You don't need to be an 'investor' to invest in Singletrack: 6 days left: 95% of target - Find out more
I want to buy a bench vise for the shed to use exclusively for bike-related tasks e.g. pressing in / out shock bushings, shock suspension work, wheels and hub maintenance etc. Can't decide on the size though - 4" / 100mm one or get a slightly larger 5" / 125mm? STW - what would you recommend?
Depends on budget, better a decent quality 100mm one than a cheapo 125mm that'll crack after a few years.
Axminster do a 125mm jobbie for £220 that we use at work and has been rock solid so far despite hard daily usage.
I'd say the smaller one but either will be fine. You never need to be anywhere near capacity. You also don't need anything particularly precise. A second hand decent make is the way to go
Have I stumbled into a parallel universe where a man is asking is he purchase a smaller or larger vice? Of course you want the large one, nay, the largest. And an Anvil to go with it.
This is one of them bot threads that was mentioned earlier isn't it.
*reports to mods.
125mm that’ll crack after a few years.
I would be impressed if the OP managed that pressing in bike bearings...
NB I just tap mine in with a hammer and never use the vice for it.
Benchmaster do really solid vices that are not crazy money - https://www.benchmaster.uk/product/bench-vice-and-bases. We use them in our workshops and have no issues.
Look out on Gumtree/FB Marketplace for used vices.
I picked up a Record no5 and no6 (proper old ones too) in great condition for £15 each.
Always bigger and attached to something incredibly solid.
I bought one of the MacAllister ones from B&Q.
I've hammered the **** out of it, crushed hard things in it and genberally done things that would probably make a D&T teacher wince and it's not cracked. The only bit that's broken is the handle end fell off when I tried to use it as a drift.....
The spinning on it's base feature is a godsend in a small shed. Means you can spin whatever it is to a more useful angle when required if you don't have access to all sides of your workbench.
I thought I'd wandered into an alternate reality - surely even the [I]suggestion[/I] that you might consider purchasing a [b]new[/b] vice gets you perma-banned from STW??Have I stumbled into a parallel universe
seek absolution here:
https://singletrackmag.com/forum/topic/mcmoontertrackworld-vices/
Grab a used Record from these folks, bigger's usually better eh?!
I have a small 4" I got from Screwfix, it's been fine.
The 'just get a 2nd hand one' advice seems to have aged a bit, I was after one about a year ago and everything local was either deeply buggered or not far off the same price as a decent new one.
I blame this place and 'lockdown projects'
Obviously I imagine there's massive variation depending on locality and down here in the soft South things are scarce whereas in God's own county the roads are practically paved with the damn things.
Here is a good one.
www.ebay.co.uk/itm/186406133355
Made in England.
I use an old iron clamped in the vice upside down for a hammering anvil.
Good price.
https://gandmtools.co.uk/product/record-imp-bench-vice-80215931/
These were designed as a motor mechanics vice.
Handy vice, as you can take outside and clamp to an outside bench. Includes a small anvil.
(Did not know about G & M tools.......tool heaven......)
I've got my dad's record No1 from the 70s. It's bloody ace.
Also have an antique mobile vice, bit fiddly but excellent for outdoor use on the workmate or on a scaffold. It's a Stanley, probably 50 years plus old.
4" is a decent size for this stuff, 5" you're looking at it handling larger clamps and blocks which i don't think bikes have as much off. The thing that'll be more important is the workbench/table you're attaching it too, it needs to be a decent lump with room and strength to manage any harsh usage, you can find cheap vices on facebook marketplace, ebay, etc, but a solid workbench, they're always either overpriced and expensive everywhere you look.
I bought one of these recently for bike stuff - seems plenty big / strong enough. First job was clamping an airshaft to get the piston off / fit a Luftkappe. Worked perfectly. I also bought some soft jaws for it that are magnetic that should come in handy too.
It isn’t wildly expensive either which helped swing it.