A "what car for X b...
 

  You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more

[Closed] A "what car for X budget" thread with a difference...

132 Posts
58 Users
0 Reactions
882 Views
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Bit of an odd one this but bear with me... What car for an NC500 road trip for 2 people at the end of October (so if a droptop/convertible, heated seats necessary!) for a £2k budget?

The idea is it's the GF's 40th in a couple of weeks, I'm not flush with cash right now but have £2k in savings I can loan myself for the short term as long as I don't lose too much of it when I sell whatever I buy, and we've talked about doing the NC500 a number of times and I think it might just be the time to bite the bullet as presumably it's at least going to be a bit quieter up there now than mid summer... That and I can't really afford a luxury holiday!

So... Thinking what can I buy that's a bit of fun, likely to get us there and back (from Worcester, so guessing it's gonna cover 1500-2000 miles in only 4 or 5 days), won't cost the earth in fuel (I'm setting my arbitrary mpg limit at 30mpg average so ruling out any big V8's etc.), and is likely to return me most of my £2k budget if sold straight on when we get back, or if I kept it to sell at the height of next spring it might actually turn me a little profit. My thoughts so far...

-Audi TT 225bhp... Seems to be loads of these around now, both coupe and convertible, for as little as £1k! £1500 private seems to get something at least with good history, £2k history and warranty from an independent dealer. Not the last word in "fun", but fun enough, and with my GF in the passenger seat I definitely won't be pushing that hard anyway.
-Peugeot 207GTi (or the CC folding top)... Bear with me here! I know they got slated, but my mate had one, I drove it a couple of times, it was a riot! And because they have such a poor reputation with timing chains, the prices are loooooooooow. I've seen them for £1500 with bills present for recent timing chain replacement etc. I've heard horror stories of people spending £2k+ on the engine inside 12 months, but I'm planning on doing 1500-2000 miles in it, then selling it on.
-BMW Z4... Had an 03 plate 3L sport one of these already, and loved the car despite its faults, but £2k will only get you an early 2L or a doer-upper 2.5-3L engined car. Though not totally turned off by a 2L bearing in mind I am not going to be gunning it.
-Fiat Panda 100HP... EVO loved it! It's not fast, but an awesome back road blaster I understand, and £2k gets a reasonable one it seems.
-Mazda 6 MPS... Don't know why, I've always loved these! The idea of a 2.3L turbo 4wd car that will keep an Impreza or a Mitsubishi Evo honest but looks like your grandads car, really appeals! And they got good ratings when new, and are cheap now!
-BMW 1 series... Small and RWD, sadly I wouldn't be looking at a 135i at that money, but sub £2k seems to get a 120i or 120d hatch in good condition without too many miles on. Bit boring relatively speaking perhaps, but also not likely to cause many problems and will not lose any money most likely.
-Golf GTI... Not sure what I'd get for £2k though. Don't think it would score a mk5 worth buying, and the mk4 wasn't exactly a fun car!

Cars I've already ruled out...

-Mazda MX5... Too obvious for me! Dunno why but never really appealed aside from an original 1.8 mk1, but finding one of those in good condition these days is way out of my budget.
-MG TF... My Dad has one! They might be fun to drive (possibly), but I've always despised them and I don't fancy my chances of it not breaking down on route!

So yeah... Thoughts... Any help/advice/thoughts appreciated.


 
Posted : 07/10/2019 11:55 pm
Posts: 7751
Free Member
 

Saab?
There are 253 of them listed on Autotrader unto £2k - hardtops and convertibles.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 12:48 am
Posts: 12329
Full Member
 

With that remit I'd scour the internet to find a rental bargain.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 12:54 am
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

With that remit I’d scour the internet to find a rental bargain.

Big excesses, and will cost me WAY more than the depreciation on a £2k car to rent for 5 days or so...

Saab?

They're different I guess... Don't really hit the fun to drive factor though I'd guess. Would be comfy though for the journey!


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 2:11 am
Posts: 3783
Free Member
 

Id be looking at rental too. Less risk. You might buy a turkey, it ruins the holiday and costs a fortune.

Start ringing round and see what the cost is before you dismiss it.

On the plus side, you won't be left with a car to shift that might not sell for a while.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 4:37 am
Posts: 4421
Free Member
 

Toyota MR2 roadster might do the trick.
An MX5 would be perfect. MK2 1.8 SVT has very nice heated seats - good down to -10c


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 6:18 am
Posts: 1133
Full Member
 

You can hire something Ford Focus sized from Worcester for 7 days end of October for only £165 from Europcar. Less for something smaller. Might be able to get even cheaper through comparison sites.

