[Closed] Sealant: Stans 'Normal' Vs 'Race' Vs Orange Vs Peaty Vs What else?

I've used Stans, it's fine.
For no particular reason, other than to try something different, currently using Juice Lubes stuff. It smells nicer.
Also Mavic in road wheels, cos it came with the wheels.

I tried the race, never noticed it being any better, went back to stan-dard stuff.

moved from stans to orange. Its more expensive but has sealed holes that stans wouldnt have.

although i do run a LOT of sealant it seems.

its got bits in like peatys.

Started on Stans "normal"
Tried Juice Lubes - never sealed anything
Tried the cheap stuff from mole valley - again, useless.
Back on Stans again unless someone makes a big case for anything else.
Friends tried to convince me to try cafe latex, then promptly got a flat. No thanks.

Long time Stans user - recently switched to Orange, which seems on a par. Then tried going cheap with the blue stuff from PX, which is so thick that it seems unable to reach the punctures in time - so watered it down 50/50 with Orange and seems ok since.

If I could find a bulk Stans supply at a cheap enough price id happily switch back.
Although, recently acquired liquid latex may shortly meet with glitter in home-brew-experiment.

Joes, very much like Stans but seals better, quite alot better I am finding. Haven't tried their expensive stuff (that's like Stans Race). Supposed to be twice as good but the regular stuff works so well I don't know why I would. Its also much cheaper.

ooh, i'll give that a go.

Stans IME just works, and works well.

NRG (Planet-X) was OK actually, might have dried out a bit quick but was dirt cheap ina sale so had no complaints.

Joes was a PITA as the granules wouldn't stay in suspension long enough to pour into the tyre.

Currently using the OKO tractor stuff someone off here recommended diluted 2:1 (water:OKO), which makes it about 10%* of the cost of stans. Seems to be working so far (sealed the tyres fine, and one known saled puncture which was the reason for taking the tyre off to top up). Certainly looks like it needs diluting, it's the consistency of thick cream!

[url= http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/OKO-TYRE-SEALANT-ANTI-PUNCTURE-OFF-ROAD-1250ML-STOP-PUNCTURES/182124416574?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649 ]Tractors tuff, £9/litre.[/url]

*Maths fans:

Stans is £13.99 per 473ml at wiggle, or 2.95p/ml
OKO diluted to 33% is £9 for 3.75l, or 0.24p/ml

Looks like 'normal' stans doing it for most folk but the tractor stuff has got me interested....

Anyone tried Peaty's sealant yet?

Does anyone know a bulk supplier of either Stans or Orange? (And by bulk I mean in bigger volumes you can normally find)

No real experience to speak of as I've only just made the conversion to tubeless, but a total bodger like me managed to get most tyres to seat and seal very easily with Stans 'normal'.

I say most because not even Stans can cope with a 2cm gash in a tyre.

Stans. Not had a puncture in five years. But then good tyres too.

Stans race is supposed to be better but needs topping up more according to the lads at 18 bikes...

Has anyone used the Conti sealant?

The nutrack stuff isn't bad although the downhill version seems too thick and I've watered it down with some of of the milk version. But the price has been creeping up so currently on Joe no flats which hasn't had any issues to date. That statement will, of course, completely jinx that!

Just been for a week in Spain and running Effetto Caffelatex and never suffered a single puncture despite a lot of thorns.

NuTrack stuff i think is OKO

Stans race for me. Sealed non tubeless contis that had been weeping heavily and losing air for weeks. More expensive but I won't be going back

Been using the Continued sealant for 3 years, never had a puncture fail to seal. Keeps longer than Stan's too.

OKO claim it never dries out and has a very long life and I think I've read somewhere they don't use ammonia.

OKO here. 1:1 dilution. Dirty cheap!

stans race here. It might be good luck, but I've not had a puncture since it went in many months ago. As for it needing topping up, then I've not noticed it drying out any quicker than normal stans, and that lasts over 6 months itself.

We have orange in one of the wheel sets as we needed some in a hurry following a tyre swap (huge slash in the sidewall, not sealant would have saved it) and can't say I've noticed any difference to the normal stans.

Thread high jack.

Any one better at stopping the sidewall weeping. Using stans in nobby nics pacestar and they are quite weepy, but oddly don't seem to loose much pressure.

Hutchinson's not had a mention yet - that stuff is good also.
Best I used was Geax, ages ago, but it seemed to disappear from the shops. Had little black bits in it and sealed anything.
I guess if you're using crap tyres (ie. non tubeless) then you need to get the best stuff cos you'll no doubt get more punctures.

I bought some Bontrager sealant today as it was all the shop used. So time will tell. The guy in the shop recons that Wyhite or Trek (Cant remember) are bringing some non Latex fluid out thats better and cheaper.

teethgrinder - Member
OKO here. 1:1 dilution. Dirty cheap

oops.
i didnt dilute mine.
thought it was a bit gloopy....

