You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more
Grrrrr my bike is getting on my nerves LOL.
I've got a continual minor rubbing/grinding noise i can't track down at all.
I had a bit of a click also so fitted a HOPE bottom bracket the other day, a brand new set of Wellgo B-54 pedals to go along with the BB and i STILL have the noise.
It's almost like the chain is rubbing on the front mech... but i know that it's not and it's not quite as pronounced as that noise we all know and love.
Is it possible that it's just the chain and the chainring rubbing and making the noise ? If so, why on earth would that be ?
I'm running a 10 speed SLX double and bash, bought in that configuration as a double, with a HGX 10 speed chain
Looking on CRC, it was this crankset
http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/Models.aspx?ModelID=28019
Is it possible that the crankset is not Dynasys but my chain is ?? I was SURE when i bought this it's a Dynasys / HG-X crankset... I'm 99% sure my chain is HG-X and my cassette is too
Would that potentially cause the issue i'm having... i guess maybe yes...
(Older) Shimano 10sp chains are directional (writing on the outside).
Hmmmm i'm pretty sure i bought from Tweeks
that says it's an SG-X .... Hmmm hmmmm.
Have you checked your free wheel/rear hub?
Is it when you pedal only or anytime the wheels roll?
I'd start by giving all the drivetrain a good degrease and clean ,chain off,cassette off,jockey wheels etc.
Reassemble and lube then see if the rubbing is still there ,I have had noises like this caused before by a dry or dirty drivetrain and bits of grass/sticks trapped in the back of the cassette or between jockey wheels.
If its still there after that I could be the your drivetrain set up or some other rotating part ie.Hubs or discs rubbing.
Or....bented mech hanger?
Only when i pedal, same noise with the 'noisy' Hope Pro2 evos, and also with the other wheels the very quiet hub Giant p-sx2's.
Jockey wheels recently cleaned, chain cleaned/lubed often, i had the cranks out last week and made sure the rings were all clean
I'm thinking more and more that it's an incompatibility now between the HG-X chain and the SG-X chain-rings.
Rorschach - Member
Or....bented mech hanger?
You know how it is with bikes, you're 100% sure the noise is coming from 1 place but it's actually coming from anohter.... but... i'm 100% convinced it's coming from the front end rather than the back end of the drivetrain.
I have another mech hanger (and an XTR mech) i can use to prove/disprove the theory though.
Right... i've bought another SLX 10 speed HG-X middle chain-ring. Should be on it's way today i rekon.
I've got another crank that i can use that had a renthal middle on there once upon a time, it's also an SLX crank, so will fit the new ring to that, fit to the bike and see what happens....
Thanks for the thoughts lads, keep you posted.
could it be the chainring bolts?
Had a similar issue with my missus' hard tail. Changed the bottom bracket and pedals, cleaned the whole drive train and spent ages checking everything but it *still* did it. As a last resort I chucked a new chain on it (despite the old one being hardly worn at all) and bish-bosh, quiet as a mouse.
Still no idea why
gonzy - Member
could it be the chainring bolts?
I'd assume not as it's not a stuck together item by me, it comes built from Shimano as a double/bash so i'd assume they're all the correct length etc. I checked them for being done up tightly etc and they're all good in that context.
Is it your knees?
LOL@Tom.... Maybe sir, maybe.... i'm getting old and tired i admit yes.
Take your chain off and spin the cranks, then spin the wheel. Does it still make the noise? It isolates those components.
No, no noise with chain off.
Brakes 😉
Could it be a 9 speed chain? Or would that just not work at all?
woody2000 - Member
BrakesCould it be a 9 speed chain? Or would that just not work at all?
Not brakes, quiet as a mouse when i'm not peddaling.
Well, it COULD be a 9 speed chain... i'm pretty sure i bought a 10 speed HG-X... but as we buy these days from different places, it gets all confusing as to what's what and no real order tracking... i'm 99% sure it's a 10 speed HG-X.
weeksy - Member
No, no noise with chain off.
So it's something to do with your chain then 🙂
Depends how much it's bothering you, if it's only a slight noise. A new chain isn't that much £, so that would be a good start point.
Or wait to see what your new ring does.
Last thought, chain rubbing on the rear mech cage?
Aye that's a point - have you put the chain the wrong way through the mech and it's rubbing on the little tab? 🙂
Or, is the mech too close to the cassette, do you need to adjust the b-screw?
Will have a look at rear mech tonight, i may even throw a new XTR mech i have spare on there just to put my mind at rest...
Woody.... it's funny you mention that... because EVERY time i look at pics i struggle to work out the correct routing for the chain.... but i'm not posting a pic up of mine fitted just in case it IS wrong and you lot tear me to pieces...
Someone find me a decent pic showing chain routing please... if i go all quiet and say nothing... you know we have the answer 😉
[img] 
[/img]
Using that pic mine is deffo routed like that... honest lads 🙂
[img] 
[/img]
same...
you still have reflectors attached to your spokes!! 😯
not mine, internet pic... i'll take one of mine later when the boss goes to the gym
Yes, in the middle of the rear mech cage there is a small tab that is easy to miss. If you put the chain in front of the tab it will rub on it. Put the chain to the rear of the tab.
I misrouted the chain through the rear mech a while back and it made just that noise
😳
Did the wrong side of the tab thing myself the other day (I was in a hurry, ok?)
sounded clicky & graunchy, and also couldn't shift into the smallest two sprockets unless I went into the big ring (3x9 xt)
Been there, done that. Schoolboy error.
Its on right lads, honest
Check your Chainring bolts, if one of them is slightly loose you'll get a worrying sound (like a BB going bad)
Happened on my boss's campag chainset recently, took ages to track down
So, i have been playing, stripping and cleaning the bike after the sweet commute last night.
I've had the chain off and fitted the XTR rear mech. Chain is deffo on the right way, routed the right way etc. Chain line is good, mech is good... I think maybe it's the front ring yes, but maybe just me being overly sensitive LOL.
I guess we'll see when the middle ring arrives if we're happy.
Well i'm not sure if i've thrown you all a red herring or if the XTR rear mech going on has resolved the issue. Just done a 30km loop with a mate, his bike is WAY noisier than mine.. although i think my drivetrain is a little noisier than his, but in all honesty, there's not that much in it.
I think the XT rear mech i have needs new jockey wheels, despite me stripping and greasing them recently, they're hardly free moving...Although they are the best part of 3 years and 9000km old... so they've had a good innings. I'll pick some up and have as spare mech then for emergencies.
Thanks to all for the advice and ideas... much appreciated lads.
OK,update on this... I was sill getting the noise.
Today i fitted the HGX ring onto a spare set of cranks i had lying about... instant and complete silence !!! I'm a happy happy boy.
Sadly, it means my lovely SLX Double crank is up for sale !!!
However... i have silence 🙂