[Closed] Osprey Escapist 18....anything better for commuting/days out?

I've had the escapist 25 for a few years. It's really comfortable on the bike, I use it when on (youth) club mtb rides, so lots of first aid, tools, shelter etc and it's fine with all that. When walking, it's not as comfortable when loaded up, say 10kg, but fine with less. Having said that I use it most days just for food shopping. All in all, it's good. Oh, and nothing has broken, worn out, fallen off etc 🙂

Ooh good info. When out walking it'll definitely be a summer pack/shorter walk pack, so will probably be between 5-6kg tops. (With most of that being water, so going down throughout the day!)

If anyone has the 18l Escapist, I’m assuming that I will fit: Jeans, boxers, socks, shirt, shoes, rain coat, deodorant, lunch box, tablet, chargers and a few bike bits like pump, tube etc?

I've got one, it's a tight fit for clothes, shoes and lunch

Hmm, trying to avoid buying lunch at work. SPD brogues maybe? Flashy I'm looking in your direction!

I'll not be using a bladder in it when commuting if that makes any odds?

Oxfords, not brogues, my dear chap!

I have a Talon 22 for such occasions and it's just about perfect.

Yeah the Talon 22 was my other option. Am I right in thinking that the Escapist should be a slightly better fit on the bike?

I think I need to see them in real life before committing. I used my girlfriend's Tempest 26 the other day which was fairly decent, but a slightly strange fit due to my lack of boobs and child bearing hips....it'll be okay as a stop gap though!

I have a used black/grey Camelbak Hawg in VGC if you wanted to replace with like for like.

Cheers for the offer @Frankers, I think that I want to go with an Osprey. I just love their stuff!

the Escapist should be a slightly better fit on the bike?

I've only used it on my more upright bikes (MTB and Brompton) and I'd say it's as comfortable as my Raptor, only difference being that it's (obviously) bigger.

I use an escapist 25 for everything you describe and it’s great. Been going strong for 7 years now too. I would struggle to fit what you describe above in a smaller bag than I’ve got now without it bulging and compromising the fit/comfort though - especially the bulging back on the bike. I find the pack works fine even when it’s not completely full, but when you ram it full it doesn’t sit quite so well (this happens with lots of bags). Not completely full means there’s room to have a shirt loosely folded on top rather than rammed in too, so still looks presentable after. May be worth seeing if you can test fit everything you need to carry in an 18 before you commit.

Cheers for the info Ben....I'm thinking that the 25 might be the way to go....although I'd like to go with the 18 to get a clear difference in size between my Talon 33.....I can probably leave shoes at work actually, ditto Tablet. I definitely need to to see them in the flesh.

sorry for the hijack but does anyone have a recommendation for a smallish pack without waist straps?

Again, for commuting mainly. I currently have a Deuter but it's on its last legs/straps.

Osprey Synchro 12 looks possible.... as the waist strap is negligible.

I ended up with the Escapist 25.

Mega chuffed with it, used it this afternoon for a commute to my studio in town. Was only there for a few hours so didn't have a whole load of stuff in, but it was really comfy and it definitely fits all of the stuff in that I'll need on my longer commute.

Escapist 25 FTW.

Is my regular day pack on the MTB with not much stuff in tbh. But it’s really comfortable, cinches up tight and takes all the abuse from mud, rain and even the odd fall. Ahem.

But it has also come into its own for the odd trip away. I’ve used it as carry-on with 2-3 days worth of clothes, wash bag and a laptop with charger. It’s surprisingly roomy.

Really, really rate it.

I’d size up and go with the 25l.

I've just ordered a Syncro 12, so will report back on that when it arrives.

Forgot my ****ing boxers today. Forgot my wallet last week. Tit.