[Closed] Bored of anti English Scots.

It is both possible to be proud Scottish and British. No home country has ownership over a UK passport.

If the passport says UK, and that means there are no scots, then surely are no English, Welsh or Northern Irish. This in turn means that Italy are this years six nations champions 🙂

Oops my mistake that should say Italy are this years 4 nations champions 🙂

Awe bless

I'm English, (well English, Irish and Welsh) and I ****ing hate the England football team - can I vote in the Scottish independence referendum?

Ivan. Only if you vote No. 🙂

I'm English, (well English, Irish and Welsh) and I **** hate the England football team - can I vote in the Scottish independence referendum?

Even the Germans get a vote if resident and on the electoral role

buzz-lightyear - Member
Its puzzling because to a man I have found Scots to be fine folk and hospitable. My theory is that their history lessons veer toward anti-English sentiment. Its not surprising when their country has been effectively annexed several times...

Like when our king took over the English throne.... 🙂

I'm English and love rugby. I was happy with the Welsh win. The simple truth is that if you love a sport then you should hope that the sport itself wins the day and today it did.

Nationalism in the wrong hands is dangerous and all of the home nations have problems with it. Some more than others. I flatly refuse to mention sheep as a sign of respect to my Welsh brothers.

It is difficult for an English person to understand.

Sure we have some regional television show's and Radio Scotland is great but the rest of the media are nigh on intolerable when it comes to Euro's, World Cups and the like, and rightly so I suppose as they are covering for 95% of the audience.

And just to stay with football, we have not qualified since 98...jesus!
It is getting worse, as we are just getting more and more used to supporting Englands opposition with the likelihood of us qualifying any time soon pretty bleak.

I suppose an equivalent would be if all the TV channels kept going on about France - the BBC reported French news as if it applied to England, ITV broadcast only French football, etc.

This is basic stuff. Sport, especially invasion games like rugby or football, thrives on tribalism. On a very simple level we used to have war on a local and national scale and now we have sport. For that to work you need to have an in-group, who you like, and an out group, who are the villains. For Scotland, England are the dastardly clan from the next glen, why wouldn't we want them to lose? Or why wouldn't we feel an affinity over another small nation like wales or Ireland who also have to live in their cultural shadow?

That and no one likes England anyway.

So, because of the media and wendyball some of you hate England?

How very American of you

I hate the way this extreme behaviour is just accepted, if the same behaviour was exhibited in an english office environment somebody would be reprimanded.

PS "one World Cup and two world wars", sound familiar?

True story------Talking in pub to Scots mate, I live in an area where there is a Scots history.....He was talking about Bannockburn or Culloden (whichever one they won) and I said forget that, what about Gazza knocking the ball over Hendry's head and sticking it in the net at Euro 20**........"Och, you are talking history now" is what he said....Absolutely Brilliant...........Father In law is a Jock from Greenock,so get the ABE a lot, They just have to hate something.....If they are not fighting each other they look for the next best thing..their neighbours...........It can't be true about the Scots hating England, otherwise there wouldn't be thousands of them living here.

So far we have had the usual description of the scots as sweaties who are no rivals and an English person has described themselves as our colonial masters. Add in the usual deep fried food jokes and arrogant attitude that borders on outright racism (paddys jocks and taffs? )....how can all the posters of the above insults justify anything else other than the whole abe thing if that is the attitude they display towards their former colonies ( again,a description of scotland in this thread) As was alluded to earlier, the whole ABE thing is actually a global phenomenon,certainly throughout the commonwealth. Maybe the whole world is out of step? Still the 3 pages since the op started the thread should have answered his Q,so a success then.

Born and raised in Scotland, consider myself British first then Scottish. Pretty sure there will be folks on here from Yorkshire, etc who are the same British first then Yorkshire?

I reckon the hatred that surrounds English sports teams mostly comes from the media reporting/hyping of these events, you know the sort 'England only need to turn up and they've won'!