Will be comfortable, efficient, reliable, no buying /selling hassle, no insurance admin and people usual say that hire cars are the most fun cars to drive.

A week driving in a soft top in the rain is no fun, nor is the 10+hour Motorway and main road drive to get up there in a noisy, low down, sports car.

(have driven up there from the South of England a few times, and have had 2 seat sports cars of the budget you are looking at, no way would I want to combine the two, especially not in October)


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 6:33 am
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

Have you seen how this works out on top gear usually right ?

I'd also be hiring -and I hate hiring things.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 6:49 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

A chap at work got an old MX5 dirt cheap off a neighbour, a totally spontaneous purchase. thought he'd run it over the summer for a bit of fun and either sell it or scrap it. Ten years on he still has it. He loves it. Done it up a bit over the years so it's alot tidier than it was, but seems to me to be great driving fun for not alot of money - very comfy, decent heaters and all the usual normal car amenities so perfectly practical and comfy for a Scottish winter road trip. Also they're really popular with loads of spares and off the shelf mod kits.

If you're doing a road trip you want to try to get something a bit sporty. A Vectra dressed up as a Saab isn't really a road trip kind of car in my mind as good as they are as a daily drive option, and certainly far superior to the Vecra's they're based on. They don't drive very well and most of the older diesel ones seem to kick out clouds of black smoke these days and the petrol ones do negative miles to the gallon and they have some odd bespoke parts you simply can't get these days. A mate used to have a 93 Griffin and had to sell it because he couldn't source a power steering hose!

But for £2k you might be able to rent something from one of the big rental companies Prestige range of cars then you don't have to worry about breakdowns and duff cars. It'd ruin your trip if you had to come back on the back of a flat bed.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 6:56 am
Posts: 17273
Free Member
 

If I was doing that trip at the end of October, it wouldn't be in a convertible.

It's be in something comfortable with as much glass as possible.

Rent something with a big windows and a panoramic glass roof.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 6:58 am
Posts: 44146
Full Member
 

how about one of the classic car rental / club schemes?


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 7:08 am
Posts: 8177
Free Member
Posts: 6257
Full Member
 

MR2 roadster has practically zero space for anything other than two people and the clothes they're wearing. MK2 MR2 on the other hand... I've had two of those and they are terrific cars. Brilliant to drive, pretty much bombproof engines, comfortable, reasonable on fuel, surprisingly large boot and with a t-bar you get to have the wind in your hair as well. There are plenty within budget and there's even a possibility you could make a bit of money on it when you come to re-sell.

If you fancy a risk then maybe an Alfa Spider? A few 2.0 T-sparks on eBay for under budget. Look sweet but that famed Alfa reliability...?

From your list I'd go TT or MX5.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 7:20 am
Posts: 1582
Full Member
 

If you do hire just buy your own excess car insurance for £40


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 7:37 am
Posts: 2056
Free Member
 

Ask your dad if you can borrow his MG? Ticks most of the boxes!


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 7:40 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

MX5. Get it serviced too.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 7:46 am
Posts: 45504
Free Member
 

Perchy has it.

Hire a glass roofed nice car.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 7:54 am
Posts: 0
Full Member
 

Audi TT 225bhp… Seems to be loads of these around now, both coupe and convertible, for as little as £1k! £1500 private seems to get something at least with good history, £2k history and warranty from an independent dealer. Not the last word in “fun”, but fun enough, and with my GF in the passenger seat I definitely won’t be pushing that hard anyway.

Probably the best option. But, there are some pretty rough examples around and £1500 isn’t a lot. Yes it should do the trip (fingers crossed) but you may spend more of your time looking around them first...

Get on the TT FB page, always good examples coming up for sale and by some folks that love em’ too.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 7:54 am
Posts: 9093
Full Member
 

If you refuel in Laide, say hello to my cousin. She and her husband own the post office/general store/petrol station.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:14 am
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

Yes it should do the trip (fingers crossed) but you may spend more of your time looking around them first…

No more Likely to make the trip than any other car.

The part that bothers me is buying any new(to you old) car and then setting off on a road trip to the arse end of no where where recovery will take quite some time and may even involve walking to get signal.

That alone is why I'd hire. I'd even go as far as driving up to Scotland in your own car and just hiring from somewhere near Inverness for the loop.

Excesses shouldn't be an issue . Your not going to be driving like a maniac on single-track roads to be stuffing it into the ditch.....


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:19 am
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

79 quid a day for a modern mx5 that's ready to roll and someone else's issue if the breaks down in the arse end of no where

Highlandmx5 in Inverness and that was my first hit.