So, based on this thread, just bought some OKO. Will give it a try.

Stans has been OK for me but leaks a little to much through Schwalbe SG sidewalls so needs constant top-ups.
Caffe Latex has been OK-ish, no better, maybe a little more prone to drying out prematurely IME.

dufusdip - Member
The nutrack stuff isn't bad

The Nutrak stuff IS bad - it's worse than useless. I tried it, had a flat, just a small hole, and sealant poured out of the hole, refused to seal. Thought maybe the fluid had dried p and there wasnt enough of it to seal, so I went home, topped up with Nutrak, tried again, all out the hole again.

Put a tiny splash of Stan's in, hole sealed straight away.

oops.
i didnt dilute mine.
thought it was a bit gloopy....

I don't know if it's supposed to be diluted or not, it might be the same concentration of latex in water as others, just with a thickener, but others had so I did too. I've not had any problems with it.

Is suppose the gloopier formula might be an aid in slow moving tractor tyres, keeping it stuck to the sidewalls. If it ever punctures or dries out I might experiment with a less or no water as it's still incredibly cheap.

I bought some Bontrager sealant today as it was all the shop used. So time will tell. The guy in the shop recons that Wyhite or Trek (Cant remember) are bringing some non Latex fluid out thats better and cheaper.

Bontrager stuff is dreadful. And how does the shop monkey know it's better if it's not out yet?. Amazes me how highly held bike shop staffs views are.

I usually use stans. I do have some stans race though from when it was on sale at the same prices as regular stans. It was noticeably quicker at sealing up a difficult tyre and stopped the sidewall leakage I usually get with that tyre.

The guy in the shop recons that Wyhite or Trek (Cant remember) are bringing some non Latex fluid out that's better and cheaper.

Any one better at stopping the sidewall weeping.

Switched from Stans to Orange. Mainly for road, as the Stans is still holding up on the mtb and cross. But I won't be going back. It seems to seal faster when mounting. And is sparkly of course 8)

How much of the OKO stuff do you use per tyre once diluted? Same as stans (100ml or so an end)?

How much of the OKO stuff do you use per tyre once diluted? Same as stans (100ml or so an end)?

I thought it was more like 60ml? But yes, same as any other sealant.

I use JRA Wheel Milk - its cheap and does a good job but it does dry out after a while.

I had issues with Stans not sealing when I did puncture so don't bother with it any more.

Might give some of that OKO sealant a whirl.

thisisnotaspoon - Member
I thought it was more like 60ml? But yes, same as any other sealant.

Thanks, you're right - 60-90ml. Dunno why I had 100ml in my head.

Apparently Peatys is selling as fast as they can make it. Not sure whether that's because it's ace or the link with Peaty....

Depends how fast they are making it, I've seen lots of previews but no reviews of it yet so can only assume its selling on association.

I bought some Schwalbe stuff, not used it yet, but noticed its made by Stans

I swapped to Orange and then back to Stans - which in the case of my slow leaking Racing Ralph has proven better - It's stayed up for a week - I feel however with air leaks there are too many variables to categorically state one sealant is the best . . I need to start home brewing !

Hi, slight hijack (but kind of related)...

The syringes are expensive at a tenner, is there a cheaper alternative/seller?

I thought it was more like 60ml? But yes, same as any other sealant

Latex works because the latex molecules coagulate in high shear situations (i.e. being accelerated through a small hole). Unless there's a synthetic material with the same properties I can't see why you'd want to move away from it (niche for bikers allergic to latex?).

Has anyone used the Conti sealant?

This thread is pretty hopeless so far.

OKO is brilliant
Nutrak is OKO
Nutrak is crap

I feel however with air leaks there are too many variables to categorically state one sealant is the best

I like the sound of the OKO - it's a third of the price of Stans undiluted. Is water the best thing to use with it? How about diluting with more (cheap) liquid latex?

Presumably undiluted liquid latex is much of a much muchness. You can get 5L of model making latex for [url= http://www.mbfg.co.uk/liquid-dipping-latex/2282.html?gclid=Cj0KCQjw5arMBRDzARIsAAqmJezo_SQfK0omqETOkcnSSs-AV37bGhiuVmnVlAn22vi14bdmOhTNiLsaAotLEALw_wcB ]£25 plus postage [/url]

patriotpro - Hi, slight hijack (but kind of related)...

The syringes are expensive at a tenner, is there a cheaper alternative/seller?

eBay syringes and pick a size, I use 20ml ones as they fit inside a valve core

Where are we getting OKO from?

I bought the syringe but dont use it. If im topping up I have an old Stans 2oz bottle and top up through the valve stem. Its also handy for sucking out the used stuff to reuse. If im fitting and filling up when the bead is off then I use an old washing detergent ball that has measures on the side. Both work fine at a cost of nothing.