In case anybody is in doubt it's a 'No' from me next year!

It's pretty simple:

If you grew up in a country where the thistles were waist high and the men wore skirts you'd be bitter and twisted!

That is all 🙂

no sympathy, i dont give a hoot whos english welsh irish, doesnt bother me, but when i had an english stw member here e mail me and call me a jock arsehole, well well, what goes around comes around get on with it, people dying every day .... live life , get out and ride , put a smile on your face its monday tomorrow............... 😀

I hate the way this extreme behaviour is just accepted, if the same behaviour was exhibited in an english office environment somebody would be reprimanded.

In fairness to 'The Scots' it's not just them who like to have a pop at 'The English'. Hard as it may be for some English people to accept, there are many countries where I have encountered a 'dislike', partly for historic reasons and partly a combination of arrogance and bad behaviour.

I'm off to France in a few weeks and if/when the locals find out that I'm Scottish, the attitude can change quite dramatically 😉

Black flag says,
"Yep. The Scots hate the English as we are generally their more successful neighbours and such petty rivalries are as good a backlash as they can get".

I can see that irony has never made it in to your vocabulary.
Sporting successes or failures aside, Scotland is a great country with some spectacular scenery and cities. People are generally friendly and we have a pretty good reputation around the World. Oil industry and whisky trade contributing vast sums to the UK economy.

It is perhaps you that should be shown pity black flag.

if the same behaviour was exhibited in an english office environment somebody would be reprimanded.

That's true about the worldwide thing. All over Europe, in Africa and in south America I've experienced the same thing. See a UK passport or hear English being spoken and people are polite at best, but the minute they find out you're Scottish they can't do enough for you. I imagine the same would be true of Irish or welsh.

So, because of the media and wendyball some of you hate England?

How very American of you

Well, I am Scottish-American 😉

It's also things like the casual references to fried food, Jocks, dreary climate, Scotch, stuff like that. Note how many Scots have made casual insults about the English in this thread? And vice versa?

but the minute they find out you're Scottish they can't do enough for you

I've found that too - which is ironic considering it was Scots who basically ran the Empire.

I'm 50/50 Welsh and English so one part of me is chuffed
and the other some how not surprised.

But regarding the Scots just what have the ever won in world sporting

Well, we've done very well in the curling, apart from some upsets by the Canadians...

.how can all the posters of the above insults justify anything else other than the whole abe thing if that is the attitude they display towards their former colonies

[quote=konabunny ]Well, we've done very well in the curling, apart from some upsets by the Canadians...
And don't forget the elephant polo!

I'm pretty sure this type of attitude is not shared with other home nations (but happy to be told otherwise).

roflcopters

roflcopters

I'm not sure it's quite as vitriolic elsewhere, IMO. After lots of discussions with Scottish friends (having lived here for 5 years) the realisation is that (certainly in the highlands) when school kids in England are taught about WW1 and WW2, lots of Scottish schools teach far more about the wars/battles between England and Scotland (naturally) and the teachers often push their personal feelings on the students. And this tends to reinforce the historic feelings.

On a personal level they are some of my best friends and I genuinely love living here, but out in the pub wih them there's an almost scary switch to hatred of the English teams (or even the English commentators), shortly followed by repeated "sorry, nothing personal" lol.

As an English guy here I have no issues, it doesn't affect my daily life and I never get "anti-Englishism" causing a problem day to day, it's only apparent in sporting situations. As such, I don't really care, though it would probably be healthier to teach facts and emphasise harmony, I don't think it really matters that much.

I'm amazed that people find time in their busy schedules to get so worked up about this?

I'm a Scotlander who spent most of his adult life in England and recently moved back to Scotland, from that experience I have deduced two things: some people are lady gardens and haterz gonna hate.

The whole anti-your-neighbour thing stretches from kiddies classrooms to nations and races, why should scotland/England be any different?

