[Closed] Anyone seriously 'overbiked'?

I live in essex and have a heckler. I take the cross bike most times...

I've just got another 9 extra gears....god only knows when I'll use them.

Yep, I own a cross bike, so don't really need a road bike especially as I have spare wheels, also could lose the 26" retro mtb, but it's like driving a classic car, it's an old friend, and the singlespeed 29er, the cross bike can go everywhere it can, and that's without the other 29er which is going to be another singlespeed but could run gears if it wants.

But it's nice to have a choice, and the government aren't taxing bicycles yet, and I like to see them all sat ready to play.

Equation for working is: pays money = more toys.

I have recently been mincing about on an orange five.

Im often amazed at how over biked a lot of bikers are at trail centres but i guess if you ride a mix of knarly stuff and trail centres and can only have one bike then what can you do? My orange ST4 feels like a downhill bike to me when i change to it from my hardtail. It's enough for the majority of things that i ride in Wales.

I successfully circumnavigated the Green route at Swinley on saturday on my 160mm Zesty..... I survived..... Just...... 😉

My orange ST4 feels like a downhill bike to me when i change to it from my hardtail. It's enough for the majority of things that i ride in Wales.

I'm sure one of the mags described the ST4 as the bike the majority of Five owners should have bought.

Yes I ride Woburn most of the time on a yeti asr7. My hummer or my sov are more than enough really and I know it!

Totally and utterly when riding my Scott CR1...

Hahaha oh yeas mmwaaahhahaha. It's not for every day but some days it takes my breath away

I'm frivolously overbiked a lot of the time.

Yep I'm in the east Midlands and my main mtb is a Scott Voltage.. I mainly ride the dh at woburn on it which it feels a bit much for, but its a fun bike to ride so who really cares? I also have a chameleon but if I had to go back to one mtb itd be the voltage.

yup
[img] [/img]

Yup. 5-spot here, which for 90% of my riding is probably "too much". Flippin' great, though. 😀

I've just bought another HT, this one has a Lyrik plugged in the front. 90% of my riding is in the Chilterns, what do you think? 😆

In my defence, it's my only bike

Pretty sure I fit the bill for this. Did my first ever trail on my zesty 714.

Over-biked...possibly. Under-skilled...definitely!

I'm under biked on the climbs

i took my 6inch bouncy bike on an old railway line, could of done it on a road bike!

but still had a great day 😆

it's a bike just ride it in anyway you want 😉

I have suspension forks on my hardtail and more than one gear 😳

At the moment, yes! My Titus is waiting for its forks back from servicing, so I'm riding my local my local woods on my Alpified Heckler, with Marz55's and chunky tyres!!

OP how can a 170/150 bike help you go harder, faster up a hill, it can only make you go slower....so therefore you are over bikes.

I see loads of folk around where I live, and puzzle at where they are riding such rocky, steep decents which favour such bikes.

I even wondered about ditching the 100 x 100 suspension bike when I got a cross bike, and remembered how much fun it is with no suspension etc

Yup.

I don't care either; I love my Rune V2, I enjoy riding it and have fun on it whatever I ride. I even take it to trail centres sometimes. I'm not the fastest person up or down but I'm not the slowest either.

There seems to be a lot of interest in what other people ride, where they ride etc. Who cares if they're having fun and not harming anyone?

Deleted my self gratuitous post

FunkyDunc - Member

OP how can a 170/150 bike help you go harder, faster up a hill, it can only make you go slower....so therefore you are over bikes.

I don't try and go hard/fast uphill, but surprisingly it climbs better than my HT - my Strava times are acceptable, I clean most climbs and keep up with my mates. Maybe it's more bike than I 'need', but I admitted that - for the most it gives me lots of fun though.

mindmap - wasn't criticising anyone, just curious - wouldn't judge anyone for what they choose to ride.

Op - it wasn't aimed at you, more the inevitable barrage of awesomeness that was about to come those who can ride a unicycle blindfolded with no legs past all of these over bikes people at trail centres!

My Rune suits me because I can only justify having one good bike and it needs to do my everyday riding as well as DH days / uplifts etc. if I could afford or justify it, I'd have a DH bike as well as a more sensible trail bike. I may comment on someone having a nice bike but I'd never judge them for having too much or too little bike because I don't know why they're riding that bike. All that matters is that people have fun and enjoy it.

Agreed ^^^^

Every bike I own is too much bike for me. Never mind.

This thread needs pussywillow.

My only mtb is a 100mm forked singlespeed ht. Until my 11 geared, 650b'ed, carbon 160mm fs arrives 😀

I live south of the Watford Gap and have a 160mm AM bike.

But it's very nice.

