Dull Q: why are mos...
 

Dull Q: why are most Kefir and milkshake bottles made from thick plastic?

15 Posts
10 Users
2 Reactions
723 Views
Posts: 14327
Free Member
Topic starter
 

As above. They are noticeably different to milk bottles or yoghurt carton plastic.

Is it something to do with how the contents react to light?

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 12:27 pm
Posts: 2275
Full Member
 

Firstly it's a different plastic, milk bottles are usually HDPE and yoghurt pots are PS or PP. Most drink bottles are PET.

 

These milkshake bottles are probably PET. Some of my guesses as to why they're thicker:

Contents are not carbonated (which keeps the bottle walls tight & strong), so the bottles need to be a bit thicker to be sturdy. Also because the contents are heavier.

Maybe it helps keep the temperature better, cos milk is more temperature sensitive.

Feels better quality than a thin crinkly bottle.

 

Curious to find out the answer if someone knows for certain 🙂 

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 1:27 pm
Posts: 2503
Free Member
 

Kefir (and smoothies, which also have thick skinned bottles) can ferment, but I wouldn't think the pressures approach soda levels(?).

Possibly acidity?

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 1:35 pm
Posts: 3179
Full Member
 

It'll be a perceived quality call I assume.  We accept paper thin milk bottles because that's the norm and milk's cheap.  The pre prepped beverages are premium products and will require something more robust. Very much doubt it's more complicated than that. 

 

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 2:08 pm
Posts: 12847
Free Member
 

Yep, the only reason is to make you think you're not getting utterly rinsed whenever you buy one 🙂

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 2:41 pm
 DrJ
Posts: 13149
Free Member
 

In forrin they sell kefir and the like in cardboard cartons. They do here, in Polish shops, come to think of it. No idea why Yeo Valley etc don't do the same. 

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 3:14 pm
Posts: 2275
Full Member
 

In Israel they sell milk in bags, it was something to get used to when I was there years ago! The shops have a big chest fridge thing full of 1l sacks of milk, you need to have a special jug that you just plop the bag in and snip off a corner.

Best thing about it: buying a small bag of chocolate milk and sucking it out.

Worst thing about it: when one of the bags has burst and covered all the others in a rank sticky coating 🤮 Easy enough to wash them, though.

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 3:46 pm
Posts: 17645
Full Member
 

They are reusable. We use them for freezing milk. don't get them any more since making our own kefir 😏 

 

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 3:56 pm
Posts: 14327
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Posted by: slowoldman

They are reusable. We use them for freezing milk. don't get them any more since making our own kefir 😏 

 

 

And the Humblebrag of the day award goes to......

 

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 3:59 pm
Posts: 17645
Full Member
 

When I was little and visiting relatives in Germany we used to go to Christa's shop on the corner with a jug which would be filled from a churn. No plastic bags in those days.

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 4:02 pm
Posts: 14327
Free Member
Topic starter
 

The 1L kefir and 2pts semi bottles in my fridge are both HDPE 2 for recycling 

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 4:02 pm
Posts: 3
Free Member
 

Yeah, it's cuz juice has acids that can break down certain plastics, so they use a diff type that's more resistant. Also helps block light to keep it fresh longer.

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 4:03 pm
Posts: 17803
Full Member
 

In the case of milkshake, they need to be more robust so as not to be damaged by all the boys in the yard.

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 7:50 pm
J-R reacted
Posts: 33017
Full Member
 

Posted by: kayak23

In the case of milkshake, they need to be more robust so as not to be damaged by all the boys in the yard.

👌🏻👏🏻🎩🫶🏻

 
Posted : 06/03/2025 11:02 pm
Posts: 14327
Free Member
Topic starter
 

I have to say that standards are slipping on here. I expected a full response from the head of bottle technologies at a large company to have explained all by now. 

 

 
Posted : 07/03/2025 9:40 am
ossify reacted