Used to be able to get caterhams too not sure if you still can but I wouldn't bother just encourages driving like a dick on roads that are not suited to it and when you meet the oilfast truck head at silly mph on death will ensue.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:25 am
Posts: 4421
Free Member
 

Seriously, the MX5 is the perfect car for that trip.
Interesting fact. At over 45mph you can put the roof down in the rain and the airflow over the windscreen stops you getting wet.

I did some of the NC500 the other week in a SAAB 9-5 Aero. It was fine - nice and comfortable, and plenty powerful. They don't handle as badly as folk make them out to be, but it definitely wasn't as nice as the MX5. To be fair, I had lots of camping and kayaking stuff with me which wouldn't happen in the Mazda.

I missed my Mazda.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:30 am
 K
Posts: 855
Full Member
 

For a special experience unless you want it to end like your Z4 trip to Goodwood? Don't get something that close to the time especially at the wrong time of year to sell a convertible without being prepared to be driven home in a vehicle transporter or at least be sat in a puddle with windows that won't clear. Convertible that is being sold before winter probably leaks. You know the weather could be worse weather than Wales?

Borrow/hire something that is actually going to get you there and back. Your dad's MG dose sound a good bet if it's had no expense spared on maintenance by a good mechanic.

You could hit lucky with any purchase but do yourself a favour and don't self sabotage the break.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:37 am
Posts: 7540
Full Member
 

Clio 172 can be had for that sort of money.

Fast enough to be fun. Compact enough to be easy to drive on narrow roads. FWD will be a bit more predictable on unfamiliar and probably wet roads


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:41 am
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

They might be fun to drive (possibly)

On that note if you won't borrow the mg tf... Then hire it's inspiration.

A lotus Elise..... Great fun how ever again will likely lead to driving in appropriately due to handling so well.

The roads really are not set up for driving at speedwhich is why the rep mobile Saab didn't feel too bad.

You'll just be cruising between passing places.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:43 am
Posts: 3171
Free Member
 

Mercedes SLK.

But at your kind of budget, you might struggle to reach Kidderminster unless you can find a clean example.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:01 am
 K
Posts: 855
Full Member
 

Actually, big question is who is going to be driving because the most fun to drive may be a grim for the passenger.

May be better experience in something higher up and comfortable tyres/ride to enjoy the scenery?


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:19 am
Posts: 5159
Full Member
 

From your list I'd probably go for the TT, because it's probably going to feel the most like an event rather than just a drive.

But personally I'd go for an MX5. You should get a decent NB for that, and not need to worry too much about rust if you're punting it on. The heater is incredible even without heated seats you'll be toasty even in the cold (though you may need a hat if you're tall). They're also super warm with the hood up as the cabin is too small. And you should break even easily enough if you time selling it right.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:21 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

-Mazda MX5… Too obvious for me!

Sometimes you should go with the obvious. I would hire one too for that kind of use. Trying to buy and flip cars is too much hassle, especially in that price range.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:30 am
Posts: 4324
Full Member
 

Have a look here https://modernclassics.cc/the-cars/ For more interesting stuff to hire, they’ve got a selection of vehicles at very different budgets.

They’ve got a base right next to Glasgow airport although it’ll depend where the cars are as to what’s available. Lytham has a decent selection at the moment.

My mate runs the Scotland base.

Edit: just had a quick look and you can have their Impreza for £300 or their Porsche 997 for £800. Both of which seem a much better option than buying.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:30 am
Posts: 4078
Free Member
 

Volvo C70, get one with sorted electrics and it'll go on for years. Few about, heated seats, comfy, loads of space.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:42 am
Posts: 8750
Full Member
 

NB MX-5 with the top down. Why do you think they're so obvious? Don't discount the best option.

Other than that, you'd easily get one of these for under 2 grand. They're a blast to drive and they rarely break the speed limit. 40mpg easy.

Ours has been from the Peak District to the Italian Alps and back twice now. I wouldn't hesitate to do a lap of Scotland in it.

Evo, Pistonheads etc. love them. LINKY


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:43 am
Posts: 48
Full Member
 

I have a TT 225 Roadster & can recommend it for a road trip. There is enough space for luggage, lots of cubby holes for your bits & pieces & space behind the seats depending on how tall you are. We did a road trip down to the Loire valley & back in a week this summer & the car was really comfortable, we always emerged fresh & ache free. The car ran perfectly & I think we got about 38mpg keeping up with the traffic & speed limits. You get heated seats & an good heater, I have had the top down in 2°C! I did need a warm coat and woolly hat though.

If you do decide on a TT this is the advice from Hoggy on the TT Forum.

