[Closed] Exotic forks - alloy v carbon

*bumps*

Not uesed either but I would spend the extra 25%.

The steerer you mean? Carbon steerers scare me.

Can only comment on the alu steerer ones but they're much of a muchness ride-wise with all the other carbon rigids I've used - eg a bit of give but nothing to write home about.

Fantastic stw advice:

Admission of no knowledge - CHECK

No basis provided for advice - CHECK

carbon ones in the classifieds for the price of new alloy (not mine). Worth a punt IMO.

Highly recommend the carbon! Very light and flexible!
Go for it!
I wouldn't go for the all steerer carbon though! 😐
[img] [/img]

Carbon steerer + £££+ and hardly any lighter.

I'm after 29er PH

You know this is a good deal....
http://www.singletrackworld.com/forum/topic/fs-carbon-exotic-29er-rigid-forks-virtually-brand-new

I'm after 29er PH

ah, doh

I got these 29er ones off here for 65 posted and they were mint, as new!
There are also lots on Fleabay to choose from as well!

WD I can get new alloy ones with a warranty for £5 less!

oh you SO need my input now
Opinionated -CHECK
Informed - NO
Engineer- NO
29 er owner - NO
Rigid Fork owner -NO
Carbon Forks owner-NO
IMHO decide how light you want or how much you want to spend and act accordingly
HTH
😆

I'm confused now, whether you are talking about eXotic carbon v alloy forks or steerers. Re steerers, haven't you answered your own question? if they're hardly any lighter why bother paying 25% more?. Re forks, I have Nukeproof carbon (exactly the same fork I believe) and Salsa Cromo, use them on the same bike, the carbons are a bit more springy and comfortable, I find.

If interested I could also sent you the reciept as well so this might work with the warranty, so your choice, take it or leave it.

Aren't carbon legs a little more forgiving?, aluminium legs will produce a slightly harsher ride.

Get the ones from Daddy and job done! 😉

yep, I'd go for the 2nd hand carbon for a softer ride and lighter bike. They are virtually new and unmarked, so presumably not been rattled down any rocky descents.
BTW I don't think the carbons are fragile, if that's a concern, I've been regularly using mine in the Yorks Dales on rough fast descents, with no problems (so far).

I've had the 26 alloy forks on my rigid commuter/mtb for a year. Weight with uncut steerer was 925g iirc. Ride absolutely fine, I don't find them particularly harsh at all.

If you are talking about legs and not steerers then I would have thought changes in tyre pressure and size would be more noticeable. Big difference on the road but I'm running radial spoked factory wheel, 25mm tyres at 100psi. With a 2.3" tyre at 35psi on a 3 cross wheel I'm not sure the effects would be as great.

Well I do have alloy kinesis rigids (blade type) on my Merlin but am running 26" hybrid tyres (commuter). Completely different design to the basic round tubes ones but you do get all the chatter just like an aluminium frame whereas a carbon frame filters it out.

In order of harshness the general consensus is: Aluminium (harshest), cromoly steel, carbon. But that is with near identical design so it is down to material only.

Given the choice I would ride carbon for comfort and off road performance. Steel for ultimate life and being able to abuse them. Alloy for cost v weight.

Carbon, but dont go looking down the legs as your braking heavy. 🙂

Carbon On-Ones on my 29er. Love them. Add some wide, non oversize carbon bars for added affect.

Ahaaaaaa,
Well now, I rode with some Alu suspension corrected ones (26 inch) for a couple of years (mainly commuting and rough tow path sruff. Thats all I could afford at the time and they worked great.
I then built a 29er and used the forks on it with disc brakes for 3 to 4 months until I replaced them with the carbon 29er version.
I noticed a difference straight away as you can watch the carbon ones flex constantly, smoothing things out a little.
Theres not much difference in price so I'd go with carbon, but the old alu forks are still going strong on my daughters bike.