XT Di2 1x11 or good...
 

  You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more

[Closed] XT Di2 1x11 or good old fashioned mechanical?

16 Posts
12 Users
0 Reactions
85 Views
Posts: 3224
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Looking to order my drive train for my soon to arrive Spark 700 Plus tuned frameset.
Wondering if theres any huge benefit to going XT Di2 or if 1x11 do I simply stick with XTR shifter M8000 XT rear mech?
I appreciate with 2x11 it make more sense, but whats the upside over old fashined shifting?
Whatever shifting will most likely be paired with an e13 9-46 cassette.


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 12:42 am
Posts: 21461
Full Member
 

I considered it, but for a 1x11 setup, it really doesn't seem worth it.


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 9:22 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

have the di2 it's ace even for novelty value , it's not going to have you waxing lyrically how it's changed your life.......but it's cool having no cable issues


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 9:32 am
Posts: 357
Free Member
 

I'd also be interested in hearing opinions on di2 as I'm considering it for my Niner singlespeed so I can conert it to 1×11 quickly without all the faff with new cables and outers etc.


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 9:37 am
Posts: 6
Free Member
 

I have xtr Di2 and I'd say it's better than the road Di2 system ( the new dura ace looks amazing )
This is my first shimano set up in years as I was always an sram fan. Di2 is faultless if a little spendy.


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 9:40 am
Posts: 43345
Full Member
 

I quite fancy it so I could put an additional gear change button on my bar ends.


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 9:49 am
Posts: 6
Free Member
 

Whatever floats your boat 🙂
I used an r600 shifter for a while but after changing a few prongs, couldn't get a positive enough " click " when riding with gloves.
I went back to the regular xtr shifter


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 9:51 am
Posts: 3224
Free Member
Topic starter
 

So, it won't be an enlightening change, I've never had mechaical cable issues so aside from it probably being pretty cool from a functionality and 'its new' perspective, it's probably not worth it?


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 3:42 pm
Posts: 6409
Free Member
 

Had XTR di2 - shifter is shit


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 3:49 pm
Posts: 6
Free Member
 

I was cynical until I actually used it. I've also never had issues with cables but this is a different league to mechanical.
Try it or have a play with an install in a shop. You'll be sold.

Where are you? Happy for you to try mine if anywhere near north Hampshire.

How is the shifter shit ? It's a switch and far more consistent than the mechanical shifter which I though was pants.


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 3:49 pm
Posts: 4421
Full Member
 

Apparently, some people have issue with the ergonomics of the shifter. It's fine for me however. Do it!


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 5:05 pm
Posts: 6409
Free Member
 

It replicates a cable shifter, with lever throw, it doesn't need to, poor design imho and one of the fundamental reasons I sold it, even the climbing shifter from the road group is better


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 5:26 pm
Posts: 6
Free Member
 

It's not a poor design, you just didn't like it. I've never been a fan of shimano shifter enganomics but can just about cope with the Di2 as the click is lighter. Ideally I want to split and r600 shifter and have a button under each grip to replicate SRAM etap


 
Posted : 28/01/2017 5:45 pm
Posts: 4439
Full Member
 

What happens if you fully submerged the full d2i system? Is it completely waterproof?


 
Posted : 03/02/2017 8:34 am
Posts: 7932
Free Member
 

Should think so. The connectors are basically double sealed. If you managed to get a stick between the spoke and the cable I suspect you'd need to replace both the spoke and cable afterwards.


 
Posted : 03/02/2017 9:19 am
Posts: 2597
Free Member
 

What happens if you fully submerged the full d2i system? Is it completely waterproof?

I've seen various videos where they fully submerge bikes underwater- such as Martyn Ashton's Roadbike party.
Road Bike Party vid [url=

The bike video [url=

I've also seen countless CX riders hammering their Di2 equipped bikes through the muddy, wet & gritty CX season without any issues.

I'm eyeing up the XT Di2 too. Some reasonably priced kits out there for 1x11. Pretty much the same price as Sram Eagle 1x12, just add a £59 cassette to the XT setup..
Eagle [url= https://www.mantel.com/uk/sram-xx1-eagle-upgradekit?spec%5B%5D=285&spec%5B%5D=15018&utm_source=google&utm_medium=shopping&gclid=COG4jZfO89ECFcS37QodwkoKyw ]HERE[/url]
XT Di2 [url= https://www.mantel.com/uk/shimano-xt-di2-m8050-upgradekit&utm_source=google&utm_medium=shopping?gclid=CPnRzZ3O89ECFU-T7QodZYkKyw ]HERE[/url]


 
Posted : 03/02/2017 9:29 am
 adsh
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I thought the main advantage for Di on mountain bikes was the ability to change gear under full power and that over the course of a [u]race[/u] this added up to an advantage.

If you don't race and are not a gadget freak I can't see the point. I can however see the disadvantages of extra weight, cost and replacement cost (mechs). Disclaimer - I'm a late adopter of everything.


 
Posted : 03/02/2017 10:21 am

6 DAYS LEFT
We are currently at 95% of our target!