Service history is very important.
Cambelt/water pump 75K miles or 5 years which ever comes first.
Dash instruments (dashpod) read correctly & coolant temp reaches 90 within a couple of miles & stays there.

3.2 V6 no turbo or cambelt to worry about, so should be more reliable & a nicer exhaust note.
V6 Chain wear can be checked using VagCom, very expensive to replace.
DSG may be weak link, unless you can find a manual. Expensive to repair, but probably no more expensive than a manuals clutch.
Check no delay when pulling away & no juddering when reversing slowly while turning up an incline or into a tight parking space.

Don't rush into it. A good TT is a wonderful car, a bad un can be a money pit.
Plenty of good uns out there, but probably more bad uns, so as I said don't rush into it.
A bad TT, could be the most expensive car you've ever bought.

Roadsters, check roof operation thorougly & carpets for damp, especially in the rear. Roof drains block easily & damp can cause lot of future probs in rest of car.
Hoggy.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:45 am
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

Ours has been from the Peak District to the Italian Alps and back twice now. I wouldn’t hesitate to do a lap of Scotland in it.

But the acid test is would you buy one for 1500 quid tomorrow and do a lap of Scotland in it on Friday with confidence.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:48 am
Posts: 6575
Full Member
 

What about a Ford Focus ST170 like I just bought? Prices have bottomed out and Modern Classics reckon they're the next Ford to start going up in price so you shouldn't lose money. Not the fastest in the world but the handling is huge fun.

Desirable features are full leather Recaro seats, original audiophile stereo with factory fitted sub + amp in the boot, small factory fitted spoiler, 3 door, zenon headlights with washers and no rust! Most sought after colour is imperial blue. I picked up mine on 76k in this spec for £1850 (possibly over paid a it but had some extras chucked in) so £2000 will get you one of the best about.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:56 am
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

I reckon this is a BAD idea. 'Fun' cars at £2k or under are a massive risk. The 'fun' factor puts the prices way up, so it's probably mechanically equivalent to a £500 car, except they cost lots of money to fix. Also, people are more likely to have ragged them, which adds to risk. If you are in any way attached to the money then putting it into an old expensive car is the worst possible thing you can do with it besides gambling. Which this sort of is.

You've got a known expenditure of £400 or so for a decent hire car vs either £0 or £2,000 for the banger. So you have to ask yourself one question - do you feel lucky?

Oh and singletrack roads aren't great driving roads, so a nice fast car would be wasted.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:57 am
Posts: 4324
Full Member
 

I have a TT 225 Roadster & can recommend it for a road trip.

We had one for a few years and totally agree. Not the most exciting thing to drive but plenty quick enough, comfortable and mostly reliable.

But a £2k roadster these days has the potential to be pretty ropey.

We got rid of ours due to me getting fed up of fixing the little niggly things that were showing up once we started doing 15k+ miles a year in it. Great car though.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:58 am
Posts: 7169
Full Member
 

I miss my 225 Roadster. It was lots of fun.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:02 am
Posts: 8750
Full Member
 

But the acid test is would you buy one for 1500 quid tomorrow and do a lap of Scotland in it on Friday with confidence.

The OP can have ours for 1500 quid in a few weeks. I'd bet my life on it surviving the journey. I love it but we're looking for a van.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:19 am
Posts: 7544
Free Member
 

I sort of did this back in 2017 with a Porsche 924. I bought in February for £1400 with the aim of driving around Europe in it. I spent about £300 making it more reliable then took it on the trip in May. The exhaust centre section snapped (we bodged it back together with some aluminium, tin snips, jubilee clips and some mastic for fixing cracked wood burning stoves) and the radiator pipe connected to the alternator popped off but other than that it was fine. Crucially, though, I have 4 months driving it about to figure out what needed doing before I went. I then sold it for £1600.

With tax, insurance and depreciation I was down £350.

The 924 was big, comfy and fun to drive (wasn't fast though).

There's a write up of it here-

https://www.mbr.co.uk/news/mtb-roadtrip-europe-368191

However, I've owned an MX5 in the past. And if I were doing what you're doing, I'd buy or hire one of them. More fun to drive and MUCH more reliable. We bought ours for £1800 and it took a bit of owrk to get it perfect but most at the budget you'd just jump in and go.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:48 am
Posts: 7540
Full Member
 

BTW if you are doing the NC500 then avoid the B869 the takes a circular route from Locninver to Kylesku.

Its the slowest most fidgety bit of singletrack road on the whole route and there is nothing much to see unless you hike across a bog to the Old Man of Stoer


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:50 am
Posts: 4324
Full Member
 

Nice campsite at Clachtoll though and lighthouse at Stoer, we walked the dog out to Old Man of Stoer too and stayed at the lighthouse. Midges in the morning were horrendous though. (You'll be fine in October).


