You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more
Hi all
Why would someone choose the 3mm shorter axels over standard ones? Some of the higher end pedals seem to have them. e.g. the Shimano XTR M9100's.
Cheers
Stance width.
There seems to be idea amongst road riders that the narrower the stance width the better.
I disagree, but it does make a difference. I'm much more comfortable on wider mtb cranks than narrow road cranks.
Even adding 2mm pedal 2ashers can be the difference between comfortable or not.
Why would someone choose the 3mm shorter axels over standard ones?
So that you get a better pedalling position. Q-factors on mtb cranks are massive and annoying.
If your looking at purchasing the M9100’s then don’t. The dust seals don’t stay in place and pop out after 5 mins of riding. Do a search, it’s not just a common problem, it’s a problem with all of them!
Is that just the M9100 and not the M9120?
I've avoided XTR pedals since the time lots of axles snapped.
It’s both unfortunately.
If you want light weight SPD’s then I’d avoid Shimano. Some £33 Welgo M19’s are lighter! Or Bontrager Comp’s if your a bit of a brand snob.
Bontrager Comp’s
Also known as Halfords Pro, and not as nice to get in and out of as Shimano imo.
That said, the pair on the road/gravel bike are now 3years old and only just showing bearing slackness.
Back on my SS marathon days I used to consider myself quite fussy about about that dreaded Q factor stuff.
Then, some years ago swapped to flat pedals and realised I couldn't care less about 5mm changes
Q-factors on mtb cranks are massive and annoying.
for cycling princesses with pea-ish tendencies.
hip width
I have the narrow axles on my XTR 9100s and as said, they effectively reduce the Q on mtb cranks so they are closer to a road width. Not had any issues with my 9100s.
Cheaper spuds are okay (bikehut, wellgo, xpedo) and I've used them in the past but the bushings eventually wear, whereas Shimano's bearings last much longer and are easily serviceable so are a better value proposition long term for me.
Cheers all
I have to say, I've had a pair of Shimano XT pedals for a good 5 - 6 (maybe 7) years now and they haven't skipped a beat. Clip in and out perfectly, they look all bashed up now but they just work and no squeaking or crunching. I'm just looking to upgrade now and treat myself to a few new components.