[Closed] Soul seat post length

You might get away with that but will be on the edge of acceptable.

I run a 400mm on my Large frame and I have a 32" inside leg. Hasn't got too much spare post inside the frame.

Quick point on this is Cy recommends you have min of 100mm inside the frame regardless of the min insertion depth on your post (check out the warranty section of the Cotic site)

Hoep this helps

st length is 16" = 406mm

available seatpost = 250mm

saddle adds say 30mm, total 686mm.

30" x 1.09 = 831mm, so 12cm short, get a medium?

I've got a 410mm on my medium and I wouldn't want to go any shorter.

OK thanks a lot, I won't take the chance. What seat posts are people using?

p.s. cynic-al, not sure what you're telling me? Explain again, with stick men diagrams if necessary...

I added up the various lengths between the bottom bracket and saddle, and compared with 1.09 x inside leg (one way of getting your saddle height from bb).

Thomson for me. Is there any other worth having?

Thomson for me. Is there any other worth having?

Yes, many (if you are capable of individual thought).

Thompson.
This was a 410mm & still had plenty before the min mark.
(5'9 - Size Small).

[url= http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3413/3447985361_2eabe67a89.jp g" target="_blank">http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3413/3447985361_2eabe67a89.jp g"/> [/img][/url]
[url= http://www.flickr.com/photos/takisawa2/3447985361/ ]Soul-1 (2)[/url] by [url= http://www.flickr.com/people/takisawa2/ ]pten2106[/url], on Flickr

Oh, OK - so by your calculations I've got to find 12 cm? Don't you need to add in the length from the bb to the end of the crank?

Also, poisonspider, I heard that Thomson seat posts get worn if you adjust the height a lot - something to do with the beaded sort of coating?

*awaits Thomson related flaming*

thebunk...My thomposons are in-out-up-down all the time. No issues to report, & both mine are S/H jobbies off here. The one in the pic is years old. I've tried a good few over the years but I consider them a default fitment, like their stems.

[i]Don't you need to add in the length from the bb to the end of the crank?[/i]

good point, well made so +175mm to cynic-als calculation.

you need to lose 5cm - maybe a small 😉

st length is 16" = 406mm

available seatpost = 250mm

saddle adds say 30mm, total 686mm.

30" x 1.09 = 831mm, so 12cm short, get a medium?

Crank length?

I'd say you'd be fine with a 410mm

cynic-al - Member

Thomson for me. Is there any other worth having?

Yes, many (if you are capable of individual thought).

Are there? I'll check with my mates to see what I should do. 😉

Also, poisonspider, I heard that Thomson seat posts get worn if you adjust the height a lot - something to do with the beaded sort of coating?

To be fair they do get scratched quiet easily if you are constantly taking them in/out etc. but I wouldn't say they get 'worn' as such, it's just cosmetic.

Cor, as well as getting 2x10 [url= http://cotic.posterous.com/newsletter-drivetrain-options-and-human-behav ]which Cotic Cy sounds unconvinced by[/url], I thought I'd gone and ordered the wrong size!

As the others have said a 410mm Thompson sounds like what you need, and a small is almost certainly the right size for you.

I'm running 2x9 on my BFe (and have also done on my Soul in the past) and it works well however can back up when Cy said about the noise of the chain slapping about sometimes when using 36 on the front and the small rings at the back. One of my local descents is quite fast and rooty and it's way noiser on the bikes I have with 2x9 than the ones with triples.

I use a ControlTech team post. Looks, feels and performs just like a Thompson but a few £ cheaper

Loooong post always wise.

cynic-al - Member

I added up the various lengths between the bottom bracket and saddle, and compared with 1.09 x inside leg (one way of getting your saddle height from bb).

831mm!! thats a lot for a 30" leg.....
are you sure you've not multiplied instead of divided?? 😛

Actually now that I think on it - I'm 5'9" and have a small BFe and while I think a 350mm post would probably be a tad short for me on that I'd have thought it'd be ok for a slightly shorter person, as there isn't a silly amount of seatpost showing on my bike:

[img] [/img]

Oops forgot about the 175mm...

I may not be capable of individual thought but at least I can add up (with a calculator of course)!! 🙄

6'2" on a 17.5 inch BFe with a 410mm thomson. I can just get the seat high enough for xc if i leave the post 1cm below the downtube. So you'll be fine with a 410mm on a 16inch

I can add up too, I just forget parts of the formula 🙄