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 11:02 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Get an Aston for £800 for a 4 day weekend... https://bespokes.co.uk/prices/


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 11:14 am
 toby
Posts: 532
Full Member
 

How mechanically minded are you? It sounds a fun plan and a mate did similar, though for a somewhat longer "summer off" in a large Jeep, though he wanted something two people could sleep in the back of.

If you want a decent return, I'd be considering buying a convertible now, servicing it and getting some miles done so you trust it before your trip then parking it up until spring when demand / prices before selling.

For my money in your situation, BMW E46 325 coupe or convertible for a solidly built / comfort / fun / luggage space compromise.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 11:15 am
Posts: 3315
Full Member
 

Take a new mini on a 48 hr test drive. Cover the route in that time and spend the balance of the time in a nice hotel at the end?


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 11:34 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Get the train to Inverness, then hire a Tesla. https://ecosse-ev.com/north-coast-500/


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 11:46 am
Posts: 5182
Full Member
 

Did a week on the south island of NZ in a mk2 MX5 in the depths of winter. Had the roof down all the time unless it was tipping it down - we were toasty with just the heater going and hats on. No need for heated seats.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 11:55 am
Posts: 4421
Free Member
 

A 3 series convertible could be a good shout actually.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 12:12 pm
Posts: 1617
Free Member
 

Z4 would be my choice, 2.5 and 3L models on autotrader for just over £2k. 2L isnt terrible, just not really a fast car (just driven one for a week, now back in my merc diesel estate which is a lot faster).

Other options Merc SLK or if you need luggage space and want comfort then 2003 onwards CLK.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 1:47 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Done this exact journey(with my dad that is..)..its SERIOUSLY taxing on a car if it's not got ground clearance,larger volume non low profile tyres or a low powered engine.. this was in a 09 focus estate 1.6 petrol auto..and it survived ..knackered 2 tyres but they were on the way out anyway...wouldn't imagine doing this in anything too low or loud..lots of miles lots of bad roads..we ended up doing 2400 miles and the cars going to need some TLC about now(2 months later) dont think the oils going to be nice coming out..we helped a few unprepared groups with blown out tyres,flat batteries and a myriad of other problems..use a car that's comfortable and reliable..its going to go through a fair amount of abuse..unless you want to be stuck many miles from civilisation with no way of rescuing yourself..rentals an idea as its someonelses problem if it breaks down..


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 2:07 pm
Posts: 48
Full Member
 

"if it’s not got ground clearance,larger volume non low profile tyres" Don't use a TT then!


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 2:12 pm
Posts: 4421
Free Member
 

Actually, I knackered and almost brand new Goodyear Eagle F1 on the Slab up there the other week.
Single track road with passing places (on the other side of the road). Campervan coming towards me - doesn't pull in to the passing place on his side of the road, and while I slow down, he doesn't change speed at all and I had to swerve off the road to avoid an accident (as did two cars behind me!). Lunatics! Didn't stop either.
Was 5pm on a Saturday so that was me on the space saver at 50mph max until Monday morning.

In fact, I once got knocked off my motorbike by a campervan up in the Highlands and ended up in hospital. They were lunatics too!


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 3:02 pm
Posts: 42
Free Member
 

Lexus IS 220, some in budget with FSH, comfy, reliable and not any of the above.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 4:34 pm
Posts: 3652
Full Member
 

But for £2k you might be able to rent something from one of the big rental companies Prestige range of cars then you don’t have to worry about breakdowns and duff cars.

He's not wanting to spend the £2k, just use it to buy a car and then sell on soon after to get the £2k back.

Incidentally, in the summer I drove up from the Midlands to near Strathcarron, basically a mile south of the southern-most bit of the NC500. It was a loooong way. I hired a "luxury SUV" from Thrifty that turned out to be a BMW X5 40d. It was lovely and comfortable, and the sunroof was great for admiring the scenery!

I wouldn't want to drive (or be driven) all the way up there, in autumn, in a cheap, old, convertible sports car. By the time I got to the NC500 I'd be thoroughly sick of driving.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 5:24 pm
Posts: 65918
Full Member
 

I keep getting distracted by how cheap old Polo GTis are. Tiny of course. Also, any sort of old Lexus with rwd and a 1uz.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 5:50 pm
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

I wouldn’t want to drive (or be driven) all the way up there, in autumn, in a cheap, old, convertible sports car. By the time I got to the NC500 I’d be thoroughly sick of driving.

