[Closed] Cane Creek Forty - new bearings or replace?

I quite like CC headsets, so I'd slap a new bearing in it. Pay a little extra and get a stainless one as most headsets seem to eventually succumb to corrosion rather than wear. Bury them in grease too when you fit them - keeps the dreaded moisture away - just make sure it's not somewhere that can attract dirt too.

I've just taken my Cotic apart after a year and the Cane Creek Forty headset was like new.

So I'd just get new bearings if I were you. And ride your bike more, obvs!

Thanks I'll open it up and get some replacements ordered!

The CC 40 on my old Fatbike lasted seven years with one change of bearings (and that saw the very worst conditions imaginable). As far as I know, it's still running the same headset now.

I once put a cane creek 110 headset in my surly long haul trucker. It was expensive at the time. I asked the rep how much replacement bearings were? He replied, no idea, I've never needed to sell a set. He said the 110 stood for years. No idea if it was true but the touring bike was used and abused and it still felt new when I sold it 10 years later. I'd happily have another cane creek headset.

I have a cheap one in my scandal. When I installed it, I used some stringy grease {can't remember the name} but keeps water out. I also strip my bike every 3 or 4 months and clean and regrease. Seems to make stuff last longer.

Replace them with the Cane Creek Hellbender stainless bearings. Mine are halfway through their second winter on my road bike and still super smooth. Or buy a 110 headset as that now has a lifetime warranty that includes bearings!

I've found the orignal CC Forty bearings to be shite for weatherproofing.

Had the same headset on 3 different bikes and it's always the bottom cup bearing that goes after a few months.

Not had the same problem with a Chris King, Hope or Works headset so far.

I've had to replace quite a few standard bearings on these, they aren't up to the job being asked of them. Take one out and have close look at it, and you'll see that the inner joint between the races is unsealed, and thus open to any moisture it's exposed to. It surprises me how they last a typical british summer, let alone a winter.

I had a similar issue on my CC 40 series on my Edit V3. It started creaking after 3 months of riding (top cup).

I took the bearing out and added a bit of grease after teasing the rubber seals off and it's been golden since.

Had one on my old canyon spectral, was the single worst cycling component I've ever had, even worse than crank bros acids! 🤣

Both Cane Creek headsets that I've had, the lower bearings have failed in less than 6 months. They suck in water and rust up. As Coatsey says, the lower seal isn't up to the job.
Replaced the last one with a new sealed bearing from Kinetic Bearings. £11 & poper seals & it's been fine so far.

Replaced both bearings in mine with Hope bearings. The original CC ones died on one particularly wet ride very early in their life. No need to replace the whole headset though… just fit better bearings.

Thanks everyone, good broad spread of answers there! I was getting very tempted by a new hope headset but I figured >£80 for the headset + buying more tools (I'm not doing it with a block of wood and a hammer...) was daft when I could take a punt replacement bearings from Kinetic for £11 as per Phil_H. Also should be far less tool time!

Yeah, the cups are fine, it's the just the rubbish bearings. I need to see what size bearings I need for one I have at the moment.

Replaced the bottom bearing on the one on my Canyon after a couple of months with a 110 bearing - which it was still happily running 5 years later when I retired the frame, so yes - better bearings is the answer!

Headset bearings are a disgraceful failing of bicycle design that car drivers wouldn't tolerate. Most bikes are designed for sunny places like California, not real places like the UK.

Even good quality sealed bearings will fail after weeks stuffed up a head tube, soaked in salty muddy water.