[quote=tomhoward ]This thread needs pussywillow.
My only mtb is a 100mm forked singlespeed ht. Until my 11 geared, 650b'ed, carbon 160mm fs arrives

Give him time....

I ended up liking the 7 Stanes facebook page, there seem to be heaps taking their DH bikes up for Spooky wood etc. Always saw heaps on big bikes mincing everywhere. But then again there are plenty of overly large unfit people on light as hell XC machines looking like heart attacks waiting to happen.

I dropped back from a heckler to a Blur LTc feels about right, was going to go with the Tr but got the chance on the LT built how I wanted it. I'm looking for a DH bike to balance it out and not hammer then LTc in the local DH series.

If I'm having fun on my chosen bike for that particular days riding then I'm not over biked. I've had my DH bike with me at a BMX track. That was bloody good fun.

First full sus bike I bought was a speccy Enduro in 2005,I think it's 150 mm travel.Was great when I rode it at Morzine & doing some of the 7 stanes.I think the last time I rode it was 2007/8.I bought a 100mm travel Giant nrs in 2007,that's enough travel for my usual trails,I'll keep the Enduro though for the next foreign holiday,it's spent most of its life as a dust collector..

Only time I feel overbiked on my 160mm, coil forked steed...

Wait, is it a steed? Or is it a rig? Make it rig.

...coil forked rig, is when it's got excessively sticky rubber on it. It's absolutely fine for simple stuff the rest of the time, as it's not just a big rockplough, it has a bit of poise and balance. Honestly I think all really good 160mm bikes do, the bad ones give up descending capability for climbing prowess and the OK ones give up a bit of allrounderness for descending.

But excessively sticky tyres, fffffuuuuuuuu

i took my 6inch bouncy bike on an old railway line, could of done it on a road bike!

Same here, it was bloody awful! Probably would've been ok with a proper length seatpost though, my back was killing me by the end of it due to how low the post was.

I know someone who used to often commute ~30 miles round trip on a Brooklyn Race Link!

I am absolutely over biked for the vast majority of my riding. I have an Enduro Evo and a Stumpjumper would have been more than enough for most of the riding I do. It would take a proper battering on DH sessions and the messing around that I like to do. I would rather have the reassurance of a heavier stronger bike than be worried about breaking things all the time. I would almost certainly be faster around most trails on a smaller bike but would I have as much fun? I'm not sure.

"Overbiked" is a concept I don't recognise. Does riding the bike they are on make them happy? Are they having a laugh on it? Then it is the right bike.

It's that simple - can't understand why people need to overthink stuff so much.

[i]I know someone who used to often commute ~30 miles round trip on a Brooklyn Race Link! [/i]

At one point in my life I had five bikes. (I know, I know, but money was tight), so I decided I would cycle into work each day (about 15 miles each way), on each bike in turn.

Monday was fine on the road bike
Tuesday on the cross bike was also fine, fun even.
Wednesday on the Geared mountain bike, fine
Thursday on the singlespeed bike, fine but a little tiring
Friday on the singlespeed jump bike.,,, Mother of god! I thought my legs were going to fall off. So, so tired when I arrived at work but by the time I got home I could barely stand.

It's that simple - can't understand why people need to overthink stuff so much

I find people overthinking harmless questions to come up with smart arsed answers a bigger problem round here to be honest 😉

Did the summer trailquest series on a ridgid scandal this year. Was supprised how relativly easily your could bike in the peak with no suspension, though royce clough had me blinking the third eye when i was carrying to much speed.
Wont be getting rid of the 5 spot with 150 36's yet..

Overbiked, yes.

Care, no 🙂 if I'm really worried I can swap tyres, drop fork travel, and raise the seatpost, for less gnar.

Yes when i bought my five am i thought ill only do it once so got everything big then itl last longer so yup usualy way over biked 80% of the time but im really not arsed 😀

over the years indeed, 160mm travel bikes liked them all, some like turner rfx original version titus supermoto climbed better than some xc bikes I have owned.....the titus over a 10mile circuit was quicker than my yeti asr sl......faster and safer on the downs so made up loads of time.

These bikes allowed me to ride with a knackered back when a hartail would have meant giving up

ridden up col de perysoude/port de bales/superbargnes on a Maverick ml8...all good fun

enjoyed them all now on a 120/95 mm 29er and still overbiked 😀

Ride and enjoy

I keep selling 140/150mm travel bikes and buying something shorter but keep ending up with a 140mm bike again, just put a 150mm for on my stumpjumper so definitely over biked again but won't be following the urge for a 120mm bike as it won't be any lighter

never happy

Absolutely
An Orange Five SE and I keep both wheels on the floor mincing round the downs. A hard tail would be more than enough but I don't care