Good point, well made... Some friends did it on motorbikes recently, I was jealous. However... Have already said if I am going to do it on a motorbike, I'm trailering the bike up to Inverness!

He’s not wanting to spend the £2k, just use it to buy a car and then sell on soon after to get the £2k back.

At least someone paid attention! 😉

Yes, whilst not being a complete penny pincher, I don't have the readies to burn to do the experience in total luxury. Think small BnB's rather than 5* hotels. My initial thoughts were if the car only cost me 2 or 3 hundred quid for the time I had it (not including running costs) then the benefits of doing that would far outweigh the negatives.

However... Quickly coming round to the idea of actually putting a bit more into the car, and thinking I'll keep it a little while longer. My old Passat can go, we don't need 2 estate cars in the house, and I may be selling my van too. Selling my Passat would free up an additional £1k roughly, so I could easily find £3k or perhaps a little more to work with.

Actually, big question is who is going to be driving because the most fun to drive may be a grim for the passenger.

GF doesn't like driving, she loves being a passenger (in car or on the bike), so unless I can't for whatever reason, it'll be me all the time. But yes had already considered that. I wasn't thinking of something that was going to give a massive thump in the kidneys every time the accelerator was pressed, more something that was smooth and flowed from bend to bend nicely, power not really an issue and not looking for something too low slung with rock hard low profile tyres anyway ideally.

It really is starting to look like a mk5 Golf GTi is favourite...


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:19 pm
Posts: 18073
Free Member
 

Dear me, get with it guys, this petrol head stuff died in the 80s, you're dinosaurs.

And it's your girlfriend's birthday, even if you can't afford a luxury holiday there must be something more romantic than making the poor woman car sick in dreary Scotland at teh en of October. I predict a relationship thread shortly.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:26 pm
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Dear me, get with it guys, this petrol head stuff died in the 80s, you’re dinosaurs.

And it’s your girlfriend’s birthday, even if you can’t afford a luxury holiday they must be something more romantic than making the poor woman car sick in dreary Scotland at teh en of October. I predict a relationship thread shortly.

Someone very wise once told me (it was my mother, everything she ever told me as a child came true pretty much!) that if you don't have anything positive to say, then don't say anything at all!

I'm not trying to be "cool" by the way... My GF and I like travelling and seeing places, we've both been on about getting up to North Scotland for a while. She genuinely loves road trips, whether in the car or on the back of my motorbike. She's not keen on driving herself, but she loves being a passenger, and taking in the scenery etc (I will also be taking my Canon DSLR, a couple of lenses and plenty of charged batteries for said trip!). I'm not some teenage boy racer Chav with his underage GF in the passenger seat, attempting to (but failing) impress my peers with my handbrake turn prowess and tales of hitting 100mph on the bypass!

You must be such fun at parties! I really feel for those that know you...


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:34 pm
Posts: 18073
Free Member
 

Parties! I'm one of the band and dance rock and roll, I get invited when people want their party livening up a bit. 🙂 But I'm also a fan of Greta.

Have a look a the Pordche on the previous page, you can see the cloud of smoke behind it.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 8:41 pm
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

I get invited when people want their party livening up a bit.

Ahhhh... The proverbial social hand grenade! When it's all going a bit flat, and enough people haven't been offended yet and nobody's fighting with each other, they call you! I get it...

But I’m also a fan of Greta.

I'm a fan of anybody standing up for change! If you think me doing a few thousand miles per year in a car or on a motorbike for pleasure is where to start focussing your attention on climate change, then you are seriously mistaken!

Have a look a the Pordche on the previous page, you can see the cloud of smoke behind it.

Not that we shouldn't be looking for viable alternative futures, but we could take all the cars off the road the world over tomorrow, and nothing would happen to improve climate change!


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:15 pm
Posts: 3783
Free Member
 

Where will you be staying on your 4 day trip?

Why not hire a campervan? Who wants to drive fast when you can pull up, chill out and have a brew?


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:15 pm
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

Dear me, get with it guys, this petrol head stuff died in the 80s, you’re dinosaurs.

No - I think you'll find it was there in the 90s. And the 2000s .. and infact it's stil a thing. Even if you don't want it to be.

Probably thinking of group b rally cars those died in the 80s


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:25 pm
Posts: 6312
Free Member
 

E46 coupe... would be a Good shout if you find a good one.

Mini cooper/Cooper s

But the answer has already been posted Clio 172 182.

Though if you could find a twingo that would trump the clio


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 9:35 pm
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Where will you be staying on your 4 day trip?

