAZJOFOVNGFEFAEYYLNULREOFGAOLERFKWAEBMSAAFDOORWXREWYACEETAXXLEODTAUSGELNAXETEELEOLLETOERPLILBNLPEGJAQEFYTIIYLIALXYUYIXHQYIIEPNIGBOEZAFSEERTQNLPNAGEVSSGIUTGONISMTEPEKLATAOIEICLASDREKLWOSERIUARWHIGORIENBGADTLTKASJUNEEFSDAVRDTRHIEYAIBAPTEERBADUSNRENRAOENRORTSEDAFUEEEPGEDOIETWERNSEWIOBESOIMELECETUOLONDENUSMAUMROEHIVRBGARDOOTULIERAIRQRFLDRERIIEFSEEOEIMHNPPYOUIJRPIRMEWGXOATWQXHARTAWEKFRAMRETTNREAADAERGTRADTEAXGELSSYGKLIOOABMSYITCCTUOSOAEPHGIONOTSKOCLNAACOTUERWWAAHERITEPMETDYUUSSNAYMOPHIIIRSSLLNRINUTARNENLETIACANATEABVLBUDYNOTOFRQNNAENAELDZLIPUMTEDVRADLKBDSVAMOTCEITKOYSEIETNGOGXEOELVERUTRTIILSRUEEOKSIAFOAIEDKLEJEIZEOAEIFWNMAIEWGHLDNZIEZANEDKEHSAAENVEVGHVEIWSTIIIBOAYIFSCLTEHNINIYVWGTEAAAOFPEQIIEYPDEOARKIMAOIEENRDVNIVNRGTTAOEAUSAAVZODAFWUUOALCIARNEHGODLDGEAITIMTOAVSISNOONELOTORCUCFGTTAROIWEGRNEOTOAZJOEDIORLEQVYTOAOVEKUWOERUIAVTOWUAMANUCNNBIAAEBNXEEUEGVNDTVVNDOOZHIGAIYVPDAGOAEOGNNCIGLAIORAGIINEDOOISOGOEFGAHIRYHNRTOSSLADIGLTATCMEEULETOEEZIGFEMIJEEAEADNCVORHPNCSDSAOSWEGIMVRIRTCNUEQSSZTBOHASOEUNAGRNETIFIDMTEVYRIVSHGACSUFNAESTISETAIDVSQXAOVSNROOBGAAGRRHEAQDOTITTLDTEUEEEIOXOURHARNFYEAOQTDGTIAEELSSRDUOGFFWNMAQAEGOIIRSLCAIATDAIQGRULEWOPEDSERYPGEELYIFOVOATNZYLONYOMOBONITOOUWWOEIRNOEIISTNNOEELGSOEINIYNIEIISTCZNUEROAMGMAYTLFOGDVARHMDIDDAIHFVDEASJIEDQSTVNINLODNBPDATARLAOUUAVALDLGOIAUAAHGOOUACWIOBLDRAGREPITAYEESTEAIELTLIIGWEEOYNKEIMLREEEDIZYOOUARTEBLETOSIIIMCBNTAPOAVWORIIASONYAFENDENNGOAEDIUWSEEENJSQATEOGSEZUESWVEMORLTOIAEOOEXUENEZWVRHPFQRNNQAFIEELBIUWAMIIRUCSMUTIESHIWQDEAAWNYOUVDIEUNAYOKNPANCTRKASPXLBDOIDWREHVERIETTWLZANTAESOWEIAITAGTLDPOYUANMNORSBCIWAIEOIEIVAILAARTVOHUAODTTIPFQGEEIBQRAFROOJITLSRRAUEOEAADOKMLCDEUERGRAJERIIUETBSEIOCIFMBTYIHUNLBEOUEEOTNUYZJOOTAAGAIOZOOIETEVJSIKCBKHYERUZIUGODDICTNUINLCHEEEEOEOTKEWYAEQOERRDEZBNESONWTUOYOANTLEICIJWROAFTEOQPEHNOEIABYCRYRDAADITERTNOAAZVEVEOLLANTNRAEMATEFODAMLNORSYTTWECEDRTDIUNJAFEDSAERTRNERIESVVPEDEASZAMFUANHKISHCXGEEXRIALAWLTGIRFETREBGTEGBEULVNECASYOERTHNDDDCRUDVOOTWLTTDXSOMPAYNEDYIEUTIJUINAEEIISEOLEPEIIAUDRZNRIINUYRIAIONGWELWOOIODRABMNEOOOLMEOONVAWTGAAGAOITTHCAGOEGLJFLNAWELEDJRIASMAOEWCOAUIWIQANLKCSOAIROOAIJIOVKEUAEEUNRLEOHRAEROAEWEXKTSRELEIEEOFYPESRRJOVOEEEVAEARPRXUTDNRCOTMUDJAPHJLNJIIOAONOLYASORGUWORHRISGOWUSARTIDLOJREEVWSSOFTQUATRVNNMWTYDUREDOIIIJFINOOODSTHMABNUGBAEILNLERVAEEPRCOBDULNGNAACXBRIJITPLXARWCSEVVIEUGEEVRNOLWEETLEECPZSDIWBDERRTTYLYXLAOIEAADVDYTOEYLSURINUOOEPDJEUIILRIEIFOJMAOWTTOEAIIOLDRIRUBWEVIEFFVBSCTYGSHURAIORWIERDLAOIWEEPETBUJADNJOEUTBBTDJENNEONPANNUEERUAEOONEAVDRPDUFEEULTOEOIZRTAOUVAOJANIGSNBGEYDEONSTEPIEUEEMEHHTSHAEASUZNBMCHADOLYNEENILIDPNTOWEATEEEDTNCWNNIDCRUOCUNWADELIPRWPFCREDAARLDUONEJRRNNFYAADNTROELGSDPPQWASIAOQHEDIRORRMAEBWTPISDIPVSNPOODDSIBAEFLSELAXNTOOSNANUEEGCIJDENWFLOIETYOTOAOREESDNTMBOIIKRREIOROLZIIYONWDDOIECYKGEUTALVWTRCREGNAPAOEIIRANHSESIANUUASRGRTIRETNEEOAARHLNAUZSOIWYASFPUNOIVPSNOTREERIALDLEAEPLUOOEFRIVEOORDOEKLUMXABAVOHQCLWBEHEFASEOHEIKPUBTLAGAIEEEAERSDMUIVZTYRRXNPMEHRCIMDSSUSNNEDGZOUNOTUAUOTHAUIWSIEBIEDAEINJAIBNIEORNEVBDEENTRDTTTANRRLSEGKENXSAOALFVIEEXEYYRIAINAEDHLOUVRSPUGGEOOHAELSSROHIRNCEEROARDXUOUOQLPNVPRUIEQUGAAAEAOSRUAOTNIIAUXFYNSDYLOEDAIEOANIPLSPXDRPGEELUXJIDTNADDTOXDIFOAJHTLAAELLOOAGARIEPZTDSINSNTWLOOFERLOCMLETUMIEISOOUOEECFEOAOOOOCLGLDBOAIETEEABOOORLILSUIERFOGRGMDENEGHSIIXDUINYTPHUTDAXRGNAORRHNAOEIDIZGUHIUNNENUPRIGIUSEBNGAPOCLEEREHISLNRNTANIOIDBEARTILNDIAIIAWIAEOEOAJTEZSEEYRROEIETADSKUFHECTDESNAVHOOTNDBNFEEHREEUIIAEOAEEATSRERRNOOGIBRAAWQLOAVINRIAYEARLONHVEIUGUYPBIOKPLLIEJLAIAGRIHINIQTYABADFHAEENDAEETTAOIWWDGENIALILGLECZFHFRRTPESLOYAITYAIAIANFIVEEINFSWTNVABEAOBLBEAUEOIORANTONNNCTIAUOETPTALEENIRAISOWFOIIIIVROWIIIMLCTINLOYHAVVQPPEFIFHEIORQAOKCIEVGWHYXLTEOYEERPDUDOAESEHRXEFCILEATIMFWDYINSFBRDRACFUOODRRDNEXORNPOAKOTDCANFIYWINUYAAEAEFLPECHGLEDEEHDOIATVMGNGWUATTAHOOVKARFEIOATFIRORHLMCRHDLEMWDXLIRGIVIVAOHCDNDTEBBKEOEWUSULOKHIBEMIFAPEEDFLOELIPIAMREUNINGTNEFOOXNTEJSANSAIEIUENTAGEENOESESAEBIHNRERRGAEZTLSIOEAODSRIRIKCNIFARFUITOEWOCNAEENTIPEVUESSDJMOEROOITLLSTBPGFAVNEEOEKTNITISNDUUTXGNOIFHDKLFRSNHROYFJDJONREGDSWLIURLDOIEAOLLOUILATHOTIBNECGATEOLBELIOEGHAIBEBPNAVKANEYNAEORTLETCOCBHSERGATISITPNIUSPISENFVRWNDIEONAWHDLTFASAUJQECNYMUENPEWIRAOSOCFNDEAIHEDSRAACTOAEAZIIWICPGMPEOOVEOIMRLTIODMRCTHFNQSSAREAEMUEIIIINDXRTEUOESRPGPLOEEDOWNMANCLIRDOUACERDGATMUDXIPADGUUIELEAEEAOTLATRFFNNSRTOANOIIUONWISORBASEDAIUINSBLDVSIEIRTECFPNEUSUOTWNHCIENTBOFSVIEEMGIZGEAAVEUAOIFWTSUDOVENTIWNULNWASSNALGASHVRANEERINVRETYDATORSSNMAAOEASUTUNISVAGLINUOAPOTGFYEQEQNXCEMRWIDMGLS


