[Closed] Orange, Whyte or Bird?

Giant Anthem 1.
Fox suspension, XT drivetrain/brakes, carbon wheels, dropper post and boost hubs.

https://www.giant-bicycles.com/gb/anthem-1

You "should" be able to test ride all three of those. The Bird will give you the most scope for customization of build and the ability to speak with the guys (Ben?) behind the company. The Whyte is a great off the shelf package, UK design. The Orange will gain you exceptional IrnBru kudos when in Halifax and offers the ability to upgrade.... at a cost. All have modern geometry and won't ride badly, but a test ride will split the hairs in your buying process.

The oranges felt very similar geometry wise to the Bird, (orange 5,6 and I rode a segment) The whyte although not a bad ride, I was a bit underwhelmed by it, I don't know if it was a case of having too high expectations from all the good reviews?

I ended up with an Aeris and have no regrets.

If you can, go and test ride both Aeriseses at Bird HQ so you can speak to Dan or Ben about set up for a proper test. That said, I didn't and picked a mk1.5 Aeris based on the numbers and a phone call with Dan. Loved it ever since.

Test ride the bikes to see what you like best. If you still can't decide just buy the Bird on value and service*

* I had a warranty issue with my Bird, nothing wrong wrong with the frame, just the same parts you get fitted to 1000's of other bikes. Bike was out of action for a total of 5 days, didn't even miss a ride.

Oh and the bikes are ****ing ace too 8)

Seems like a nice position to be in. Another thumbs up here for bird service/support.

I've owned a T130 (2015) and an Aeris (mark 1), the Aeris being what I ride now.

Aeris ticks all the boxes, at a great price.

Geometry has of course changed for both of the above bikes since.

Orange overpriced IMO.

I'd go for an Aeris.

Hah, my 40th next month too! I demoed the Aeris 145 a couple of weeks ago (review on here somewhere) and really liked it. Their proximity to me and how awesome the guys there are made it a no-brainer. Just need to pop back up and sort out the spec..

The Bird looks like a top bike, not sure if the external cabling would bother me though. Petty I know, but it would.
Orange is a lot of money. Whyte T130s doesnt get a bad word said about it. Nice to have such a such a great choice of British bikes.

I'd probably go for the Bird with GX, Pike RC, DT Swiss wheels and Guide brake upgrades.

Maybe upgrade the shock too, as it's much cheaper than doing so later.

External cable-routing is a big plus for me.

All three are great choices and I'm sure you'll be happy with either or.

Bird will offer the best value, Orange the least, Whyte somewhere in the middle.

I'll recommend one I've ridden but don't own in the Rose Bikes Granite Chief. The travel is more than you want but it's very well mannered, flys up, flys down and an easy bike to ride all day. The new updated version isn't quite a snip but still high value and fully customisable using the configurator. Plus you get a uk rep and you can demo.

I'll recommend one I don't in the Aeris. Whilst the T130 gets a lot of love and nice warranty, it's a bit weighty, and the customisation on the Bird will swing it.

Seems like Bird is the word!

Bollocks to value! It's your 40th birthday present, get the bike you [i]want[/i] not the one the internet tells you to 🙂

Test ride them all and go with the one that makes you smile the most, not the one that pleases the finance officer the most.

And for balance, I bought a Four based on smiles per mile after test riding loads of bikes (cheaper and more expensive!).

First reply suggested Anthem 1. I rode a Whyte 130RS, a Four and the Anthem. For me the Giant felt lighter and most nimble so I bought one. Only ridden it a couple of times so far and very impressed. It replaced an Anthem SX and is quite different.

Cotic flare?

Bird every time, compare the warranty! Great bikes, great team and peace of mind.

The Orange is good, but imo the Whyte is better, felt more sophisticated and controlled than the Orange. Haven't ridden by the Aeris but a quick look over the geometry makes me wonder if it will feel a bit tank-like, despite the short travel. It's very very similar to my old Mondraker Foxy, which was fast but felt like too much bike a lot of the time, particularly on tighter trails. The Whyte felt a much better all-rounder to me. The bird is excellent value and you hear good things about the Warranty but my Whyte hasn't missed a beat so far!