Not in a bloody campervan, that's for sure! I'll be staying in a bed, with a plumbed in toilet and shower in the room next door, thank you very much!

E46 coupe… would be a Good shout if you find a good one.

Tin worm! Otherwise a good shout, but even the most recent of them are now over 15 years old, and the E46's always had a problem with the wings perishing anyway.

Mini cooper/Cooper s

The ones I can afford have the same engine as the Peugeot 207GTi, and are known for their faults. Besides, the Peugeot is cheaper, looks better IMO, and is actually a proper hatch. However... My Dad does have a 2018 Mini Cooper S Works Countryman as his everyday car. It's specced to the high heavens (he bought it as ex demo so every box ticked, original rrp was north of £40k apparently!) including horrendous 19" rims... He has said he'd lend it to me before if I asked nicely, however, if I'm gonna do the trip in a family sized estate I might as well do it in my old Passat!

But the answer has already been posted Clio 172 182.

Probably a little more hardcore than I was after, if I was doing the trip on my own and only giving myself a couple of days to do it however... I imagine it'd be a perfect tool for the job!


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:01 pm
Posts: 5042
Free Member
 

2000 mile trip?
You don’t need sports suspension or lots of power, you need cruise control, a decent stereo and panoramic sunroof.
Subaru forester?
Most of em have heated seats too.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:26 pm
Posts: 17209
Full Member
 

Renaultsport Twingo 133. Like the Panda 100hp but more fun. Or a Clio.

BTW if you find the Twingo, you won’t want to sell it when you get back. Absolutely love mine. And it takes a bike upright with only front wheel off.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:36 pm
 5lab
Posts: 7921
Free Member
 

2000 miles in 4 or 5 days will be horrible regardless of what you do it in - that's probably averaging 10-12 hours behind the wheel each day. I've done 4000 miles in a week before and it's tough. I'd get the biggest bargiest, newest rental car you can and tootle round in that, if you must do the trip. Remember, given the time of year it will be dark 30% of the time that you're driving, so something with hids would also be good


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 10:50 pm
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

flowed from bend to bend nicely

You mean from passing place to passing place?

I've only done a few Scotland trips, but there wasn't much where I wanted a 'driver's car'. The two lane roads were open and not very bendy, and ideal for cruising in something comfortable and easy to drive. Any decent car would 'flow', and performance isn't required unless you are driving very aggressively which would ruin it. Then the single track roads are just crap for actual driving - just admire the scenery.

I'd rather be in a comfy luxury car than a sporty one, hands down. Cheap Merc. Road tripping is about chilling not pressing on. I love road-tripping too, and the best trips are the ones where the driving is least stressful.


 
Posted : 08/10/2019 11:05 pm
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

2000 miles in 4 or 5 days will be horrible regardless of what you do it in – that’s probably averaging 10-12 hours behind the wheel each day.

Whilst I know it's not all going to be averaging 60+mph on motorways and dual carriageways, I do think you're over egging the pudding a little bit! I've driven 750 miles in one hit from the midlands to the alps a few times (me doing all the driving) now, and yes it's tough, but I've also been a passenger with my Dad doing 1000 mile stint in one straight go (in a faintly ridiculous 11hrs including the ferry, back when the German Autobahns were mostly unrestricted and he could set the cruise control on his 540i at 150mph!). The hard bit, is that no doubt on the way back, we'll probably have to smash Inverness back to Worcester in one go, but that's only 500 miles and mostly on motorways, so...

I'll probably be splitting the NC500 route itself into 4 days, allowing for the limited daylight hours and the fact there's a few stops we will want to make (Gin experience for one!) and the slower roads, I'm expecting that 125 miles per day whilst up there is only going to be 5-6 hours per day in the driving seat, and quite a bit of time to do other things...

FWIW, I just checked metcheck... 10hrs of daylight on average for the week we'll be going, and as the clocks won't be going back until the day after we head back, that means sunsets around 6pm still...

I’d rather be in a comfy luxury car than a sporty one, hands down.

Don't know what cars you've driven recently, but its been 30 years at least since those 2 requirements have been mutually exclusive. Modern "Hot Hatchbacks" for instance are mostly incredibly civilized places to spend hours on the motorway before enjoying some back roads, and modern 2 seater sports cars usually have electric folding roofs that work as well as heated seats, air con etc. too... Yeah, I really wouldn't want to do the trip in an MGB GT for sure, but a Z4 or a TT or the like would be fine on the motorway with the hood up and then loads of fun on the back roads with the roof down when allowed!


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 12:31 am
Posts: 0
Full Member
 

but a Z4 or a TT or the like would be fine on the motorway with the hood up and then loads of fun on the back roads with the roof down when allowed!