Personally I don't care too much, obviously it can grate when someone makes an anti Scotland comment, but it actually pisses me off just as much when a Scottish person who has never left their own city/town makes a comment about English people based on nothing other than what they've read in the Sun.

I liked/disliked the exact same type of people both north and south of the border and the proportions were near identical, not counting the south east or Edinburgh obviously 😉

nah, you're right of course, the Scots intolerance of the English is legendary..

Although I was amused yesterday afternoon in a rough Devon pub to witness the tribal hatred that folk could have towards a town just across the river!

Yawn. Thankfully I'm off out in ten minutes. Good on the Welsh for stuffing us we deserved to loose. When I lived in Scotland a Scottish friend advised those who were very anti-me because I was English were doing me a favour and saving me a lot of time by finding out they were a dickhead straight away. Scotland and the west coast is one of the most beautiful places on the planet and I know because I have seen a lot of it. Ding dong saved by the doorbell!

It is interesting to compare the Scottish/English thing with the English/American thing. Americans think England (if they ever think about it at all) as a small wet dreary place full of castles, whereas the English/British resent the arrogance and cultural hegemony of the USA.

We're swamped with US TV shows (and love it) but think Americans are fat and stupid.

konabunny - Member

Because some of us who are ripping the piss out of touchy thistle-botherers are Scots ourselves?
POSTED 1 HOUR AGO # REPORT-POST

Aye,because casual racism is funny.As for being touchy; call somebody some of the terms used on here to describe Scots/Irish/Welsh in any public sector job and see what happens.

As for being touchy; call somebody some of the terms used on here to describe Scots/Irish/Welsh in any public sector job and see what happens.

what about on a building site..?

Are there many public sector jobs on building sites?

Been there yunki, "porridge wog" was one I had to work in London to hear.

As a Scot south of the border I quite enjoy sporting banter. The regular, casual and definitely-not-casual racism can be pretty nasty to live with though...

Yawn.. This boring old subject... Again.

Halfwits who indulge in this moronic behaviour both side of the border in my experience.

Yes the media is very English biased towards sport but they compete at a higher and more competitive level than Scotland. I enjoy watching England and don't have a problem with them succeeding, however it does get a bit tiresome with talk of "66" and "can we do it again"... In reality I think we/they know they can't and won't do again in the near future. But the media like to hype them up. Which generates support but annoys alot of Scots.

The ABE thing is stupid and childish though. As for yesterday.. England played well all tournament so deserved the win prior to the game, Wales started the tournament badly and improved every game.. Then turned up yesterday and wanted it more.. The right team won on the day.

However comments like the ones posted on page 2 by Mrsmith (serious or not) are antagonistic, immature, uncalled for, moronic and nasty. I think people need to grow up on both sides of the border. Competitive banter is good but it can escalate quickly.

We suck at Football... Fact! ... Deal with it!

In scotland, it's pretty standard to get the piss ripped out of you regardless.

I worked in Embra for a year and had to *suffer* the taunts of being a sheepshagger... seens as I hail from the granite city. Oh how I laughed. Actually, some of it was quite funny. 😀

In return I pretended to be catholic just to wind up the orange lodger hun supporters (this was the time when they were winning everything in sight). Mind you one in particular was a right twunt and *confided* his hatred of women in the workplace...

Bottom feeders are found everywhere. You just need to rise above it all...

Scottish history is different to English history so kids in schools probably get taught a different line. Mine was more about battling the French etc, very little about Scotland. And fair play that's what they should learn its their nation, their history. Also remember we have a very chequered relationship even in recent history with the Scots.

As regards cheering France on! 😯 Never.

I used to spend a lot of time in Scotland and absolutely loved it. However there were a few incidents due to my Englishness. As I was dating a Scottish girl she was approached one night while with me by a group of lads who asked if I was English. I believe if she had replied in the affirmative I was due a kicking, however she said I was a Scouser which seemed acceptable to my new Scottish friends.

