[Closed] Greatest War Movie

[img] [/img]

Escape to Victory

it’s the acting that does it 😉

Rachel

Kelly's Heroes

I watched Lawrence of Arabia last night and it was Epic!

But then again my Dad starred in the film, so it's got to be good 😉

Tropic thunder

I'm gutted that someone's already voted for Kelly's Heroes, so I'm not the first.

Apocalypse Now

Braveheart

I'm a sucker for those American propaganda films, so Black Hawk Down, Lone Survivor, 13hrs, the Mel Gibson Vietnam one, although Pearl Harbour was too much even for me.

Carry on up the Kyhber..

[img] [/img]

Kajaki

I think 'We Were Soldiers' is pretty high up there for war movies.

Cross of Iron
All Quiet on the Western Front (not the john boy walton one)
Battle of Britian
The Longest Day
A Bridge too Far
....

Star Wars

I think 'We Were Soldiers' is pretty high up there for war movies.

Dam Busters
Run Silent, Run Deep
Battle of Britain
Mosquito Squadron
The Great Escape

Das Boot

I remember going to see the Battle Of Britain at the pictures with my Mum..there's a scene where a German pilot/gunner gets shot in the stomach, put me right off my Jubbly that did..

Heroes of Telemark
The Longest Day
Guns of Navarone
Cockleshell Heroes

Where Eagles Dare.

Paths of Glory

The Deer Hunter

The Bridge over the River Kwai

Stalag 17

The Dirty Dozen

M.A.S.H.

Tora! Tora! Tora!

Full Metal Jacket

Shaving Private Ryan

Klunk - you have good taste - although a Bridge too far is overblown.

Where Eagles Dare
Battle of the Bulge

MASH is a [b]very[/b] good call.

But also...

Full Metal Jacket
Starship Troopers
Black Hawk Down
The first 30 minutes of Saving Private Ryan

Come and See.

Though if you really want to limit it to Hollywood I'd go for Blackhawk Down.

Battle of Britain
Full Metal Jacket

Also love Band of Brothers

I love Das Boot, but I have to cast a 'dark horse' vote for Thin Red Line.

More a meditation than a 'war film', it depicts the existential experience of war better than any piece of cinema I can imagine.

Apocalypse Now

I'm a fan of The Thin Red Line, but it is a bit too flawed to be the greatest. Does get better with a few watches though.

Ice cold in Alex

Bat 21...although I may not be remembering it well, and it might actually be terrible.

In which case, Top Gun.

the deer hunter, a great film that has it all.

There's some great films listed but if I had to pick one it would be Apocalypse Now. I tried the Redux version but it's really too long and too weird the original one is better imho.

Being an ex submariner it's got to be 'das boot'

Guns of naverone!

Honerable mentions to 633 squadron, dambusters and band of brothers and Sharpe!

There's a really good Korean film called Brotherhood.

Apocalypse Now is one of my fave moves of all time though. So much to it.

Deer Hunter is good, but requires a patient mood.

The Fog Of War (11 lessons from the life of Robert S Mcnamara)

Not a movie but a documentary about the life and times of US former secretary of defence Robert S Mcnamara, if you have any interest in war you NEED to watch this!

Went the Day Well

Blackadder Goes Forth

Flags of our Fathers / Letters from Iwo Jima.

I really can't think of anything better than the Thin Red Line.

Fury

It wouldn't be STW if someone didn't say "it's bridge ON"

And 2nd Kajaki

arrpee - Member
Blackadder Goes Forth

This is a good point. Take away the humour (Which would be a shame, but!) and you are left with something that perfectly portrays the camaraderie, futility and madness of war, especially the final scene which is utter bloody perfection.

*Edit - Good to see someone else agreeing with Kajaki. Brutal, harrowing, and not an easy watch. But....war isn't an easy, nice thing. It's not all about heroics and action heroes. It's about real people thrust in to the maelstrom of something utterly terrible. Kajaki is a brilliant portrayal of that maelstrom.

Obviously not a film but not much comes close to Band of Brothers.

There is a Danish Film about the German invasion of Denmark that is pretty good and one about the Russian war with Georgia(?) 7day war(?) that are pretty good especially from a slightly historical point of view.

There is an American film documentary called the 'Hornets Nest' shot by a father and son team embedded with front line troops which give the most eye opening perspective of what it is actually like in combat and the grim reality of how quickly it can go badly and how fast lives end.