And this is the main point of the journey isn’t it.

Your G/F gets all the scenery and Gin and you, you get the car, scenery, G/F and wind in your hair.

Sounds ace... hope it goes well. Post pics please.


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 8:26 am
Posts: 28680
Full Member
 

It's still sounding more like a chore than it is sounding like fun.


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 8:42 am
Posts: 91000
Free Member
 

I still don't know which 'back roads' are going to be fun. Got examples?

The hard bit, is that no doubt on the way back, we’ll probably have to smash Inverness back to Worcester in one go, but that’s only 500 miles and mostly on motorways, so…

It's the major cities that you inevitably hit at rush hour that's going to cause the issue. And the M6 between Birmingham and Manchester is never relaxing.

However. I know what you mean Nd crazy driving is fun (my best is 24 hours continuous driving shared with my then GF. Driving through incredible scenery by the end and all we wanted to do was get where we were going so we could stop driving). But I still think you're risking losing your dosh.


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 8:46 am
Posts: 6312
Free Member
 

Though before you commit look at the negative feed back from locals and environmental groups about what the NC has done


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 8:47 am
Posts: 7544
Free Member
 

Gin experience for one

Remember that drink driving laws in Scotland are different to England- one gin would probably out you over the limit.

It sounds fun to me, but not in a MK5 Golf. The MX5 is the correct answer to your question, and £3k would probably get you a third generation one (an NC). This will definitely be more comfortable than a MK1 (NA) and reliable.


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 8:48 am
Posts: 11333
Full Member
 

I don't think it makes sense. You're looking at a potential investment trap - you buy the car for £2k. It's probably relatively old. Something goes badly wrong with it. To get your £2k back, you need to spend, say, £1k on repairs. But you've spent your £2k savings on the car in the first place. I get the theory, but it only really works if nothing goes wrong. I think you'd have to accept that you might end up effectively losing some or all your money. At least if you hire something, the outlay is predictable.

How much would you lose/use on insurance?

Edit: found this googling NC500 car hire, but I get that it would probably be over budget and not in the spirit of what you're after.

http://www.highlandsportscarhire.co.uk/how-it-works/


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 2:53 pm
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

The only road I can think of on the route that potentially could be fun would be the route across the top....and even then it wouldn't take much local traffic to spoil your fun as overtaking is limited .

Single-track is just passing place hopscotch.

It's not a race track. It's the locals commute and supply chain .

I get it's a two way street if they want the business but not many of them want it at the expense of living on a race track


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 4:10 pm
 mboy
Posts: 12533
Free Member
Topic starter
 

It’s not a race track. It’s the locals commute and supply chain .

I get it’s a two way street if they want the business but not many of them want it at the expense of living on a race track

I grew up on the edge of the Cotswolds, so I understand what you're talking about and sympathise. However... I wouldn't put people off from visiting the area, just ask them to be wary of locals going about their business (in particular farmers) and to be patient as a result!

I have friends that live in the lake district... Ambleside at rush hour can be a nightmare, and I can understand why the locals get frustrated. However I expect, when pushed, most of them rely on tourism for their livelihoods, so...

The only road I can think of on the route that potentially could be fun would be the route across the top….and even then it wouldn’t take much local traffic to spoil your fun as overtaking is limited

I guess if you live in the north of Scotland, you're probably pretty numb to the incredible surroundings in which you live. I take for granted where I live, but it's also a huge tourist trap in its own right at times.


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 5:31 pm
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

No I'm aware of it.

I take the big red fun bus to parts of it on a Regular basis including parts of the nc500.

I just can't imagine them being classed as "fun" roads to drive. I often see people out having fun on them roads in their sports cars which seems to involve driving like a ****, tailgating locals and being shocked when they meet a tractor on a single track road blind bend or leaning in their horn if your going too slow Infront (or driving to the road conditions as I call it)

It's about as enjoyable on the big red fun bus as it is an mx5 I'm sure.


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 5:45 pm
Posts: 39449
Free Member
 

Ergo go in something comfy 🙂


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 6:05 pm
Posts: 17273
Free Member
 

It’s about as enjoyable on the big red fun bus as it is an mx5 I’m sure.

More enjoyable, I’d say.

Id rather enjoy the scenery through big windows from an elevated driving position than through the tiny windows of a sports car.

I know what the weather is like here in late October. I can’t imagine that driving a couple of hundred miles closer to the Arctic Circle would increase the opportunities to have the top down on a convertible


 
Posted : 09/10/2019 6:12 pm
Page 1 / 2

6 DAYS LEFT
We are currently at 95% of our target!