Where are we getting OKO from?

eBay. £8.99 delivered from a few places - even cheaper than mould making latex (I've bought a litre of that as well).

So. Glitter as an additive. Any recommendations?

Fine, superfine, chunky? seem to be different sorts on eBay.

I make my own for £3 per litre I add in extra grit shall we call it than stans. I could probably get ii down if I purchased the raw ingredients in bulk. As for performance it works well, I'm testing its longevity with slightly increasing the ammonia content but the standard mix will last a good 4 months in summer conditions and as it's cheap I can regularly top it up...

OKO from Mole Country Stores/Farmway.

I got mine at Farmway in Hexham.

re I add in extra grit shall we call it than stans. I could probably get ii down if I purchased the raw ingredients in bulk. As for performance it works well, I'm testing its longevity with slightly increasing the ammonia content but the standard m

so what are the ingredients/recipe?

so what are the ingredients/recipe?

That is commercially sensitive information 8).

I bought a litre of liquid latex and diluted it down 4:1:1 with water + screenwash. It's a little too runny at that concentration and took a while to seal a puncture I had a couple of weeks back.

When I'm done with that litre I'll but some of the OKO stuff or this:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Puncture-Free-Off-Road-Tyre-Sealant-For-Ride-On-Mowers-1-Litre-1000-ML/141447420159

surely water based dilution means it wont seal/dry in the wet?

I find thatwith stans/caffelatex tyres weep more after a wet weekend riding. (spec control sidewalls)

How often does the oko stuff need topping up? The oko site says it lasts the lifetime of the tyre.
Is it this one?
http://m.ebay.co.uk/itm/OKO-TYRE-SEALANT-ANTI-PUNCTURE-OFF-ROAD-1250ML-STOP-PUNCTURES-/182124416574

I looked into OKO a bit more.

Nutrak is indeed some form of OKO but they seem to have a range of products I've never seen in the UK -
http://www.oko.com/markets/bicycles/
"Puncture Free" (not latex based, blue, viscous)
"Extreme" (a dead link) and
"Magic Milk" (synthetic latex based, light, free flowing)

Would be interesting to get a proper comparison. Some of the 'extreme mining' types claim to seal up to 10mm holes so i'm guessing some very large particles.
[img] [/img]

[img] [/img]

Original: perfect for commuters as well as everyday cyclists.
X-Treme: more robust for heavy duty bikes and better suited to mountain biking.
Magic Milk: for those looking to run a tubeless set-up and is ideal for racing.

Nothing really explains the advantages/disadvantages of each.

thepodge - Member
patriotpro - Hi, slight hijack (but kind of related)...
The syringes are expensive at a tenner, is there a cheaper alternative/seller?

eBay syringes and pick a size, I use 20ml ones as they fit inside a valve core

It's to load thru' the valve core, cheers

I've ordered some oko sealant and smells the same and has the same consistency as the decathlon stuff, which is crap. It coats the inside of the tyre brilliantly but leaves nothing for punctures, I suspect it's more for fixing a holed tyre after the event, I'll try it watered down though. I have a worn out tyre I can do some puncture tests on when I get bored.

Not a waste as the wheel barrow has a flat.

surely water based dilution means it wont seal/dry in the wet?

No. Latex doesn't 'dry out' like water based paint. Ever wonder why, if latex starts off as a water based fluid, that rubber things don't dissolve in water?

Latex is a suspension of long protein molecules in water. If you remove the water, the protein is left behind. But also, if you rub it or put shear force it through a small gap the protein molecules get tangled up like felt, and it becomes a solid. They cannot be untangled. That's why it sloshes around in tyres happily for ages but when it's forced through a small gap it turns into a solid plug.

Conti definitely has no particles of any kind in it.

Did you not shake the bottle?! They are probably all stuck at the bottom. You have to shake the hell out of the bottle, and turn the bottle upside down to check that the bottom doesn't have everything stuck to it before using it for the first time.
We use the Conti stuff at work because it's a lot cheaper than Stans and it works fine (if you shake the bottle).

Conti definitely has no particles of any kind in it.>>>
Did you not shake the bottle?! They are probably all stuck at the bottom.

Yes, you do get some settling - there is *something* that goes back into suspension when you shake it but I'm pretty sure even model making latex needs shaking?. Stans has some much larger visible particles that fall out of suspension really quickly.

oko sealant and smells the same and has the same consistency as the decathlon stuff, which is crap

Latex based sealants seem to be expensive - dq-services.co.uk sell the OKO 'extreme' mtb sealant at £15 a litre. The 'off road' tractor tyre stuff is £5 a litre (I really wonder the difference beteween those two) but OKO branded latex based Magic Milk is still £28 a litre.

Normal Stans here, seems to work well enough and means I can keep adding to my interesting collection of Stanimals on the garage windowsill.