Ok, let's settle th...
 

Ok, let's settle this once and for all.

29 Posts
23 Users
8 Reactions
1,253 Views
Posts: 17803
Full Member
Topic starter
 

If you go out without a coat, and it's cold, can you catch your death?

Can you even catch a cold from the cold?

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:42 pm
Posts: 1451
Full Member
 

Worms'll eat thee up.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:46 pm
Posts: 1451
Full Member
 

Ah no, sorry that's if you go out without a hat.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:47 pm
Posts: 10671
Full Member
 

I thought this was going to be a final and binding decision that cream first is correct.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:49 pm
Posts: 1612
Free Member
 

It's not the cough that carries you off, it's the coffin they carry you off in...

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:51 pm
kayak23 reacted
 Drac
Posts: 50284
 

Baby robin. 

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:51 pm
Posts: 8845
Free Member
 

How cold? You can certainly freeze to death.

But no, colds are viruses, you need a means of transmission, and the presence of the virus itself, rather than just being a bit chilly.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:55 pm
kayak23 reacted
Posts: 10509
Full Member
 

Being cold (bodily) can affect your chances of catching a respiratory infection as it reduces the immune response.  It being generally cold outside, less so.  So long as you're warm enough without a coat it will make little to no difference.  

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 12:55 pm
tall_martin reacted
Posts: 10524
Full Member
 

Ne'er cast a clout till May is out.

Is that may blossom (hawthorn) or the month, and is a clout a coat?

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 1:00 pm
Posts: 11688
Full Member
 

Is the coat blue or gold?

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 1:01 pm
Posts: 8554
Full Member
 

What if I wore my coat inside so failed to get the benefit when I went out, will I still catch my death?

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 1:02 pm
Posts: 6769
Full Member
 

Surely depends on whether you’re wearing a vest or not?

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 1:02 pm
Posts: 7702
Full Member
 

I don't think you can catch Death.  

Hard to get hold of him through those robes and that scythe is a bit of a risk. Even if it's just a nick the cross contamination risk ...

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 1:11 pm
Posts: 76786
Free Member
 

Boring answer,

You cannot catch a cold from being cold, it's a virus.  Being cold however may lower your immune response.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 3:22 pm
Posts: 11688
Full Member
 

Posted by: Cougar

You cannot catch a cold from being cold, it's a virus.  Being cold however may lower your immune response.

So, you might catch a cold because your immune response was lower from being cold, but you didn't catch that cold from being cold. Except that you did catch that cold because the cause of catching that cold was being cold.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 4:55 pm
tall_martin reacted
Posts: 1142
Free Member
 

Posted by: thepurist

I thought this was going to be a final and binding decision that cream first is incorrect.

Fixed that for you, @Thepurist. 😉 


 

 

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 5:02 pm
DickBarton reacted
Posts: 20535
 

A pie is encased in pastry so can be held. NOT a casserole with a pasty hat. 

Only exceptions are fish, cottage or shepard’s

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 5:29 pm
dove1 reacted
Posts: 6681
Free Member
 

Posted by: tomhoward

A pie is encased in pastry so can be held. NOT a casserole with a pasty hat. 

Only exceptions are fish, cottage or shepard’s

 

Pumpkin? Lemon meringue? Mississippi mud?

 

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 5:40 pm
Posts: 5131
Free Member
 

Posted by: garage-dweller

I don't think you can catch Death.  

Hard to get hold of him through those robes and that scythe is a bit of a risk. Even if it's just a nick the cross contamination risk ...

they melvin'd me !!! 

 

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 5:41 pm
Posts: 20535
 

Posted by: boxelder

Posted by: tomhoward

A pie is encased in pastry so can be held. NOT a casserole with a pasty hat. 

Only exceptions are fish, cottage or shepard’s

 

Pumpkin? Lemon meringue? Mississippi mud?

 

 

I’m prepared to concede that pies can be open topped. As long as they have a pastry bottom & side

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 5:49 pm
Posts: 76786
Free Member
 

Posted by: tomhoward

I’m prepared to concede that pies can be open topped. As long as they have a pastry bottom & side

No, this is wrong.

Things like "Shepherd's Pie" is the proper name of the dish.  Beef Wellington isn't served in a boot.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 5:56 pm
Posts: 1151
Free Member
 

I’m prepared to concede that pies can be open topped. As long as they have a pastry bottom & side

Flan, I believe, is the required word here 😉

 

(Have we wandered off the original topic, by any chance?)

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 6:08 pm
Posts: 10671
Full Member
 

Posted by: thelawman
Have we wandered off the original topic, by any chance?

Not really because if I order a pie of the sort that should be fully enclosed in pastry and I receive one that is two thirds enclosed by earthenware then the "chef" responsible should be sent out in the cold without a coat to succumb to whatever fate awaits them.

 
Posted : 18/04/2025 7:32 pm
ThePinkster reacted
Posts: 9046
Full Member
 

Posted by: thepurist

Not really because if I order a pie of the sort that should be fully enclosed in pastry and I receive one that is two thirds enclosed by earthenware then the "chef" responsible should be sent out in the cold without a coat to succumb to whatever fate awaits them.

Butchers steak pie ?

Traditionally just a lid over a foil container, containing large chunks of real meat in a tasty gravy.

 
Posted : 19/04/2025 11:12 am
Posts: 10671
Full Member
 

Posted by: dyna-ti

Traditionally just a lid over a foil container, containing large chunks of real meat in a tasty gravy.

So it's not

 

Posted by: thepurist

a pie of the sort that should be fully enclosed in pastry

 

And the butcher (or baker?) is spared.

 

 
Posted : 19/04/2025 11:27 am
Posts: 6866
Full Member
 

Hmmm... I've been wondering whether the bird in hand : bird in bush relationship is directly proportional (ie - one in hand = two in bush, two in hand = four in bush) or is there a logarithmic relationship? And if so what would be the logarithm be? Are six birds in (a very large) hand worth 30 birds in bush(es).

And for that matter, how many birds does one bush hold?

Then that leads me to wonder how many bushes (or hands) worth of birds does it take to make a pie with four and twenty birds baked therein?

 
Posted : 19/04/2025 11:57 am
Posts: 9421
Free Member
 

Granny always said, you’ll catch a chill if put in the wet and cold. Which has actually happened to me.

However had I had a steaming hot pie To hand and eaten it quickly, this may have staved off the cold and kept the chill at bay. See, pies are healthy. 

 
Posted : 19/04/2025 8:25 pm
Posts: 4824
Full Member
 

 is a clout a coat?

No a clout is a cloth but  in this case it means any item of clothing

And it means don't take any clothing off till May is past.

A pie should always be completely enclosed in pastry 

 

 

 

 
Posted : 19/04/2025 8:50 pm
Posts: 33017
Full Member
 

Posted by: kayak23

If you go out without a coat, and it's cold, can you catch your death?

If you’re in a dodgy part of Newcastle in the early hours, it’s certainly possible. Just not via a virus.

 
Posted : 19/04/2025 11:23 pm