I only had a car park test on the Bird Aeris but own the Whyte T-130, but it's a 2015 Whyte which is less extreme in the geomtry, having sat on the newer Whyte T-130's and the Bird, they're very similar in how they feel IMO, not much at all in it.

I went for the Whyte, but an older model as it was crazy cheap, but is absolutely brilliant.

I'd go for this bird. It's not that I'm against external cable routing, it's that they got straight through the logos on the frame, like it was forgotten about.

Banshee Phantom
just sayin'

Hmm, it seems most people think Bird. I do like Orange bikes and own a Clockwork 29er but how can they realistically expect me to pay more than a thousand quid extra for a bike that still isn't as well specced as the Bird or Whyte? My local Je James has both the Orange and Whyte in store and there is s Giant store in Sheffield (I'm in Rotherham) so I could test ride those but I'd have a job test riding a Bird I think. What about a Santa Cruz 5010? Probably have to be second hand for the money mind.

@thorpie - if you want a test ride, it might be worth joining the Bird owners group on Facebook and asking of anyone close-ish to you has one.

Very interested in this thread, going through the same myself.

Any real world experience of the weight of the Aeris One20? The reviews I've read say "It feels light".

Also am I going to be forever kicking myself for not waiting for the One45?

For the riding I do these days I cannot see that a weighty enduro 6" trail slayer would be my weapon of choice, but a light, nimble 120mm might.

Just to throw another one in the mix, Specialized Camber falls in the same travel spec too if thats of any interest?

I cant say anything about the Bird ,but I have ridden both a 130 and a Four.

The t130 was a great bike and deserves the praise it gets ,really nice ..

BUT

The Four just shouldn't work, I say this as my besty bought an ex demo from Orange and I steal it all the time ,Very light hence why we call it a cheat bike and point it down hill and its like a stabbed rat ,really wouldn't think its only running 130mm and 120mm travel at the rear ..

Both great bikes but I know where my money would be

For the riding I do these days I cannot see that a weighty enduro 6" trail slayer would be my weapon of choice, but a light, nimble 120mm might.

ST tested the Anthem 1 recently, if memory serves they really liked it.

^^^^^^ yes, the article was really useful and helped in my decision a bit :

[url= http://singletrackmag.com/forum/topic/long-and-low-andall-day-xc ]here...[/url]

havent ridden the orange.

demoed the bird 140 & the t130.

I'd have the bird. all day.

if you make a trip of it you an demo both the bird and the whyte at swinley forest. The bird guys are neat by and they have the whyte range at swinley bike hub.

but how can they realistically expect me to pay more than a thousand quid extra for a bike that still isn't as well specced as the Bird or Whyte?

Because you're getting a hand built in the uk frame. Up to you if it makes a difference.

Orange will be worth more when you come to sell. Once again, up to you if it makes a difference.

I'd get the Orange. I like Orange bikes.

^^^^^^ yes, the article was really useful and helped in my decision a bit :

here...

Interesting. I have an older Anthem and have fitted it with longer forks, wider bars, bigger tyres etc. It seems Giant have come to the same conclusion!

Currently in process of building up an Aeris 120. Should be finished tonight or tomorrow and a maiden ride this weekend. Lovely frame straight out the box

[img] [/img]

Thorpie - one you may not have considered but they are local to you.....

[url= https://www.airdropbikes.com/ ]AIRDROP - Edit[/url]

That Airdrop Edit V2 is a nice looking frame. Glad they have now made a stealth routed option as the original, which seemed crazy to me,

I own a 2016 Four, have ridden a 2017 T130RS and prefer the Orange 'feel' but it's lower spec.

The Anthem 1 looks very good!

I have a 2015 T1-30 Works, a riding buddy has an Bird Aeris 140 and if I was buying again now I'd go with the Bird.

Having said that i like the Orange Four but the lower spec for the money does make it a hard choice.

Decent distance/terrain test rides are probably the best way to decide, one of them will probably just feel right.