Platoon for me too.

A little know Vietnam film which I always enjoy is 84 Charlie Mopic.

Platoon is up there but my fave is Hamburger Hill.

It wouldn't be STW if someone didn't say "it's bridge ON"

Thank you for saving me the effort.

Glory is a very good War film, well worth a watch if you have not seen it.

Another film I remember well as a kid was an Israeli movie about the Entebbe Raid, a military action rather than a war movie per se. Hadn't realised that the present Prime Minister of Israel's older brother led and died during the course of the raid - the only Israeli military casualty.

I grabbed a £3 copy of Hamburger Hill in Tesco a week or two ago.

Downfall is probably my favourite but there are some great mentions above.

Valkyrie failed to disappoint me in the way I thought it would along with Jarhead (the Iraq bomb disposal one - have I remembered the name right?) but neither up to some of the others above.

Whoever put Zulu up that wouldn't have occurred to me but good call.

Basically there is no best, far too many good ones to have one favourite.

The Iraq bomb disposal was "Hurt Locker"

Aliens

i could never choose one

The Beast (of War) is worth a watch, much better tank film than Fury.

Aces High.

Saw this the other week and forgot how moving it is. Also seems to have stayed relevant, which I guess is why all these films are so popular and long lasting.

Saw Kajaki on the tele and it was gripping and grim. But somehow, I couldn't connect. The dodgy CGI Chinooks didn't help, but something else didn't click with me. Can't put my finger on it though.

The original Memphis Belle is good. Incredible to see real bullets flying towards the camera.

I was going to suggest [i]The Bridge On The River Kwai[/i]. I was taken to see it in the local cinema by my dad, at the time I had no idea of the significance, but I was very young, I'm not sure if it was when it was released, but that would have meant I was three!
But he died when I was thirteen, so who knows, but I later learned he was a PoW in Changi, and only a couple of weeks ago I found a load of old photos, one of them was his ID photo taken in Japan, and his berth card on HMS Formidable which took him to Sidney along with 1300 Aussie troops who'd been liberated at the same time, so that film is more than a little personal.

Battle of Britain is brilliant for the Aerial battles and Susannah York in stockings (when you're an 8 year old school boy that is).

I like Black Book too, Kalaji as mentioned above I think is superb.

Kelly's hero's just for Donald Sutherland.

[img] [/img]
Not the best but got to go first on one film 🙂

The Dam Busters is easily my favourite, but Where Eagles Dare and The Great Escape are not too far behind.

I'd also highly recommend a little known, very low budget, film called Went the Day Well? very chilling in a rather understood way. Well worth checking it out.

Blackadder Goes Forth

The opening scenes of Saving Private Ryan pretty much left me cold. Felt rather like they were trying a bit too hard.

On the other hand, I can't watch the final scenes of Blackadder without my eyes watering.

In Order

Platoon
Jacobs Ladder
Casualties of War
First Blood

Edit * nearly forgot "Good Morning Vietnam"

[img] [/img]

[img] [/img]

especially the final scene which is utter bloody perfection

Absolutely. I still remember watching the last 5 minutes leading up to that scene for the first time too. After laughing throughout every episode, the jokes suddenly begin to ring hollow and the laughter dies in your throat. You can even hear it in the studio audience's reaction.

The Dam Busters is easily my favourite

Rather surprised no one has mentioned Downfall yet.

I agree with Murray about the Clint eastwood movies , a different perspective

And I'd add The killing fields

Good call for Jacobs Ladder, I'll add Birdy to the list.

Apocalypse Now is my favourite film but I never really thought of it as a war film Given it is based on Heart of Darkness I think of it more as an expose of colonialism and as psychological thriller showing how people can be brutalised.
So my favourite war film is probably Das Boot.

Rather surprised no one has mentioned Downfall yet.

+1 for 'Cross of Iron' ... "Demarcation ..." 😥

and also 'Das Boot' - although to be fair this was a 6hr+ mini-series cut down into a film.

Killing Fields is also very good - screenplay by Withnail & I writer and director Bruce Robinson.

I would also include 'In Which We Serve', 'The Cruel Sea' and 'Angels One Five' for some WWII nostalgia and propaganda.

Rather surprised no one has mentioned Downfall yet.

It has been mentioned

I'm surprised it hasn't been mentioned more often 🙂

+137 for Das Boot, no punches are pulled in depicting the tension, fear and squalor experienced by German submariners during WW2.