 You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more
Can you please explain the difference?
[img] 
[/img]
Shadow on the right - it's more 'out of the way' but IMO they're less robust since the fixing point is pretty flimsy. The cable routing on the shadow is better though.
Shadow:
[img] 
[/img]
Non-shadow:
[img] 
[/img]
[img] 
[/img]
Shadow mechs are weak with an extra pivot to go sloppy but do have better cable routing. the lower profile is fairly irrelivent IMO if you catch a mechs parallelogram on stuff it's not because it sticks out too much it's because you didn't get your line right.
If I wanted a decent (light, strong & cheap) rear derailleur, I'd prob still go with an old skool road mech.
Thank you all for your great answers and pics 🙂
regular XT rear mech ordered
what does the sram x9 profile look like in comparison.
eee you learn something new every day
I thought shadow meant it only had the barrel adjusters on the shifters, not the derailleur
😳
Personally I prefer the shadow to the regular version (have one of each). The cage spring on the shadow is stronger so stops the chain slapping about as much.
Dunno, but in a week's riding on properly rocky trails in Spain (switchbacks.com, go there, you wont regret it) just about everyone bent their rotors, but no bent mechs (3x SRAM, 1 shadow, 2 normal) ???????
IMO its a waste of money as the cage is still in the same place and they don't do a rapid rise version.
Recently changed from old skool XT to shadow, and have to agree with bigyinn, the stronger spring is very noticable, much less flappy chain.
I switched from a regular XT to a shadow XT and haven't noticed it being weaker, saying that I'm pretty careful with my lines (HT doesn't forgive).
I prefer rapid/reverse rise too