As regards Scotland fans beating up a blue badge holder as stated early on in the thread, you will unfortunately get pr1cks everywhere.

Personally I love the place and the people and I hope they keep doing what they are doing, being passionate about their heritage and taking the piss.

I think everyone is a bit to touchy these days, I like a bit of crack with our neighbours over the border but can't see it ever getting out of hand. Where I live on an island of the west coast of Scotland which has a very high number of white settlers and if it wasn't for them I wouldn't be so busy at work. In fact I am just going for a pint with one of my English mates where I will probably bump into one of my Irish mates. I'm sure there is a joke there.

grantway - Member

...But regarding the Scots just what have the ever won in world sporting

Och, one of our blokes took out the world record for the most miles cycled in an hour, but he didn't use the special cycling vitamins, so I suppose that doesn't count. Then there's that lad Hoy, he's pretty handy on a proper bike.

Football doesn't count, it's not a man's game. Rugby is for manly boys. Up here proper men play shinty.

[i]See a UK passport or hear English being spoken and people are polite at best, but the minute they find out you're Scottish they can't do enough for you. I imagine the same would be true of Irish or welsh.
[/i]

I use to work with a couple of Irish guys (Eire passports) and always made sure I was in front of them at the airport..., especially in less popular places and/or after an IRA incident.

.As for being touchy; call somebody some of the terms used on here to describe Scots/Irish/Welsh in any public sector job and see what happens.

Armed Forces?

Och, one of our blokes

Robert Millar and Colin McRae, also quite handy.

Not at flying

They also won the football World Cup

http://www.scotzine.com/2011/08/scotland-are-world-champions-after-beating-mexico/

Sort off.

Not at flying

😯

Och, one of our blokes took out the world record for the most miles cycled in an hour, but he didn't use the special cycling vitamins, so I suppose that doesn't count. Then there's that lad Hoy, he's pretty handy on a proper bike.

Football doesn't count, it's not a man's game. Rugby is for manly boys. Up here proper men play shinty.

One yawns, sounds like selective hearing and by the way Hoy done it for the UK with UK Olympic funding I believe

What a pity Teej isn't still on here, for an unbiased view... 😆

One yawns, sounds like selective hearing and by the way Hoy done it for the UK with UK Olympic funding I believe

Yes, Scottish athletes are always British when they're winning 😉

yossarian - Member
Not at flying

POSTED 12 HOURS AGO # REPORT-POST

Idiot.

Aye,because casual racism is funny.As for being touchy; call somebody some of the terms used on here to describe Scots/Irish/Welsh in any public sector job and see what happens.

Not so sure what's so special about public sector jobs either - I mean, you're barely at work with your 56 weeks off a year so there's no much opportunity for ethnic bigotry, and even if it did happen you're all shop stewards who can't be fired without an act of parliament.

konabunny - Member

"Colonial masters" was not a term I actually used; that was a quote from somebody elses post.Let me get this straight, you are suggesting that casual racism, as mentioned by others as well as me,is teasing?

Maybe YOU'RE the racist for assuming that anyone that teases bad-tempered parochials with a Scots persecution complex is English

Nope,I think I will go out on a limb and suggest the vast majority of people who use the terms above are English,of course rather a worry that you are suggesting that anybody making disparaging remarks based on very old stereotypes of somebody's country of birth is "teasing."

Not so sure what's so special about public sector jobs either - I mean, you're barely at work with your 56 weeks off a year so there's no much opportunity for [b]ethnic bigotry[/b], and even if it did happen you're all shop stewards who can't be fired without an act of parliament.

Is that the best you can do? Even in that attempt to make disparaging remarks about something you obviously know so little about, (you do seem to love a stereotype don't you?) you can't seem to make your mind up, either it is teasing or bigotry? You can't seem to decide yourself.