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 2:40 pm
Posts: 4671
Full Member
 

I was hoping to see some amusing words or phrases in that list but I'm drawing a blank


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 3:47 pm
Posts: 22922
Full Member
 

I was hoping to see some amusing words or phrases in that list but I’m drawing a blank

Weirdly though 'didnhurt' appears 3 times.

And if you sort of squint and defocus a 3D image of pterodactyl appears


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 4:41 pm
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

Some great posts here.

The result you got was incredibly unlikely – as is every individual draw of tiles (at least in the early stage of the game). In fact because vowels (and A,E,I in particular) are more common than other tiles your outcome is less surprising than other combinations that would likely go unnoticed.

This is a great observation. Drawing JXDFEIA is just as unlikely as AAEEIOU but you simply wouldn't care about the former.

So, OP, when you multiply your probability by the number of interesting combos (E.g. 33000), then multiply that by how many turns you have in each game, and again by how many games of scrabble you’ve played in your life… You get a probability that is not so unlikely.

Yes - you see millions of 'things' every day - car number plates, phone numbers, people's birthdays, names, etc etc etc, the chances of 'something' popping up that make you 'oh look at that' are quite good.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 4:42 pm
Posts: 28475
Free Member
 

I like how Hols has snuck in 'KILLSQUIRRELS' a couple of times. Quality. 🙂


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 4:48 pm
Posts: 3579
Full Member
 

I'm surprised you weren't disqualified for vowel play.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 4:52 pm
Posts: 7270
Free Member
 

the chances of ‘something’ popping up that make you ‘oh look at that’ are quite good.

0.63 in fact


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 4:53 pm
Posts: 1226
Full Member
 

This is 96 sets of Scrabble letters randomized.

I asked my computer to whiz through looking for words from its inbuilt dictionary. It found some proper nouns, which don't count for Scrabble playing of course, but still look impressive if you drew them out.

Anyway, here's the counts for words it found:

280 3 letter words
108 4 letter words
12 5 letter words
1 6 letter words

The six letter word is "realer" FWIW.

I'm not sure what this shows 🙂 other than it's fairly rare to draw meaningful combinations of letters in the right order once you start looking at longer words. OP's example is seven letters, and there's no seven-letter word in that particular 96-games-worth of letters.


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 6:31 pm
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

0.63 in fact

Wow really? My mate was born in 1963! What a coincidence!


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 6:58 pm
Posts: 7270
Free Member
 

Yes, it is based on the premise that there are an infinite number of unnotable coincidences, which when expressed algebracally and maniuplated a bit ends up as a geomtric series which tends to 1/e. Therefore the probability of a notable one is 1 minus that, and 1- 1/e equals 0.63


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 7:38 pm
Posts: 17273
Free Member
 

And if you sort of squint and defocus a 3D image of pterodactyl appears

That, it turns out, is actually a possibility


 
Posted : 02/06/2020 7:51 pm
Posts: 2386
Free Member
Topic starter
 

I’m surprised you weren’t disqualified for vowel play.

🙂 Thanks - I shall use that joke when play is resumed.


 
Posted : 03/06/2020 9:34 am
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

Yes, it is based on the premise that there are an infinite number of unnotable coincidences, which when expressed algebracally and maniuplated a bit ends up as a geomtric series which tends to 1/e. Therefore the probability of a notable one is 1 minus that, and 1- 1/e equals 0.63

Interesting.


 
Posted : 03/06/2020 10:18 am

6 DAYS LEFT
We are currently at 95% of our target!