 You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more
I've got an XTR triple crankset (3x10) and I'd like to move to a 1x10 setup. I'm hoping the XTR crank arms will fit to any 104mm single ring and bashguard (and maybe chain guide) and that I can keep the existing 10 speed rear mech and cassette.
Anybody able to offer any advice on that? Like most things it seems like there are a million options but not everything is compatible.
Which model XTR? There was one that was a bit funny in BCD.
He's right! If it's M970 or M980 you're away, M960 is more of a pain! As you're 10 speed I'm assuming M980, so yes, fit a narrow wide ring of your choice, don't mess around with guides and what not.
What Njee said. M985 has a funny BCD though.
I'll have to check which one it is. Narrow/wide ring - I assumed they were for the new 11spd setups with different chain, cassette, mech etc. I guess not then?
Nope- Narrow wide can be used with any gear combination on the back, 1x9/10/11. Not sure it works with 6/7/8 speed due to the chain.
Using a clutch mech will further reduce the chance of dropping a chain though.
Pretty sure it's this one http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/shimano-xtr-trail-m980-10-speed-triple-chainset/rp-prod83547 but I'll have to check when I get back home
As it's a Shimano setup, would that rule out the SRAM ring? http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/sram-x01-x1-x-sync-narrow-wide-chainring/rp-prod109082. I'm assuming that if the bolt circle is the same then the it should all fit fine?
Save yourself some cash and buy a Works/E-13/RaceFace/Hope/Superstar N-W chainring. All are cheaper and do the same job.
ska-49 thanks for your advice - very useful.
The other thing is a bashguard - universal or limited for the crank? And rear mech needs replacing. I currently have an XTR long cage with clutch. Thinking of an XT replacement with [s]mech[/s] clutch. Or maybe the Saint - not sure of the benefits of short vs long cage on those 2 models
Not sure what bash would work with the m980 cranks as they have the tab covers. If you can run them without the covers then I guess a normal bash would work? Again, bash matches the BCD of the cranks so if its 104mm you should be fine.
I guess you'll be replacing the cassette too. Have you seen the One-up 42t cog? http://www.oneupcomponents.com/products/42-tooth-sprocket - might be worth considering if replacing the drivetrain. Gives you greater gear range and closer to 11spd but far cheaper.
Long vs short cage also depends on the range of the cassette. Seems that lots of people can run 11-36t with a short cage. With the new clutch mechs the cage length gets less important as it doesn't slap around much anymore.
what do you need a bash guard for?
I've actually got a recently replaced 10 spd XT cassette but that extra cog looks interesting
Anyone know of a good online guide to gear ratios? I'm assuming 32t would be the way to go on the front but i must confess the details are lost on me
What Njee said. M985 has a funny BCD though.
Indeed, which is 88mm, but it's only available as a double.
As for calculators: [url= http://sheldonbrown.com/gears/ ]This[/url] is the usual one, although [url= http://www.gear-calculator.com/ ]this one[/url] is a lot more exciting, and perhaps easier to understand.
Running short cage with 34T and 11-36 here.
I like it. It looks better, and feels like there's less mech to foul things.
88BCD XTR and Wolftooth chainring
[IMG] 
[/IMG]