Is it totally impos...
 

  You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more

[Closed] Is it totally impossible for the same rider to win the 3 grand tours in one season

17 Posts
15 Users
0 Reactions
54 Views
Posts: 2645
Free Member
Topic starter
 

I remember a few years ago Pantani winning the Giro and the Tdf and I was kind of hoping he'd have a crack at the Vuelta but he didn't . I know he was discredited but is it possible for a rider to recover enough between tours or is it something that we will never see .


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:20 pm
Posts: 6581
Free Member
 

They would need some properly good drugs to even consider trying.


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:26 pm
Posts: 2645
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Not even possible with a massively strong team ?


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:30 pm
 ton
Posts: 24124
Full Member
 

stephen roche managed the triple crown in 87. pretty damn close.


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:30 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Dave Brailsford was interviewed at the end of the Giro last week and asked that question and said he believes it is doable, would need the stars to align, the right courses, perfect health, maybe some bad luck for rivals etc. but he does think it can be done and does think he will see it done which surprised me, as I was of the opinion its a no as too demanding


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:31 pm
Posts: 25815
Full Member
 

not unless their main rivals all tried as well (or else some rivals crash out or get ill)


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:31 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Not a chance.


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:32 pm
Posts: 5787
Full Member
 

Even winning two of them seems a challenge, though - even with Sky's team, it just doesn't seem to be quite within reach. You'd perhaps need to have two teams of domestiques (think injury, tiredness, plus cadence of training), and they'd have to be pretty strong to protect the principal.

I guess if you had a year where, say, Contador broke a leg, Nibali crashed and had a niggling injury, Quintana got flu or something, then perhaps Sky could do it?


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:36 pm
Posts: 2645
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Dumoulin might have something to say about that .


 
Posted : 04/06/2017 9:38 pm
Posts: 17
Free Member
 

Ramsey Neil - Member
Dumoulin might have something to say about that .

and if there is another year like the UK start and cobbles race where the main field was decimated then he might have a shot at 2, that then leaves Spain and if the main guys are still in plaster maybe if he doesn't burn out.
The Tour will be harder than the Giro with the big teams bringing their A List out, if you race a hard 3 weeks chasing that what do you have left for spain?


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 12:52 am
 Spin
Posts: 7655
Free Member
 

stephen roche managed the triple crown in 87. pretty damn close.

Winning a 3 week tour is a bit different from winning a one day race, even if it is the worlds.

Never say never but I think it's too big an ask. In the third one (and even the second) the fatigued contender will be up against fresh riders who've prepared specifically for that one race.

If it wasn't done in the era of Merckx or Hinault I don't think it will be done now when there seem to be many more riders in with a chance in the tours.


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 6:35 am
 Spin
Posts: 7655
Free Member
 

Dumoulin might have something to say about that .

He's good but he's a country mile off being that good.

EPO era Bertie was probably the modern rider with the best chance!


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 6:40 am
Posts: 5
Free Member
 

I think quintana was attemting it this year. But (i think) he went into the giro under trained, misjudged his opponents. He is probably the only rider capable of it. But as said iyt would need luck, suitable courses, etc


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 6:48 am
Posts: 22922
Full Member
 

not unless their main rivals all tried as well

Thats the thing really, even if all the strongest competitors inadvertently agreed to all see 3 wins as their season target and therefore find themselves competing like for like on more or less the same strategy- that would just leave the door open in each tour for for someone focusing all their effort on one tour win to come out of the shadows - those big players would finish the year having won nothing.


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 8:07 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Yes, but as said....you'd need the stars to line up, so many variables!


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 8:14 am
Posts: 8318
Full Member
 

Everything is impossible until someone goes and does it.

Impossible no, highly improbable yes


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 8:16 am
Posts: 13330
Full Member
 

Its tough enough riding all 3, let alone winning them. Adam Hansen seems to get a lot of plaudits just for riding them all and he's not exactly troubling GC.


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 8:25 am
Posts: 40225
Free Member
 

Obviously not totally impossible, but highly unlikely considering that even if the big guns were all riding all three - they'd be peaking at different times and the courses would favour different riders.


 
Posted : 05/06/2017 9:21 am

6 DAYS LEFT
We are currently at 95% of our target!